user
Stuffed Ice Cream
139 1st Avenue, New York, NY 10003, United States
Appearance
Stuffed Ice Cream
Comments
sa
Review №1

Stuffed is an excellent place to go!! Stuffed has fun flavors in a great location! When I was there I got the “Thai Kwon Dough” and I highly recommend it! I am not a coffee ice cream eater but I would definitely get it again. Even if you come to Stuffed hungry, you will leave.. well… STUFFED! I went with my family and they both got Cookie Monster with Cookie dough ice cream and they loved it! Awesome place!

Jo
Review №2

Got a “cruff” made with Cookie Monster ice cream, Fruity Pebbles, and Captain Crunch, all inside a donut. It was delicious, aesthetically pleasing, and super fun!

Se
Review №3

What an interesting fusion. Having a donut and inside an ice cream.The fusion works and tastes amazing.They have several flavours which go beyond the regular known ones. I had cookie monster and red velvet. As a topping I took crunched Oreo and captain crunch. A great combination of all the flavours.

Am
Review №4

Looks cool, but not really worth it

Review №5

Really good flavors! The only bad thing is that they we no tables and chairs to rest.

Ja
Review №6

The service was very slow, apparently you can only get one flavor per pint, I wasnt giving a bag, ice pack or anything like that for my to go order so didnt really get to enjoy the pint of ice cream that I purchased because it was melted and majority spilled all in my personal carry bag. I was very disappointed in the overall experience. Will stick to my frozen yogurt shops.

Sa
Review №7

I think this place is overrated!!! It’s just all for Instagram,on Saturday July 31st we went there and saw the guys struggling to make 10 scoops! I would have change my mind when I saw them struggling but I wanted to try it and that was how mess up the ice cream were, looks nothing like the pic on their Instagram and the store doesn’t even look clean! A very small tight space! Ordered for the 10 scoops and as soon as they gave it to me, before I could get a good pic the whole stuff fell apart! When the other ladies waiting to order saw how rough it was, they all said they won’t be getting more than 3 scoops since the guys are struggling 🙄 I won’t be back and oh the ice cream wasn’t that good, too many food coloring! Try the ice cream store next door and the customer service plus taste was awesome! Stuffed ice cream is overrated!!!

Va
Review №8

Delicious! The combination of a donut and the ice cream is very interesting. We shared one as a dessert and it was still enough. Never had that before. Worth trying!

co
Review №9

Trendy ice cream spot, but a bit overpriced. I was planning on asking for 21 scoops, but prices were more expensive than I expected!

Da
Review №10

Me: Gotta work out and eat healthyAlso me: Yeah.. Umm, can I get a cinnamon toast crunch ice cream stuffed donut? With Oreos & chocolate fudge 🥴.I visit often. Love this place!

Ge
Review №11

Great ice cream and donuts! Very clean, and very fast service!

em
Review №12

Good ice-cream. Tasty flavors.

AD
Review №13

Customer service is one of the main reasons I leave reviews and it was amazing here! The guy that was working there on 3/2/20 was very cool and calm. While I was taking a picture for the review I dropped my ice cream 😂and he replaced it for me 🙏🏾The flavors are good a few of the items were sold out when we got there though.I will be coming back.

Go
Review №14

Gosh, it was yummy 😋 really liked it. Still in covid situation there was huge amount of people. Like ice cream taste

Jo
Review №15

Great place to get stuffed ice cream. I walked out with the desert and even another person said OMG stuffed ice cream. I loved that experience.

Ge
Review №16

Good place.. but very small and they dont have all the flavors all the time.

Ra
Review №17

Girl named Sofiyuh was very nice and cordial fast with my order no problems highly recommend would come back again.

Mi
Review №18

Came here for the Cookie Monster & Tea Party signature cruffs. Absolutely worth it! They stuff your GLAZED bun & give you all the works along with it! The price is reasonable & staff is so helpful & patient. Definitely coming back for hot summer days!

