user
My Milkshake
151 S 2nd St #199, San Jose, CA 95113, United States
Appearance
My Milkshake
Comments
Mi
Review №1

A milkshake bar that can make almost anything you can think of. Highly recommend this place to anyone who likes milkshakes.

Sh
Review №2

I came in with 9 of my friends. Only one worker and she made all of our milkshakes in a fast timely manner. They should really consider having more than one person working so they don’t get overwhelmed.

Li
Review №3

4 the price, around 6$ Ud think the shake would be yummier

Kr
Review №4

I LOVED THIS PLACE!!! Me and my girlfriend went there after a frisbee practice for some delicious milkshakes, and boy did they deliver! Not only the best service I’ve ever had (especially as an indecisive customer). Walked in and was immediately greeted with smiles and a conversation that felt like I was greeting a friend I hadn’t seen in years. As they will tell you, everything off the menu is amazing. We got the curly fries which were perfectly salted and fried to perfection to pair with their Hulk drink that was the perfect combination of minty and sweet. I made my own with chocolate ice cream, brownies and strawberries. I couldn’t be happier with the people, service, and product. If I could leave 100 reviews I would. I’m taking all of my friends here immediately.

Br
Review №5

Custom milkshake was delicious and flavorful. First time there and it definitely didnt disappoint. Would come back again.

Pr
Review №6

I love the concept of mixing ice cream and chocolate and creating multiple flavors out of it. My favorite one is the Spider-Man which has chocolate and ferrero rocher. I think it is a little expensive and a lot of calories. But when someone is okay to enjoy and satisfy your taste buds.

Wa
Review №7

Strawberry milkshake had strawberries and tased like strawberry. Not strawberry syrup flavors. Should bhave larger size like 1 gallon.:-)

Ja
Review №8

The shake was alright. I added premium candy and the consistency was great 👍. The price is too high for the quality of shake. I would at least like real whip cream too not store bought. 3 candies and a 24 oz milkshake for a little over $17... the milkshake lacked flavor. Maybe Ill give it another shot and try something different next time.

Co
Review №9

Pretty good. A little pricey, about $10 for one, but thats about standard for downtown SJ. Employees were friendly and helpful.

Em
Review №10

We tried chocolate, vanilla, and cheese cake ice cream. It was difficult to choose the best of them because they were all so good. The ice cream is delicious and creamy.

Ma
Review №11

Awesome little space! Definitely worth a try if you have the sweet tooth for it!

Me
Review №12

The milkshakes taste incredible, but this shop is way too busy with Doordash orders to take orders from walk-in customers. It took us half an hour to get 2 small shakes.

Sa
Review №13

Excellent milkshakes! You can get whatever you want in them! I personally really enjoyed the almond joy in them! Beautiful location as well!

Mi
Review №14

Well honestly Im for small business. But McDonalds was better

Mi
Review №15

They stay open late and thats perfect! Its hard to find snacks or even food anymore late night.

Ar
Review №16

I love the milkshakes from here!! Totally recommend to others!!!

Sh
Review №17

They offer a variety of yummy milkshakes. You can even opt for Almond milk instead of normal milk for your milkshake. I personally loved their Spider-Man milkshake.

La
Review №18

Ordered two Joker Milkshakes, they were over priced, did not taste good and did not even look close to the advertised picture! Very upsetting and disappointing.

La
Review №19

Best milkshake I have had in a while!

An
Review №20

Really tasty milkshakes with tons of customization options. They come in various sizes, so its perfect for when youre feeling like a small treat or ready to fill up. Inside was clean and modern looking. The menu is displayed on monitors along the walls. Its a small spot so dont bring a crowd

An
Review №21

Came here in the middle of the week in between Lunch and Dinner so no one was here...woo hoo means I get in and get out! Obviously its more scaled back because of COVID, but the shakes still taste great! Glad to see they are still around and will be back!

