user
The Comfort Diner
214 E 45th St, New York, NY 10017, United States
Appearance
The Comfort Diner
Comments
Ad
Review №1

Huge omelets, good coffee, very attentive staff. Outdoor seating available.

Gr
Review №2

Amazing chicken wings (real spicy) and the hamburger was incredible! That meat was one of the best I have tried!!! Recommend!!!Also the place amazing vintage, the price is fair!

Ke
Review №3

This diner opened thirty years ago near the United Nations and has never ceased to disappoint. The menu is familiar but the quality is otherworldly. The food is sophisticated takes on American standard cuisine and has been re-engineered to be an American cultural mecca. As a true culinary Ambassador for a much maligned cuisine it serves to remind the world that the USA has some cuisine worth respecting. Furthermore, the prices are not bad either and are commensurate with other diners in other boroughs, which is miraculous for a Turtle Bay location. Decor evokes a standard 50s Airstream diner. Excellent food and service. This is where we go to hide from the UN.

Yo
Review №4

At first, i was kind of skeptical. I had never been here before, but let me tell you! It was soooo good! The chicken club was amazing, fries freshly fried! Amazing

Sk
Review №5

Delicious! We ordered the lumberjack subbed out the pancakes for waffle + added fruit, and a side of grits. Our service was great, awesome atmosphere and the food hit the perfect spot for some good old fashioned home cooked feelings. You won’t be disappointed!

Br
Review №6

Solid showing, very tasty red flannel hash w roasted sweet potato and beets. A tad bland on its own, but a few dashes of salt fixed that.

N
Review №7

Their breakfast is amazing! The portions are HUGE and the prices are definitely worth it. There were 14 people in our party so the employees seated us outside. The outdoor seating was an enclosed shelter like deal. My only concern was that we were sitting in the street.

Re
Review №8

Nice staff and family oriented diner. I ordered a broccili, bacon, and cheese omelet (The BBC) with potatoes and toast. Pretty filling and a good spot to go to for breakfast.

Do
Review №9

Expensive. Small selection. I am sure it is due to COVID. The seating nice though.

Su
Review №10

The food is consistently good here. Everything that a diner should have is on the menu. Good coffee w refills. I am glad they are still open. Outdoor seating available.

Me
Review №11

Great food & great people. Loved the breakfast so much we went back the next day. The Red Flannel Hash was amazing!

Ca
Review №12

Service was fantastic and food came quick. Steak and eggs isnt a menu item id recommend though. Steak was very tough and bland.

Ma
Review №13

We were seated quickly, but the drinks and food took sooooo long to get to our table. Food seems like something they just throw together and bam! It’s a dish all of a sudden. Also, there was a hair in my drink. Terrible, but cheap so I guess it works for some people.

Ti
Review №14

Great breakfast spot within walking distance from my hotel. The portions were generous and the food was delicious.

Ai
Review №15

Nicest staff and such amazing food. Delighted to see them back open!

Be
Review №16

I went to the diner yesterday (07/26/2021) after a doctors visit right around lunch time. The place was pretty empty and I was able to choose my own place to sit. I ordered and the food came pretty fast. I noticed a young family with a sick child 2 tables over. They had lunch, the kid was jumping around despite the obvious illness. A few more people walked in and we all smiled at the kid. The waitress, Alex, was on her phone for a while which I thought was strange. The family with the child left, I noticed that they did not pay. I asked the waitress why that was. She explained to me that the kid was sick and needed medical attention, so to ease the burden she gave them a free meal. I was taken back !!!! Turns out that she was on the phone with a medical office because of her daughter needing help. This place goes out of their way, they feed the homeless for Thanksgiving (Saw that on their Facebook page), they pay it forward. So, when you get there, pay for an extra coffee or an extra meal and have them give it to someone in need. We need more places like this, BRAVO !!!! I WILL be back !!!!

Em
Review №17

I was super excited to try this place, but unfortunately let down. I ordered carry out for two very simple meals, shouldn’t have taken longer than 20 minutes to make. The website told me the food would be available at 11:03 after I ordered. After the 30 minute train ride to get there, arriving at 11:20, way past the time my order should’ve been ready, they told us it would be a 30 minute MINIMUM wait time to get our food. Very unprofessional management and poor service. Will not be going back.