Mo
Review №19

Excellent ice cream as always. Go for a cruff with any combination of scoops and gummy bears on top and youll thank me!

Va
Review №20

Best cookies monster ice cream ! Stuffed in a glazed donuts, it just cant get better. Had that over a festival during the summer and went back in their store to get some more.Price is good and pleasure it there. Hoping theyll open other location !

Sa
Review №21

Great service but they have limited options for vegan. You can build your own stuffed ice cream.

Do
Review №22

Got the Cookie Road cruff (substituted caramel instead of fudge) and it was da bomb! After a long day in the city it was just what I needed for dessert. Never had anything like it so it was a unique experience and I will definitely be back. Not too sweet or anything the perfect balance of everything. I recommend this unique and delicious dessert spot to anyone in the area!

Ad
Review №23

Ice cream is so delicious and smooth. One of the best. Plus the donut its set between was fluffy and a perfect snack afterwards

Ri
Review №24

This place has some unbelievable Donut stuffed ice creams. We went there after a Sunday brunch to celebrate a friends birthday with their Birthday Cake flavor donut ice cream sandwiches. Mouth watering-ly delicious 🙀

Ir
Review №25

Came here twice, once preCOVID and once during COVID. The customer service here is okay. The ice cream though is really great. I tried the 12 scoop bouquet lol it made a huge mess but it was nice. The staff gave us a precautionary plate to make sure we didn’t spill anything. Def going back for more of the Cookie Monster ice cream.

Gr
Review №26

Definitely some novelty value, not as sweet as I feared.

Sa
Review №27

It was pretty good! The girls behind the counter were awkward, not sure why they were a bit unfriendly.

Ed
Review №28

It’s a cute place to go and the their ice cream flavors are good too

Yo
Review №29

Great tasting ice cream. Even the vegan mango colada was delicious. What a unique combination with the donut. All flavors are unique looking.I didnt like that there were only two people working, so the tables that are there were filthy.

S
Review №30

We passed by this place on my way downtown. The location is nice but it could be cleaner. staff was helpful and they were nice for the most part. The flavors of ice cream were unique but werent all that. The lavender ice cream tastes artificial. Presentation was sloppy but the donut is very tastey and the prices were good.The neon sign is cool but then when you walk in theres pictures up of alot of instgram famous people who have frequented their location its seems desperate and lame something much more creative could have been used to add to the ambiance of the establishment. Over all it was good but they miss the mark in terms of quality and details.

Ol
Review №31

I like to consider myself an ice cream connoisseur. The ice cream was really creamy and rich but not overly sweet. I had the lavender white chocolate (purple ice cream), which was surprisingly really good. Very rich on the lavender (hence the name) - I think it’s an acquired taste for immature taste buds but sweet and delicate nonetheless. The other flavor was the Cinnamon Toast Crunch. I think that was a bit of a let down. Considering Cinnamon Toast Crunch is favorite cereal. When I say let down, I was expecting a much more infused flavor - more so crunch to ice cream with a smooth milky rush. The cruff (doughnut) is very flaky and not too sweet. It reminds of of a Cronut (donut x croissant). The combination would be much better if the cruff comes a bit warm. I didn’t ask for it to be warmed - but I think you should ask when you go there. If you’re into a warm “bun-ish melty ice cream dessert”.

to
Review №32

Crispy and fluffy doughnut filled with lashings of funky colored tasty cookie dough monster ice cream. Located in the heart of East village, so a great place to enjoy a spot of people watching on a sunny day while you eat.

Ol
Review №33

Donut + weird ice cream flavors = a big win in my book. I cant complain it was simple and enjoyable. Will go back if Im in the neighborhood.

co
Review №34

Me and my boyfriend uber there just to get ice cream, there was a little line but we don’t mind the wait. We had the signature ones.

Ad
Review №35

Nice variety of ice cream flavors. Ice cream puffs are great.Red velvet is a must try.

