Great shop! Amazing Customer Service ! Thanks guys!!!

I went to Tunny’s because the shop is close and had decent reviews. They ended up telling me I needed an alignment and to take it to another shop. This was only after they charged me for a new set of tires and said they thought the shake I was experiencing was because of a bad motor or transmission mount (never got a straight answer). If you didn’t know what was wrong with it or weren’t willing to figure it out, I would’ve appreciated honesty instead of sending me somewhere else for a job I’d think you could do (alignment) as a full service auto shop.Edited to add - car was fixed by another shop and it was the CV joint. Your suggestion for an alignment was a misdiagnosis.

Love this place to get my car fixed at they do a good job

I received a good service. I will always go there.

Fast service, good prices. Got the job done right!

Good Customer Service. Great Prices. Thank you Ben.

Not professional at all, didnt have them to provide service

Friendly and professional staff. Very competitive pricing as well.

Did some work on my old Dodge. They sweat themselves half to death getting it done . Took pretty much all day because the truck was stubborn but they did a great job and worked with me on the bill. These guys are down to earth do good honest work and make your feel like one of the guys.

Tyler, Ben and Kevin are awesome. Just down to earth dudes that dont lie, try to help you out and charge a fair price! Just good, honest mechanics, good figure 8 racers, Kevin is a Vietnam Veteran and biker. I love hanging out in the shop and talking to these guys.They are quick and charge fair prices for good mechanical work!

In and out, Repaired this mess and received change from a single $20 bill, SUPER friendly and confident tire experts! Highly recommended.

First time to have my car serviced at this location.Was having issues with a tire. Was so relieved when they fixed the rim. Very honest and gave me there opinion. So reasonable couldnt believe it. Would highly reccomend these guys.

Ive yet to find a bad thing to say about these guys. Affordable, courteous, prompt, and they get the job done right. What more could you ask for?

Terrible SERVICE. My car was worse after taking it there than before. Once they get your money they dont care about the condition of your vehicle or the inadequate service. Go to Logans not here!!

I just got four new tires for my truck and their price was almost 400 cheaper than everyone else and the tires run very smooth there had the tires the next business day and I was in and out in less than in hour and the customer service was amazing I sent a friend of mine up there a couple days later for four brand new tires and she had the same experience I did they even took a wire brush the inside lip of my wheels to make sure they sealed properly I was a tire guy for over ten years so I know alot about the tire business and will say they guy know what they are doing I normally want to get in and do the job but with these I guys I knew my truck was in good hand good job Ben

Efficient and effective service at affordable prices. The process was completely transparent beginning to end, which is always a plus when dealing with automotive repairs big and small. Whether youre local to Wanamaker, passing through, or willing to make the trip for better work this place is worth your time and money.

Good business and great prices.

Great service, good quality, friendly and knowledgeable staff willing to go out of their way to make sure their customers are taken care of. A hidden gem shoved back in a corner of Wannamaker

Got a flat and needed a tire fast. I went up there, and they saw that I clearly have no idea about cars, so he went and looked at the car for me to see what size tired I needed. Told me he had one, 20 minutes later Im leaving with a freshly installed tired. Amazing and fast service, friendly and knowledgeable people. I will be going back!

Popped my left front tire on 465 Monday evening, called them at noon on Tuesday to see if they could put a used tire on for me, got one put on that evening. Very fast & friendly service. Very affordable too!

Good service and friendly people. Will be going back.

Fast and friendly service. Will be back with future needs.

This is the Only Place My Family & I get tires & our vehicles fixed. Great Customer Service and a Place You can Trust. Reasonably Priced as well

Nice, clean, quick, professional, friendly and the best 2 used tires Ive ever bought for 50 dollars each! Thanks so much for seeing me same day and getting my tires on and rolling so fast! Awesome. I will be back when I need work done and I highly recommend this shop!

In being new to the area, its a little intimidating trying out a new place, but I desperatley needed some tires. These guys really know their stuff! Ben helped us out. He and the rest of the hardworking staff were friendly, knowledgeable and informative. Theyre a lot more than just tires. They handle brakes, oil changes, mufflers and even glass repair.I couldnt get a new set this time, but needless to say Ive found our new one stop automotive shop. Great care at a fair price! What more can you ask?

