I don’t much care for ice cream but the flavors here are pretty fantastic. The strawberry jam actually tastes like strawberry jam. The toasted coconut and chocolate was excellent and tasted like genuine coconut and chocolate. Service was exceptional. He was cheerful and quick to service us.

Cute decor, friendly staff. I love the vibe & the natural lighting. I didnt try the ice cream but I did see they had vegan options! The coffee is pretty good here & I love the packaging of the cups. Definitely worth a visit!

Friendly staff. Wonderful service. In the photo the top flavor is Miso Cherry and the one under is Burnt Marshmallow.The Miso Cherry is amazing, having that wonderful hit of sweet and salty without it being overly in either direction.The Burnt Marshmallow has amazing burnt flavor as if the marshmallows themselves were done over a campfire. It isnt overly sweet as you would expect this flavor to be.

Good matcha and great ice cream. Also several kinds of cold brew coffee. Has a 50s ice cream parlor feel, but much more comfortable.

Good tasting..different flavors..a lil pricey...

Enjoyed my cafe liégois (ice cream sundae with a shot of espresso), and my mocha. Coffee was very high quality. If I come back to NY I will definitely stop here. I recommend it very highly.

Delicious coffee crunch ice cream - the chocolate waffle cone was pretty tasty as well, but not necessarily worth an extra $1!

Pretty good ice cream and bright atmosphere and decent coffee. Small quick visit place on Houston street.

Amazing. I love this place so much.

Hey guys, I am from Germany and I was visiting New York around February 20.I just want to say that i’ve had the feeling that some people in different services (shopping-Bank etc.) are not really good in there jobs. Honestly I felt a kind of depressed.But then, i’ve dropped by @this store Oddfellows / fellows 55 e houston st new york and I’ve got the best service ever😀The guy at the service was very friendly I felt like it’s an old friend and the coffee was just perfectSo this is the story I tell my friends in Germany because it was really a lightning moment between grey and darkTHANK YOU !

Amazing ice cream and coffee options. Burnt marshmallow and Thai iced tea are my favorites. They also offer lactaid pills for sale as well. ☺️😉

Clean and bright. Good soft serve ice cream in unique flavors.

Super cute spot with delicious coffee.

It was so fresh. I look forward to a return visit. Prices were good for how much you get. They have a lot of good reviews for a reason.

This is one of the best soft served ice creams 🍦 odd fellows served a lemon zest 🍋 soft served ice cream. I love this place but sometimes the staff can be a little rude when the place gets busy. [ratings:] 👍10/10

The strawberry jam and matcha rock flavor made my day.

I was enjoying my thai tea icecream so much that I rushed to take this photo before I demolish the whole thing. Would definitely come back for this. I cannot wait to try their other flavours.

Tried the pina colada ice cream. Its delicious but the portion is a bit small.

To start the place is very cute and easy to find on the street. I had their flat white and it was smooth and taste good. They have interesting ice cream flavors. The Buttermilk Blueberry is devine. This place is worth a visit.

Good place to go I enjoyed the ice cream kinda pricey but youll find something youll like!!

Great ice cream great flavors, I felt a little bad cuz at first I tried three different flavors before I pick the one I really wanted. but the person was so nice behind the counter that she even offered me a scoop of vanilla to help clear my palate so that way I could better taste the different flavors

OddFellows has some super sweet, super rich ice cream. The flavors are different, and some are better than others. I really enjoyed the Burnt Marshmallow and the Miso Cherry flavors, however the pricing makes it a once in a while treat. Come at least once, just to try it! Staff are super friendly and accommodating. Seating is limited, so mostly a take out ice cream parlour.

How do I vote “strawberry and olive oil” to be a PERMANENT flavor? —asking for the world, ok THANKS.The last 2 times I got off the Subway for an ice cream pit stop, I left disappointed cause all the flavors sucked — it’s really turning me away as a customer. Can you please make a consistent menu ??

Corner location with big windows gives a lovely, bright ambience that invites you to come in and return. Ive tried the pastries, espresso, sorbet and more here. Overall, its as good as a fancy coffee shop in SOHO should be, with prices to match. Their pastries feel just slightly overpriced for what they are (I eat pastries daily), and by the end of day they certainly taste end of day. That being said, there arent a ton of places you can get pastries within a two block radius so its better than nothing. I almost gave 3 stars because one morning I walked over excited to get a smoothie but they were out of it.

Try the toasted sesame nutella!

Dipped in here while my better half was trying stuff on at REÍ and discovered a hidden gem. Their chocotorta ice cream was fantastic, and their cold brew punchy, yet smooth. Staff were super friendly, though keep in mind you’re in SoHo when it comes to prices. If you’re in the neighborhood and want good coffee or great iced cream, check this out.

One of my favorite ice cream shops. The staff knows your name and are supper friendly. It is a great spot to just hang out and drink coffee as well

I only had some coffee in this whimsical ice parlor, but enjoyed watching my friends devour their ice cream. The space is small, but super clean and the staff was nice. I will certainly come back for a cone.