Ma
Review №18

One of the worst service in restaurants I have ever tried, went there for breakfast. For one person they will not allow you to set on a table instead they say go to the bar and the old lady didn’t even say it nicely.what I cannot accept is that the bar was dirty and I can see some kind of small flies around which means unclean surface also they leave previous customers used plates on the bar for a very long time so it feels like setting in the middle of a pile of garbage ….the food is not that good and service is very slow I actually had to wait 10-15 minutes in order to get the menu only thing that came fast was the bill not worth itNever again

Br
Review №19

Really good spot to grab breakfast with the family if you are staying around grand central Station and want something traditional and at reasonable price. Service was amazing and enjoyed a good old fashion pancake plate

ju
Review №20

Great food, fries were delicious and crispy Philly cheese steak was hot and hit all the right spots. Service was friendly and quick. However,for better or for worse this diner truly keep it 80s decor. Needs a remolding, some seats were broken.

P
Review №21

Very nice old time diner. The vegetarian chili is very good!!

Ch
Review №22

My husband and I are staying at Wyndham across the street. I went to support a close friend at the funeral of her aunt and he went to grab a bite to eat. When he got there they seated a “white” woman before him. The customer said, “ This man was before me!” The lady said that she thought he was waiting for somebody. What an odd response. He was then seated in a booth and subsequently a man approached him and told him he can’t sit there with an attitude. Lenny said she seated me here. the man started yelling at the waitress that seated my husband. Then he clears another table and tells him to sit there.The customers were so disgusted with the way my husband was spoken to and being treated they cursed out the man and walked out. Three couples walked out all white couples.This goes to show you the we New Yorkers do not stand for this type of hatred. He was coming for breakfast that’s all he wanted. He did not have to be disrespected. We are a family a melting pot of all races from so many nations that’s the beauty of NY it’s diversity.Comfort Diner doesn’t like blacks and treats then poorly no one stands for it not even whites. Thanks for staying up got my husband my fellow NYers we love you! He’s such a nice guy. He didn’t deserve that. 🥲🥲🥲🥲🥲🥲

Ho
Review №23

Nicely styled American Diner, close to Grand Central but not on a crowded street. The staff were super friendly and efficient, the menu was the usual broad diner options, and the food itself was generous and tasty.The one downside is the place is very much split between the front and back. While theyre both a similar look, the back is near the kitchen and therefore much hotter, but also (maybe just our bad luck) more dimly lit. The front seemed airier and lighter as well as a more comfortable temperature.

Al
Review №24

I have been a fan of Comfort Diner since 2008. They had me at their 1940s style diner front and cozy old timey feel.The location doesnt hurt being so close to Grand Central in days of work commuting. This is not an area of Manhattan for parking. Maybe nights are different. Do try the Lemon Ricotta blueberry pancakes. Usually only available on weekends. They are thin and heaven on a plate. There used to be a pistachio crusted catfish with collard greens and sweet potato mash that was one of my favorite entrees but, its not on menu any longer. ☹ It was divine though. Weekends are packed here but service is always excellent and fast. Good going Comfort for staying around this long!!!

Ma
Review №25

I had the Mexican breakfast and it is super awesome. Really good coffee for diner coffee. The ownership are very kind people we are working hard to bring the restaurant back to full service now that NYC is open. I highly recommend this place for a nice art deco environment and a little different Diner menu.

La
Review №26

Waited forever while others got food. Hash was not as described. My waffle was soggy and cold. Potatoes and bacon tasteless. Service left a lot to be desired. Would not recommend or return.

Ma
Review №27

Came here for breakfast. Had the lumberjack breakfast. It was 2 pancakes, 2 eggs and 3 pieces of bacon. Sooooo much food! But so good! My husband had the Imagination Omelette. It came with home fries and toast. Again... Soooo much food. My friend that was with us had waffles with fruit on them. They looked amazing! I absolutely recommend giving this place a shot of you are in the area.

Ab
Review №28

Terrible service, the owner yelled at me and then started taking orders in front of me.