Zo
Review №22

First time here, ordered the Spiderman with vanilla ice cream and it was yummy 😋

Ro
Review №23

I went hear back when they first opened and then I just went for a second time today. The quality seems to have gone up but then again so I have the prices. They offer endless combinations of milkshakes and they also have french fries as well. I got one with strawberries York peppermint with almond milk in it was really good! They also offer Mason jars for purchase as well!The staff here is very nice and theyve always been welcoming. The only con is that the wait time can be pretty long because they dont have a lot of blenders. But this is a definitely cool spot to try out if youre in downtown San Jose and youre craving something sweet

Ar
Review №24

Delish

Br
Review №25

Great early birthday shakes with my son. He always gets The Joker, and selected a chocolate, banana, and pretzel M&Ms for me. Only downer was they were blasting their music way too loud. (I know I just made my self sound like an old fogey, but it was seriously unnecessary loud).

Dm
Review №26

Awesome little milkshake shop. The service employees seemed a little down on the dumps. Dont know if maybe it was a bad day but if that wasnt the case they definitely could have been friendlier. You can build your own milkshake with different milks, candy or fruit. They also serve fries and nuggets.

Co
Review №27

Customize shakes with selection of cookies and candies, or keep it simple. Your choice. Good stuff for your sweet tooth.

Ta
Review №28

Completely customized milkshakes, and milk free options are available

Hu
Review №29

Slow service and expensive price

To
Review №30

Amazing Superman shake!

Ni
Review №31

Tasted ok but way overpriced. I ordered the Hulk milkshake on Door Dash and my partner ordered the joker. When they arrived the straw was already inside and the mouth part of the straw was not covered (gross). The photos on door dash made them look so delicious but what arrived was lackluster and boring. It was mostly melted which I don’t really hold against the restaurant because I opted for deliver. Even putting that aside It was really disappointing looking and a rather small portion for $10. There were no detectable pieces of the add ins because it is so over blended. It really just tasted like a plain mint shake. Absolutely nothing special about this. Maybe in store it’s better but I’ll probably never try it again to find out.

Za
Review №32

Options are great! Tried 6of them all were awesome

Ad
Review №33

Amazing milkshakes, great for takeaway

R
Review №34

Like coldstone meets milkshakes. Plus the fry options are BOMB

Ar
Review №35

The Spiderman and Dark Knight are a must try in here.

Hi
Review №36

Ive been visiting this place since 3 years. As a student it was impossible for me to afford this milkshake very often. But now, I order a superman/ spiderman whenever Im in downtown SJ! The staff was inflexible in adding any sort of toppings on the drink even when I offered to pay extra!

Cl
Review №37

Loved itStormm milkshake was delicious

ma
Review №38

Yummy shakes😋 loved Spiderman shake

An
Review №39

The best milkshake place in the bay area easily. Super hero menu can get u excited. Its got a good range of chocolates and fruits to add on to and to add to that even a shake with whey protein. Amazing! Quality if the shake is a absolutely delicious. Customized options available as well. 8,16 and 32oz at $5, $8 and $12 respectively.

Ti
Review №40

This place has vegan milkshakes which is awesome. However, everytime i want to go i need to call and make sure they have their vegan ice cream because most of the time they dont have it in stock. Ive wasted several trips to this place expecting them to have their whole menu available. So just make sure to call and make sure they have the vegan ice cream if thats what you plan on getting.

Ad
Review №41

Best vegan milkshakes ever!!! I got a non vegan one and that was good too!!! I loved the atmosphere and the girl working was super friendly. we got bbq fries and they were yummy but a small is definitely more than enough of that if you know what i mean.

br
Review №42

Weve walked by quite a few times, and today we finally stopped by. Its hard to not like a place serving ice cream, but at the same time there isnt much magic here. Like others have said the shake was good but not great. The inside of the shop was empty when we walked in with one other customer show up during our visit. This would have been a great time to have someone cleaning up the dirty tables. Pretty typical San Jose. So-so quality and cleanliness with with top of the line pricing.

La
Review №43

Very good quality. I love the names of their milkshakes almost more than I love the actual shake. Their sides are nice and fresh and theyre never soggy or cold. Ive had a variety of different shakes and each one has been pleasant. The only downsize is that they are a little more on the expensive side. $8.75 or a 16 oz. The atmosphere is nice with plenty of seats, although in their busier times it can get overcrowded and Ive had to wait outside. Overall, this is a great place to go for a hangout with friends or just to get a delicious milkshake.

Vr
Review №44

Best Spiderman Milkshake.