Amazing Ice Cream! Card onlyThey are Cashless!

Great ice cream, unfortunately no vegan options were available on the day I visited. They also have Kombucha on tap which is pretty cool. Staff was AWESOME! Id go back just for them.

Two of the best ice cream scoops Ive had in my life were served here. Really, really, really good ice cream. Get the specials. The service was friendly too, so feel free to sample a bit of everything. Theyll serve it with a smile.

High quality coffee! Nice selection of traditional coffee shop drinks and obviously great ice cream

Amazing ice cream, with very friendly and helpful staff. The flavors they have here are unusual and tasty!

I got their cold brew milkshake, it was so so. Nothing special.

Good black coffee and great ice cream. Pear Walnut Caramel is fantastic and they do a decent serving per scoop. Cashless store too, which is a positive to me.

Good ice cream - many unique flavors like burnt marshmallow, matcha rocky road, malted maitake mushroom peanut (I love mushrooms and malt but didnt dare try them together...), Etc. They ran out of chocolate when we were there around 6pm. This location also has coffee and kombucha on tap. Theres decent seating too.

Fun and interesting flavors that are constantly in rotation, cool space, and mega bonus sustainability points; they use reusable spoons for sampling!!!

Oddfellows is just so delicious! I love the unique small batch flavors they create like “Thai iced tea” or “matcha rocky road” quality is superb every time!

Excellent and interesting ice cream flavors. I just wish they had more dairy free options.

Unique subtle flavors, including the cones. I will return!

Delicious and interesting flavors. Nice staff. Can’t go wrong!

Nice and clean little store, really nice staff. Ice cream was delicious and the flavors were indeed unique.

WOW!!! We were blown away by how wonderful--and wonderfully tasty and unique--the ice cream and treats at this spot were. We had been baking away on Mulberry Street, dodging the wild and unruly crowd on the raucous last day of the 93rd Feast of San Gennaro---and were thrilled to retreat and find refuge at Oddfellows...que perfecto!!!!

Cozy place. Great service. Ice cream is always delicious

Amazing ice cream, delicious coffee, great service, friendly staff!

Just solid all around shop, good ice cream good coffee and reasonable prices.

Always welcomed with smile by very friendly stuff! And ice cream is so amazing!

The Miso Cherry icecream was a miss. Nearly a grainy texture and the cherries were squishy with not a ton of flavour. Really sad. Also the peanut butter and grape softserve consistency was horrible! The grape melted, but the peanut butter didnt. So there was a pool of sticky purple at the bottom of the bowl, and was just such a disappointment.

Reminded me of Berthillion in Paris and if you ever been you know......

We stumbled on this place while heading up town. Delightful staff and delicious ice cream!

Amazing options including two vegan flavors. Pink lemonade and lime tarragon, very refreshing on a warm day.

Got a coffee crunch affogato and a drip coffee. Both sweet, simple, and delightful. Would come back!

Tasty treats and nice people! Note to self, though: next time, no chocolate pearls! Or only if I order a cup instead of a cone. Most of the pearls ended up on the floor. Oopsie.

Great ice cream, albeit some offbeat flavors.

Excellent hot latte and really good ice cream. But the neighborhood prices, a small latte and a very tiny scoop of ice cream = $9.50. Also, they dont take cash, which I have never seen before, but that is ok. So, all in all, the quality of the stuff is good, the cost - overpriced.

Completely uninspiring flavor choices. Mostly just vanilla and strawberry based flavors.

This place makes the best, smoothest ice cream. My current favorite.

Great out of the way ice cream and coffee shop with unique flavors

Have to come check this new location out. Wont be disappointed. Cheers

Nice coffee and very good service.

Friendly staff, great ambiance with really good ice cream,pastry and coffee. No cash thought.

Good coffe and really good icecream

Coffee here is better than most of the coffee shops in Manhattan

Great ice cream served by friendly staff

Coffee crunch was delicious! Thai iced was spot on!

Expensive but delicious ice creams. Creative flavors with great mouth feel in small batches.

Very good for breakfast,amaerican coffe and sweet

Tasty cold brew, fun and friendly service :)

Love this place! Highly recommend the wafflegato!!!

As good as it gets!

Good ice cream.

Lime and basil soft serve is crazy good

Excellent Ice Cream, Great Choices, nothing really plain!

Delicious icecream flavors

Very good service and coffee is the best

No vegan ice cream options available as advertised.

If you havent tried their Thai ice tea ice cream, then you gotta go!

The one-size cappuccino is too small for me.

Matcha rocky road wow

No cash a 1st for me the latte my 1st also was great

PB&J is soooo good!

The food was good

Wonderful Ice Cream ...what an experience😋

Good ice cream but pretentious

I love it!

Not bad at all

Nice place

Too small inside.

Not impressed.

Yummy

Wonderful place

OK tasting, but small, cappuccino.

Yum

Very delicious ice creams made with real fruits. Very comfortable prices. I would come back for more

Very atmospheric place, delicious ice cream