Ha
Review №29

This place has some true diner elements including being about as thin as an actual train car, but don’t let that stop you from getting a true NYC diner experience. The meal value was not bad at all. Some improvements could lie within having a place for guests to seat while they wait for the rest of their party to arrive since they will not seat incomplete parties despite the fact that they easily could when we were there. Also they do not let you get a to go cup of a bottomless beverage which was a huge turn off and quite frankly made no sense what so ever.

Si
Review №30

What a find! Great food, piping hot coffee, a table outside on a quiet street, and the nicest, most attentive owner! So pleased I stumbled across this place for a quick meal, it definitely hit the spot!

Be
Review №31

Loved it. I wish we had found it before our last day. Staff were very friendly and helpful. They noticed when we were seated we werent comfortable so they moved us to a different table. Food was amazing and tasty.

Pa
Review №32

Classic old-school NY diner. Looks like its family-run. The food was good, and the service was fantastic.

An
Review №33

When you combine the friendly staff with the great food, you have an old school diner that you will find yourself returning to over and over.

Sh
Review №34

Really tasty breakfast. Service was very nice too. Would go back.

Te
Review №35

My parents recommended we eat here on our trip. We stopped in and could not have asked for better. Dalia was simply AMAZING and so was the food. She went above and beyond a manager’s duty. Thank you!

Ry
Review №36

Top notch diner located a couple blocks away from the United Nations. The service was fast and friendly, the prices were fair and the portions were large. Oh, and the food itself? Delicious! Definitely stop by for some excellent diner food!

Je
Review №37

Love the genuine retro of this diner right down to the sports trophy lamp bases and the leatherette booths!

Am
Review №38

Servers were so friendly. Good recommendation. Great food!!

Di
Review №39

Greatest place for breakfast! Like playing in an American movie...everything was delicious and the staff very friendly and available to offer extra advise ... NEED TO GET THERE

Li
Review №40

This restaurant has fantastic service as well as delightful food. One of the best restaurant in the city. The meals came out quickly and the prices were affordable. Recommended.

Ro
Review №41

The highlight of my weekend is stuffing my face at the Comfort Diner. After searching high and low for a good local diner, Ive finally found one that I enjoy repeat visits to. If your hungry for a huge breakfast at a reasonable price, this is the place to go.

Ro
Review №42

If youre looking for basic, this is it. Nothing special but nothing bad about it. I didnt use the bathrooms but my friend did and the reviews about them being in a creep area of the basement are apparently true.

Ja
Review №43

A go to spot for a late night outing. The prices here are very reasonable, the food is filling and the service is great as well. They have a great menu selection and food is pretty tasty too.

Be
Review №44

What an amazing Diner, I think I would use the word authentic... it’s not trying to be a Diner but is a diner... the food was amazing... had the lumberjack and the best pancakes I’ve ever had ! And the a good price !The service was great, very friendly... I would recommend this place if your looking for a real diner and not a TV themed diner !

Am
Review №45

Got there, asked to be seated outside, woman said go right ahead. Sat down for 30 minutes without getting a menu, I went inside myself to ask for menus, the woman said a man would bring it out for us but he never did. Sat down for another 5 minutes then got up and left.

Al
Review №46

Hidden on 45th street between 3rd & Lex is an old school throw back (are we in Jersey (or Astoria)) diner. When you are using U-Bet in your eggcreams & chocosodas. Enough said.

Ta
Review №47

Nice staff.great food, Decently priced

De
Review №48

Food was great and staff was friendly!! Great place and good value.

Pi
Review №49

I seldom if ever give 5 stars to a restaurant. This place is a real treat for anyone wanting to experience the true American breakfast/lunch/diner. We had burgers (the sliders for the kids), the “all year round Thanksgiving meal” and the meatloaf and my oh my, they didn’t lie when stating this would be better than your mother’s. It indeed was, and much more!The staff was real nice too as we discussed how immigration has built and is still shaping America.The whole family (from 1 to 11) loved it. My favorite in NYC for sure (so far).

Je
Review №50

Im not one to write reviews, but this is by far the best customer service experience I have experienced at a restaurant post pandemic. Not to mention the food is AMAZING.