Mi
Review №36

Wait was long but the ice cream was great. Would probably only come here once or twice a year though. Seems like a bit much to be a regular patron, but definitely worth a try.

sh
Review №37

Ice cream was great...tasted fresh and the cone was also great tasting...I will be back again

Re
Review №38

Sometimes the doughnuts are really yummy and soft and sometimes they arent. Definitely not consistent. Overall, its worth a try

Cl
Review №39

Friendly service...they want you to sample their flavors. My 2nd visit here and the variety of flavors will certainly satisfy quite a few people.

ki
Review №40

Unbelievable how good this combination of cereal and ice cream can be. Add a donut and it feel like a slice of indulgent heaven. Trust me its a place you want to go at least once in your life so you inner child can be happy with your adult decisions

Sh
Review №41

Wow! The thing I love about traveling when you are from a small Midwestern city is finding amazing or innovative concoctions that havent reached your tiny part of the country yet. Like ice cream stuffed doughnuts?? Why dont they have this in Dayton?? I didnt actually get one, my friend did and she said it was amazing and worth every bite of diabetic inducing carbohydrates. I got the fruity pebbles ice cream in a blue corn cone. The ice cream was like everything I wanted as a kid but could still appreciate as an adult. The cone tasted like corn flakes straight out of the box. In other words - yummy and comforting. A lot of the ice creams have a kids cereal theme. The associates were super friendly too!

Ki
Review №42

Cool concept, but there are so many better donuts out there. This one was a little dry. Ice cream was really good. They have very unique flavors.

Sa
Review №43

This place was good. Ice cream was good. The doughnut was good.Took of two stars for the following reasons:1. The portion wasn’t as big as I thought it would be from their advertising. It felt a little overpriced.2. The person who helped us wasn’t the warmest.Besides that, it was all good.

An
Review №44

Ice Cream in a doughnut?! Love this spot. They have so many great flavors and toppings. Our favorite is the Cinnamon toast crunch ice cream with Captain crunch topping. Depending on your sweet tooth, sharing 1 is pretty filling.

Gh
Review №45

Cool new idea with in-house made ice cream!

Ra
Review №46

Great place and friendly owner. Fun concept with some nice ice creams. They had Thai ice tea and lavender vanilla!! Cool place

ti
Review №47

Delicious donut ice cream sandwiches. Cool varieties of ice cream and toppings. Nice size portions.

Ky
Review №48

Excellent Ice-cream, Sub-Par Donut. Pass on the Cruff until they fix that Donut issue.

Gu
Review №49

I absolutely love this ice cream shop! They have the most interesting flavors, such as, Thia iced tea, white chocolate lavender (my fav), and cinnamon toast crunch. I once got a ice cream cake made there and as you can see from the pic it was amazing and a great hit at the party! @traveleen_gurl

Es
Review №50

I LOOOOVE THIS PLACES!!!I tasted fruity pebbles, birthday cake (ice cream & come) vainilla & Cinnamon Toast Crunch. I still can’t decide wish is my fav

Le
Review №51

Interesting flavors, loved the cookie monster !

Ru
Review №52

Nice collection of ice cream. Not too costly too. They have good service.

Ch
Review №53

I tried the limited edition CBD Cookies and Cream ice cream. It definitely had a unique floral flavor which I did not expect and was super thick. Overall, a decent ice cream.The staff gets mixed reviews, there was one young lady there that was very unfriendly almost making me not want to buy the ice cream but the young male staff member that was there was gracious and kind.I would definitely love to return to try the Thai Iced Thea in the donut as opposed to the cup.

Ol
Review №54

In love with this place. A great after performance snack. Wish they had more chocolate options.

Mi
Review №55

I loved the Unicorn Poop ice cream, although I think eating any of their stuffed ice cream can get messy. I havent seen this where I came from but I would recommend this item as I already knew what to expect from other flavors like vanilla and chocolate.

Ne
Review №56

These ice cream sandwiches are huge and very good. I liked the tea flavours and the cookie is great

Na
Review №57

Super good got the cereal based one

Te
Review №58

If you think cronuts are inventive, you need to try donuts and ice cream. The ice cream was creamy and balanced, and the donut was flaky and delicious. The right balance of textures and sweetness!