They guy was very friendly and gave me an excellent deal on 2 used tires

Great price and fast service.

Quick work, had 2 good tires in my size, and worked with me on price. Will definitely be coming back again.

These guys are great. They got me 4 used tires that looked brand new, and they were really inexpensive. I was upset when I realized that I needed new tires because I couldnt afford 4 new tires, but they gave me 4 used tires that were practically brand new. Thanks guys.

I took my truck in for break work. They first tell me they have never replaced the part i needed replaced then told me the part was 300 bucks but i had already called autozone and they sell the same part for 108 bucks. These guys are not very trust worthy. I understand a mark up on parts but 3x as much??? I will never go back or refer any one there

When we had a flat tire on our trip to Tennessee, all the other tire shops had a 3 hour wait. Elite New and Used Tires had us back on the road in 20 minutes flat for only $50. Highly recommend.

Extremely pleased. First time, but most definitely will return.

I bought 4 used tires from here a mth n half ago. Worst experience ever! First the guy stripped out 4 lugnuts and broke a stud. Then he put sticker weights on the inside of the tire. I pulled out and back in the garage 2x until they got it right so it wasn’t rubbing on my brake caliper bracket. In all I was there over 2hrs from the time I pulled my truck in the garage. That’s just the beginning! 2 weeks go by and I’m hearing a rubbing sound. So I go to take my tire off and all my lugnuts have started to work there way loose. They also gave me mismatch lugnuts, one I couldn’t even get off with my tire iron because it was a 17 instead of the standard 19 for my truck. So I took it back up there to get a lugnut that was a 19. Wait it’s not over. 2weeks later I go to do my brakes and the 19 they gave me is stripped so I couldn’t get a bite on it. So I take it back to them. This time Tyler who says he’s the owner, says he wants to make it right. I’m going to order you all new lugnuts, and studs I’ll give you a call when they come in. He looked me in the eye and shook my hand. Week and half goes by I here nothing. So I call, he says he hasn’t even put the order in yet... what!!??☹️. Ill get on it today he says. He calls me back that day says he having trouble getting the front studs. I’ll let you know something by the end of day. That was a week ago. Joke! Worst customer service ever. Never had so much trouble with a used tire dealer. Last time i went there it was a Saturday around 10am... prime time for used tire dealer. You could hear crickets in the garage. Plenty of used tire shops around. Trust me, take it somewhere else!!

Great service as always!.

Excellent service very friendly

Great fast Service, I will send them new business!!

Quick, easy, and low cost. Workers very polite

Love this place, they have helped me out a few times, with nice deals

Good people, got pads and rotors at a fair price. Definitely recommend

They are amazing! Always trying their hardest to please their customers!! I definitely reccomend!!

I respect any professional auto shop to being open and honest without BS by not upcharging or pushing you for needless expenses. Had truck and car tires purchased and done here before.Update: Elite solved my brake issues after a few troubleshooting attempts, concerning dragging pads, and sticking as the summer got hot, while keeping cost options down. It took a couple revisits to narrow it down to e-brake cable adjustment, 1 caliper and 2 rotors/pad replacements. Truck now runs with restored mileage, clean smooth braking. Truck bought from Canada with rusted bottom by their salty roads. Previous shop recommended all rotors replaced, didnt tell me about the worn caliper piston seal when they did my pads.

We have used them 3 times for different reasons. Nothing bad to say at all. They are honest and professional.

Very friendly people fast at their job clean environment

Fair pricing and quick, friendly service!

Always helpful and fast service!

Great place with really genuine employees and good prices.

Great price and quick work, great service

Good quality used tire, low price.

These guys are great to deal with. If you need used tires on the east side of Indianapolis, you need to use these guys.

Fast and friendly, in and out within 30 minutes

Amazing customer service, professional and quick

Great service and great customer service.

Excellent service!

Best customer service

My brother and I are opening an auto repair shop under the Elite New and Used tire shop.

They always come through for me

Got me right in . Even told me to go buy parts it be cheaper . I will use them at all time

Very friendly staff and can not beat there prices will definitely be returning here for all our car care needs

Great group of guys

Have only been once, but seem to be alright guys

Is very professional and very clean