Ni
Review №51

Fab little hidden gem, we always visit for breakfast when in New York. Gorgeous pancakes, great service and atmosphere 🙂

Pi
Review №52

Clean, with super gentle waitress, had a simple eggs and smoked salmon. all good and well done. for a midtown diner experience not to miss

Ch
Review №53

Bad food, bad service, and horror movies could easily be filmed in the dungeon-like bathroom in the basement

Ga
Review №54

Good diner with good food, but thought that it was a little expensive as the tips were included in the bill.

Su
Review №55

Delicious, interesting breakfast. The red velvet hash with sweet potatoes and beets was a really nice twist on one of my favorite breakfast dishes.

Sh
Review №56

The Western Omelette was huge, tasty, and came out fast. Very friendly staff. Awesome breakfast experience, I will be back!

Vi
Review №57

Very busy place to eat, seeing the staff run all over the place is like having a show while eating. The staff work so hard & it is much apprectiated. This is a place worth coming to!!!

Ka
Review №58

Omg you have to go an try the Red Flannel Hash so deliciousThe coffee was delicious for a dinerFluffy fresh omeletGreat staff and serviceThe bathroom experience was the only negative

Ra
Review №59

Was desperate for some good ole diner breakfast. Ordered bacon, pancakes and coffee. It was delicious. The diner could use a cosmetic upgrade. There were 4 people seated together at one table. I sat on the other side and one table over due to Covid. The waitress was very friendly and attentive. I felt comfortable and safe as the staff adhered to the covid policies.

Da
Review №60

We came in on a Saturday morning, the place was not even full, but our food took more than half hourI ordered a steak and eggs, which came very very bland.My wife ordered the huevos rancheros, and it literally had only five individual beans sprinkled over the cheese with no salsa.

Al
Review №61

Great food, loved the pancakes and great staff overall. You can tell they were extremely overwhelmed and forgot one of the items on the list but they offered to personally deliver that one item. I would come back here again and again. I just wish the fruit bowl had more array of fruits.

Lo
Review №62

Was looking for breakfast. An old diner, could use an upgrade but very good food and the staff was very friendly and adhered to the Covid protocols, bringing takeout to customers at the door and wearing masks. I did eat indoors and there was a table with 4 occupants enjoying their meal.

Gr
Review №63

All the diner classics plus some mexican ones like chilaquiles. Portions are huge.

Au
Review №64

Because of COVID restrictions, there was NO indoor dining available.Was in NYC for a meeting that ended up being pushed backed 30 minutes after already arriving early.Wanted something to eat while wasting time but was not having any luck. Literally walked right into this place that had a make shift seating area for us to have a sit down breakfast. It was really cold and although we were seated outside in this make shift area, it didnt few that bad. Really wishes they had heaters inside. It wouldve been perfect.I was surprised by our food. We shared a meal but it was fresh and large enough for us to share and have some left over. My scrambled eggs were a bit runny but otherwise everything was god.

Is
Review №65

Great place ! Service was great and food as well . Never felt so comfortable, will definitely come back . +their birthday cake that they did for me was delicious ! ☺️

Jo
Review №66

This breakfast burrito is delicious but it is filling - Ron Burgundy.I had extra sausage in mine, tight packing and very tasty. My wife says the eggs in her breakfast are up there with the best shes ever had. Would recommend.

Ma
Review №67

Very old school New York diner. It’s a small business owned by the loveliest family. Super kind, attentive and great hosts. Their blueberry pancakes are to die for.

Ni
Review №68

Such a gem. The people who run it are so nice and the food is good

Ca
Review №69

The food and service here kept us coming back every morning during our trip to New York. The manager Dahalia runs a tight ship and you can feel that everyone loved working there. Absolutely get the lemon ricotta pancakes. I would have taken a picture, but each time there were in my belly before I got a chance to.

Da
Review №70

The service was terrible. We sat down and our drinks order wasnt taken until 15 minutes later. They forgot to give us the drinks. We ordered our food and waited 40 minutes for the food until we decided to leave. There was also a musty smell lingering in the air.

LD
Review №71

Huge portions, busy. Older and a bit cramped.