Ch
Review №45

Tasty shakes!

AV
Review №46

Came here to My Milkshake tonight and wow! What a great concept! They have a wall full of candy that you can pick and choose to blend in the milkshake. I got a joker which is Strawberries and Nutella! It tasted even better than it sounds. Perfectly creamy and thick! I will def be coming back as soon as I can

Pu
Review №47

Pretty good shakes. Havent had the food. The portion sizes for the shakes are pretty large, which is nice! A lot of my friends thought a lot of them were too sweet. To be honest, even the smallest size is quite a bit for at least my group of friends. But, theyre nice about letting you order whatever size you want and then splitting it into half.

He
Review №48

Picked up a Dark Knight with soy ice cream and almond milk, a milkshake for my husband, and an order of tater tots. We had been here a year ago and the man behind the counter remembered us! He even remembered I like chocolate! The milkshake was well blended and delicious! The tater tots had a nice crunch when you bite and a soft, warm center. My husband enjoyed his milkshake, as well. There was a menu of premade things and a make-your-own option. It has a decent size dining area for downtown San Jose. Loved our visit; see you next year, My Milkshake!

Sa
Review №49

One of the best KitKat Oreo milkshakes I have ever had.

Ve
Review №50

The shakes are delicious!

Ha
Review №51

Location is perfect because it’s downtown but the staff is not that nice. You don’t really have a lot of options only select vanilla or chocolate base. For additional options like brownie or cheese cake, fruits or cookies you have to pay extra. Although it’s a nice quick stop but I’ll not go back as their milkshakes are not worth the price.

yo
Review №52

What ever I write it’s nothing one of my top place in sanjoseThank you so much Mr Marty you did amazing job100% fresh

Ry
Review №53

Ever since discovering this place one year for Fanime, my friends and I make sure to drop by and get something, usually before we leave the con on Monday. Great mixtures and theme, plus food being served is a great addition. Love this place.

Lo
Review №54

Really good Shakes. Def coming back for moreGood serviceLots of options not so much the Ice cream but fixings are endless

Al
Review №55

Today is my first time at my milkshake and I got the small Oreo milkshake with extra Oreos and no whipped cream!!!. This was so good!!!.

Al
Review №56

Fun place with yummy milkshakes! Our daughters volleyball team gathered there after a tournament. The girls enjoyed it! Definitely filled up with all the girls and added parents. I definitely say this is a must go to place for a great milkshake!

Ro
Review №57

Oh my goodness! I love this place!This place specialized in milkshakes (as the name might indicate)There are two systems for ordering here. System 1, you pick a thing off the menu (all items are named after super heroes!). System 2, build your own. You chose your milk, ice cream, fruits, candies, whip cream, etc.I particularly love this place because Im lactose intolerant and have actively avoided dairy for years. This place has the option for me to ask for almond milk and soy ice cream. Normally these options create a watery abomination, but not here! The almond/soy option still creates a thick delicious shake like I remember from when I was a kid! I cant tell you how satisfied I was with my first taste of the Deadpool (Oreos and strawberries - get it, its red and black)Ill be coming back here next time Im in the area!

Ka
Review №58

It is a small place located adjacent to the Second st parking at SJ downtown. The shop was kind of deserted and there was no one in the counter when we entered.We ordered a 12 oz. custom milk shake with whole milk and chocolate icecream along with mango and banana, and no whipped cream. The service was fast and once we got our order the place was back to just us, with not even the people in the counter. The milk shake was good, but not exceptional.

Mo
Review №59

Good milkshake place if you are not worried about calories. Loaded with ice cream and candy! You can customize your shakes. Good place to go with kids.

El
Review №60

Theres runny soppy milkshakes and theres thick milkshakes.These are thicc milkshakes.

Vi
Review №61

A cute little shake shop. What else can one ask for on a night stroll in San Jose downtown after dinner. The shakes that we tried were quite good - thick, smooth and tasty. And its open pretty late into the night so more reasons to raid it after a good time elsewhere.

Au
Review №62

They have dairy free options! How it works is you choose your milk, ice cream, and any toppings you want. For dairy free folks, they have almond milk and soy ice cream. However, the wait was very long. it is hard to find parking, but there is a paid parking structure right next to it.

