It is I wonderful place if you want to buy large lots of coins for cheap. Nice guy. Dont recommend going on Saturday unless your going to the auctions.

Had a great time at McCully’s while here on vacation. The owner invited me back because he had more of what I was looking for...but it wasn’t accessible at that time. Definitely a old school shop but worth a visit for sure!

Total disregard for my rare coins, didnt even look, their loss,im glad they didnt cause to just dump on coin shop i would of shared my profit but its only moneyall mine, lol .nah i know where there coming from... takes alot of time. looking at every coin, to see, if this starving individual has anything or not? well i plan on going back, how could you not want so old Hawaiiana Currency whats left of it !!! smh !!! if its not silver, dont go there basically the impression i got .i only had money . aloha !!! oops my bad, i for some reason thought this was a review on my time i spent at bishop street coin shop my apologies to McCully, The Gentalman at bishop was upforward and honest, now for the other place, i have many choice words but you may judge for yourself .aloha !!! so sorry for the Confusion . MCCully .

Best place to sell and buy collectibles.

Great service, knowledgeable about his products! Highly recommended

I felt I finally met the GREEDY GRINCH who tried to steal my Gold at 50% off Market !! What a World we live in....

Best kept secret for coin collectors.

Support kind and helpful, great store