Ja
Review №72

They have the worst egg Benedict’s I’ve ever tried. The eggs and muffins do not taste good. The potatoes are over fried. The hot water for tea smells like it from the hot tab, definitely not boiled from fresh water. I gave this store one star. This is a tourist place, not a foodie place.

Vi
Review №73

Best waffle Ive ever had and great friendly service too!

St
Review №74

Old time style diner...good food and breakfast...close to grand central station

El
Review №75

Nice, quiet place to enjoy good comfort food at a good prices for its portion sizes. The staff were very nice to us even when it was near closing time.

St
Review №76

What a fantastic place! Feels like you got spotted out some when in the old days. Lovely staff, great food and a fantastic atmosphere.

Mi
Review №77

My lady says the Challah French Toast is heavenly

Ta
Review №78

I had a cup of the vegetarian chili, it was delicious! The cup of chili was the perfect bite on a cold day. Everyone at the diner was so nice too.

Wi
Review №79

The was prepared just how I like. Great experience the food was great 😊 an the host is nice.

Ki
Review №80

Delicious filling breakfast a short walk from Grand Central. Friendly staff and reasonably priced.

Kr
Review №81

Good food reasonable prices and the wall art entertained me

Co
Review №82

Apparently breakfast is what they are known for. I ate dinner here. The roast beef sandwich with carmalized onions and cheese was great...but the fries were soggy and the fried mac and cheese balls lacked flavor...but the sandwich WAS great

Mo
Review №83

We stayed in a hotel nearby and we ate 3 times for the breakfast there. The staff is nice, the food is good (big quantity.)

Ma
Review №84

Great food. Erick and Dalia were fantastic!

Pa
Review №85

Great little diner and delicious food! Love their omelet and strawberry French toast, and the staff is quite amazing

Gi
Review №86

Affordable, tasty and amazing service!Will definitely be back.

Ri
Review №87

Excellent wafflles, cute and helpful staff! Thank you for the experience!

Ka
Review №88

Great quality food! Highly recommended. Fantastic omelette

Ol
Review №89

Good service and decent food buy nothing to shout about.

Me
Review №90

Love this place. Great little neighborhood diner, super friendly staff, and the steak & eggs are delicious! My son and I have become weekly regulars since coming to NYC. Offers both indoor and outdoor seating.

Lu
Review №91

Sometimes you look for something traditional, tasty and just correct. This place appeared like if it was sent from heaven.

A.
Review №92

Amazing place on the West Side! Meal sizes are appropriate for the value and the food tast great!

Tr
Review №93

Great service and food. Large portions!

Sh
Review №94

Food and service was great but the place is too closed up.

Pa
Review №95

Bathrooms are disgusting!! Mops are dirty !Wipe off tables with a dirty rag !!

Jo
Review №96

I always have breakfast here, friendly staff, very tasty food

Ni
Review №97

Great place and service!

Ma
Review №98

Average portions, food is OK, staff was not very friendly and seemed annoyed.

St
Review №99

Superb little olde world diner...recommended a visit. Check out their Womlettes....

al
Review №100

Great food. Big portions. Fair price. Very friendly staff. Really good spot for breakfast.

Information
100 Photos
100 Comments
4.1 Rating
  • Address:214 E 45th St, New York, NY 10017, United States
  • Site:http://comfortdiner.com/
  • Phone:+1 212-867-4555
Categories
  • Diner
  • American restaurant
  • Traditional American restaurant
Working hours
  • Monday:8AM–8PM
  • Tuesday:8AM–8PM
  • Wednesday:8AM–8PM
  • Thursday:8AM–8PM
  • Friday:8AM–8PM
  • Saturday:8AM–8PM
  • Sunday:8AM–8PM
Similar organizations
  • La Bonbonniere28 8th Ave, New York, NY 10014, United States
  • Ritz Diner1133 1st Avenue, New York, NY 10065, United States
  • Park Cafe861 7th Ave, New York, NY 10019, United States
  • The Flame Diner893 9th Ave, New York, NY 10019, United States
  • Madison965 1st Avenue, New York, NY 10022, United States
  • Star On 18128 10th Ave, New York, NY 10011, United States