Kr
Review №63

My Milkshake speaks to my sweet tooth and my creative itch.This small downtown shop lets you customize your dream shake. With so many options it can be a bit overwhelming- from candies to syrup, sprinkles, brownies, cookie dough and more!While you cant do much wrong when it comes to ice cream, I was bummed they dont blatantly offer blending options- my vanilla shake with peanut butter, brownies, and cookie dough was fully blended leaving no reminisce of brownies or cookie dough. The cookie dough flavor was lost and the final product just ended up tasting like peanut butter chocolate ice cream. Highly recommend asking for your shake less blended if thats what youre expecting.

Ma
Review №64

I should have took a photo of the food but it was too good to interrupt. The service was very helpful and welcoming.

Ut
Review №65

Good milkshakes. But wait a little while before you start drinking it. The consistency is way to thick to be able to start drinking it, even with the thick straw. The flavours are nothing special but its good nonetheless.

Al
Review №66

Chiara and Vanesa made excellent recommendations on which milk shake was the best. Clearly they know what theyre talking about.

Al
Review №67

Great place to go downtown! Parking can be somewhat difficult depending on when you go but they are open super late too! You can choose from one of their pre-made milkshakes or make your own! They also have mason jars available :) Thanks my milkshake!

Be
Review №68

Small shop with a Big name in the milkshake department. Featuring Marvel and DC Comic names to their signature drinks - try them all with a uniqueness to each one! Great place to swing by on a first date or an after dinner treat.

Mi
Review №69

Easy to get to, (without car) great hangout, and fun environment! Staff understanding and lovely! If you love sweets and ice cream this is the place to go! :)

Br
Review №70

This is my favorite milkshake place. You get to choose your own candy to go in it, too!

Ma
Review №71

Loved and missed milkshakes

Al
Review №72

You can get basically anything in your milkshake. Also you can get your milkshake in a cool 16oz mason jar for $2 more, which pays for itself in 1 visit because when you bring that in they’ll only charge you for a small.

Mi
Review №73

Great experience. Staff was super friendly and helpful. But most of all the ice cream was really good and I will be going back next time I am in the area.

So
Review №74

We were super excited about this place as we had gotten a milkshake a couple of weeks ago and it was delicious. Considering this place has “milkshake” in the name, we thought that they would make good ones as well. We got the superman (peanut butter cup and brownies) and waited as they made our milkshake. We saw them add some milk, scoop some peanut butter and crush a brownie with scoops of ice cream in a blender. When we got our shake, we thought it was okay, but wasn’t what we were expecting. The milk made it not so thick and the brownie was too crushed up for us so we only tasted the granulars (is that a word?) of it. We were hoping for some chewy pieces. The peanut butter was good, but nothing special.Overall, it was alright. I wouldn’t pay almost $7 for another shake.

Za
Review №75

A nice place. Went there few times. The guy who work there is so friendly. The floor and the tables are clean. If you are an athlete, then you wont go wrong with this place since they have a special active menu. Its a little expensive, but worth it.

Mi
Review №76

Very disappointed. I ordered doordash from here trying to support local businesses. The fries were cold, the chicken nuggets were over done and the milkshake melted. Too expensive for such poor quality

Pr
Review №77

Tasty custom milkshakes! The shop was a little untidy, but other than that really good service.

Sw
Review №78

Good milkshakes with superhero names!

Ca
Review №79

Amazing Milkshakes! I got referred here by a friend, and she definitely has good taste. It is $5.50 for the smallest cup, but packed with flavor!

Sa
Review №80

Good selection of DC/Marvel universe themed shakes, and they taste pretty good and are quite filling. Probably why they are a bit pricey.

Gr
Review №81

Ive decided to change the 2 stars to 4 because theyve changed a lot in two years, thankfully. There is a better operation going on and they have a great selection of candy to add. Its still funny to see how the screens are placed where froyo machines were.