An
Review №59

Very interesting flavours!!! I wanted to go to the place since I arrived to New York, unfortunately the atmosphere in the place took a star away as the place definitely needs a nice renovation. Other then that, the staff was very nice and lots flavours to choose from 💜

Ar
Review №60

Initially skeptical due to the massive line of teenagers daily, but I should have known better. The kids know whats up! Providing a sugar-rush with the weight of a Ford F150 pickup truck, this is a dessert overhaul for your blood sugar. Sticky, drippy coffee ice-cream smushed to the insides of a glazed donut mashed together with almonds and condensed milk. Get there early because they do sell out of most of their flavors. Worth the hype.

Br
Review №61

Reallllly yummy ice cream! I didn’t get the donut sandwich but just the regular ice cream itself was worth coming for. They had a variety of unique flavors my friend got rice Krispy ice cream and I got a red velvet cookie dough ice cream. Really loved the amount to choose from. And they provide a couple of tables for sitting. Will be back!

an
Review №62

The donut ice cream was delicious.

Yu
Review №63

Donuts were stale. The Ube ice cream was a NEON purple - it was way too much artificial food coloring.

Gr
Review №64

Cookie Monster & almond pistachio ice cream are delicious

Ni
Review №65

Was just exploring and walking around with a friend and we accidentally stumbled among this place. Heard it was super popular and everyone loves it. Went inside got the Unicorn donut (cant remember the exact name). Ice cream was pretty good, unique flavors that are very creamy, lavender and thai tea. Butttt the donut.... it was very dry and blocked out the authentic taste of the ice creams with a store brand cheap tasting piece of sugary bread, I was so grateful I had water. I personally recommend it for their ice cream and nothing more. Maybe Ill change my mind if I go back

Am
Review №66

Got there at 9:40, waited on line with everybody else once it was my turn it had just hit 9:59 and the owner says they are closed and that they cannot take me. I was the last person on line ...

Ma
Review №67

A delicious decadence, but I was not aware the extent to which my teeth would be blue/green and my fingers would be dirty. They’d be well advised to add some kind of water (maybe a fountain) or hand sanitizer.

Ni
Review №68

Had a great experience at this ice cream shop. Theu had cool new ice cream flavors and cool donut stuff ice cream sandwiches. We got the cookie monster and loved it.

Er
Review №69

Came here during their grand opening when they were doing BOGO promo. I got the blueberry cheesecake and while it tasted good, there were frozen chunks of blueberry that were too hard to bite into. The serving size of a cruff was a bit disappointing for the price.

Ad
Review №70

The ice cream was phenomenal. I love the ice cream donut combo. The employees were friendly, and knowing that the ice cream and nuts, the employee asked if we have any but allergy. Thats what you call excellent customer service.

Ri
Review №71

So good! Had this place on my list to go to for a while and was not disappointed at all!

Au
Review №72

Such a cute place. Amazing dessert spot. Definitely an insta worth experience. I got the stuffed donut it was amazing. Try the weird flavors theyre the best. And the donut is the best part TRUST ME HERE

va
Review №73

The donut and ice cream combo is the best thing to satisfy a strong sweet craving. The donut is a bit tough and would rather it be fluffy, but it was pretty good coming from an ice cream shop.

Ca
Review №74

Best place for a sweet tooth. Recommend for donut sandwich fanatics and ice cream lovers.

Dy
Review №75

Awesome and creative ice cream flavors with a tasty and fun twist. A great treat anytime of the year

Mi
Review №76

The best ice scream I have ever had. The doughnuts were perfectly cooked. Their cake cone actually tastes like cake. I love this place

He
Review №77

They did what dunkin donuts shoulda done ages ago. I LOVED the glazed donut but only LIKED the icecream. Overall, it was decently priced for the amount they served.