Mu
Review №82

Amazing. Im not much of a dessert or sugary drink fan, but I do indulge in my cravings to reward myself for eating healthy all the time. And I had no idea I had a milkshake craving until I accidentally showed up here one day - and, oh boy!What is this? Thick, luscious, chocolate, almond milk that never seems to end in my mouth! The trick is the choice of additives you pick from a plethora of chocolate/candy choices to be ground into your milkshake. And priced so well - $6.50 to $9 (12 to 24 oz).So, Ive search Google for something like this close to where I live in Santa Clara. Nope. Sunnyvale- nada. Cupertino, still no. So I haul my ass in my car, circle around for parking, feed the meter and go on a mini-hike to my pilgrimage. Still worth it!(I was on a long call and finished my shake by the time I walked over to my car; so I walk back to get a refill - this time a 24 oz!)

Iq
Review №83

The girl / lady with black hair and glasses is soooo rude . We got about 7 shakes I think and she had this face where it was obvious she hated her job ...Was rude to all the questions we asked her and the shakes weren’t good either ... charged an extra 2.75 for adding ferroro rocher to the joker shake and she didn’t even make the shake right. But the asian boy who made our shakes was so great and kind ! He made my shake and it was hella good . He had more of a leader attitude than that older girl . I give him 5 stars

Oa
Review №84

Open late and staff is always friendly. Shakes are epic!

Al
Review №85

The milkshakes are really good. You can make your own combinations. Theres hardly a wait. Its pricey. Youre mostly paying for the brand. Its good but not great.

MI
Review №86

Tried this place twice. May i say that they know how to put it down on making milkshakes. So many choices on make your own milkshake orders. I think i would get something different every time.

Ka
Review №87

Would of been nice to sit but 30 min before closing all chairs were on top of tables

Mi
Review №88

This place is soo good whenever i go to san jose i take my kids here as a treat very good

He
Review №89

One of the many places in the Bay open late, for your sugar fix.

Tr
Review №90

The menu was good. No comment about the location since its in downtown so gotts expect some struggle with parking. Worth to try.

TC
Review №91

Me and my friend called this establishment to see if we could make a custom milkshake and we called they said “Stop prank calling us you losers.” Me and my friend then called they back and said we just wanted to order milkshakes. Now me and my friend will never contact this establishment ever again.

Ol
Review №92

They do HAVE Vegan options. They offer a soy vanilla with plant based milk and customer selection of add-ins.

Co
Review №93

The milkshake was pretty good. But for 8 bucks, it probably should be right?

Ka
Review №94

Best drink ever and the chocolates as a bonus🥰

Bi
Review №95

Its a cool place to go to in downtown San Jose, but it is extremely expensive.Also, the menu is very complicated. The staff wasnt very friendly and very clicky with one another. It wasnt busy at all when I went, so I went straight to the counter, but she said she wanted me to walk to the back and read the menu and the steps first before going back to her. And when I went to place my order I felt like I was interrupting the employees conversation with one another.The fixings they offer are quite expensive! $2 for two small bits of kinder chocolate!

Ve
Review №96

Wide variety of milkshake options with all chocolate and fruit flavors. friendly staff and great ambience right in the heart of SJ downtown!

Ro
Review №97

Decent. No chunks of strawberries in the strawberry milkshake. Hilarious that they have to misspell the superhero names to avoid copyrighting! Still, great for a hot day.

Ni
Review №98

Small shop but good shakes.

Ch
Review №99

Affordable comic themed shakes. Enjoyed the catwomen shake. Fun, hip joint

Ad
Review №100

The best strawberry-vanilla milkshake

Information
100 Photos
100 Comments
4.4 Rating
  • Address:151 S 2nd St #199, San Jose, CA 95113, United States
  • Site:http://mymilkshakesj.com/
  • Phone:+1 408-899-6688
Categories
  • Dessert shop
  • Ice cream shop
Working hours
  • Monday:12–11PM
  • Tuesday:12–11PM
  • Wednesday:12–11PM
  • Thursday:12–11PM
  • Friday:12PM–1AM
  • Saturday:12PM–1AM
  • Sunday:12–11PM
Service options
  • No-contact delivery:Yes
  • Delivery:Yes
  • In-store pickup:Yes
  • In-store shopping:Yes
  • Takeout:Yes
Highlights
  • Great dessert:Yes
Accessibility
  • Wheelchair accessible entrance:Yes
Planning
  • Quick visit:Yes
Similar organizations