Ma
Review №78

So many different flavors and they let you taste test as many as you want! I got ricr krispies + birthday cake. My friends got the cruff (donut + icecream) with thai iced tea icecream flavor but I went with a cone. Good prices and even some tables to sit and eat there. Soo much sugar though - be prepared.

Ma
Review №79

Delicious first experience; staff could of been more warm and patient being that it was our first time there, it was absolutely empty and we were def ordering.At last, those #Cruff was so yummy! Couldn’t finish it but they have to go packaging available 😝 also a plus they met you sample the ice cream. No bathroom. 12 seats.

Ka
Review №80

I am beyond happy with this place!! It was the most amazing ice cream experience Ive ever had. It was magical and so yummy. The ice cream was Ferera Rocher flavored 💜💜 so good!!

Fr
Review №81

Such an amazing experience tonight thank you to the young man that helped my boyfriend and I tonight I didnt catch his name but his customer service was amazing! Made my valentines day perfect thank you!

Je
Review №82

Really good

Li
Review №83

Loved the cookie monster ice cream but the donut was dry.

Me
Review №84

Nice ice cream and donuts ice cream

Fa
Review №85

Ice cream just okay. But too much food coloring, its good for photo though.

Sa
Review №86

They were out of doughnuts so the cashier told us to come back in 2 hours. We waited and went back, then he said 30 mins so we waited again and called once 30 mins went by. The cashier told us he’d have doughnuts in a couple of hours....... safe to say there was never any doughnuts being made. Disappointed and won’t be coming back.

Ke
Review №87

Awesome varieties of ice cream, perfectly soft donuts, and awesome aesthetic desserts!

Ma
Review №88

It was delicious, and customer service was great!

K
Review №89

Great ice cream, good service. Tiny place, but worth the wait. I wish they didnt run out of flavors I want to try, but otherwise great!

Ma
Review №90

I’m totally not impressed with this place. I’m a foodie that travels all over looking for desserts, I finally tried this place and the chick on the register had NO personality, it’s like dealing with a brick, the donut was dry and stale, plus the ice cream wasn’t good at all. NEVER AGAIN!!

Cx
Review №91

The ice cream was very tasty. Their signature dish, The Cruff was amazing. The taste was very sweet, but not too sweet to the point of sour. The people who served us were very nice and had very good manners compared to some other people... Anyways this place is amazing.10-10

Ki
Review №92

Good Ice cream place! But customer service isnt friendly at all. Definitely going back for more Ice cream.

Em
Review №93

If youre looking for good ice cream, this place is just okay. The ice cream is not homemade and tastes like conventional supermarket ice cream. It looks pretty and is more for Instagram. The East Village has a lot of better options.

K.
Review №94

Vietnamese Coffee ice cream was yummy!

Ra
Review №95

Try the cruffs - 2 flavours of ice-cream - Thai ice tea and lychee with mochi or almond toppings - stuffed between warm soft glazed donuts! Come here just for the cruffs.

Av
Review №96

A pretty penny for your ice cream. Try to come before 7pm to get your choice of all the flavors as they sell out fast. Not much room to sit.

Sh
Review №97

Do yourself a favor and try this place. The service was very welcoming and observant. This place has a nice design.

Ki
Review №98

Unique dessert place. Super tasty.

ba
Review №99

For my first time it was delicious

Lo
Review №100

Ice cream was really good. The cruff was good, but really messy

Information
100 Photos
100 Comments
4.5 Rating
  • Address:139 1st Avenue, New York, NY 10003, United States
  • Site:https://stuffedicecreamnyc.com/
  • Phone:+1 917-985-6166
Categories
  • Ice cream shop
Working hours
  • Monday:4–10PM
  • Tuesday:2–10PM
  • Wednesday:2–10PM
  • Thursday:4–10PM
  • Friday:4–10PM
  • Saturday:4–10PM
  • Sunday:4–10PM
Service options
  • Takeout:Yes
  • Dine-in:No
Highlights
  • Great dessert:Yes
Planning
  • Quick visit:Yes
Payments
  • NFC mobile payments:Yes
Similar organizations