What a great experience. Showed up on a Saturday a few minutes before closing. The staff (3 of them) were extremely friendly and took the time to show us items that were not even on display. Great prices. The store was clean and well organized. Would definitely recommend to others.

Been coming here for a few years now. Great coin store, very good selection and very knowledgeable people working there. I would highly suggest anyone that is interested in buying or selling coins make a visit.

I am moving and I took my grandparents silver service sets and flatware in to Pegasus. They greeted me immediately. Said bring all your stuff in and let’s look at it. I knew some of it was sliver plate, but I really had no idea of what was what and how much it was worth. I hated to throw it out. They sat and inspected each piece. Showed my what was what and 30 min later I left with a nice three figure check. They could have told me anything. And they were honest and showed me what had value and why. I would HIGHLY recommend them. Fast. Courteous. Honest. Hard to find these days. Thank you so much.

John is a pleasure to do business with, always professional. You can shop here with confidence. Always a 5 Star experience.

Very knowledgeable, great customer service, and gave us the best price in town for our silver coins. Couldnt ask for more, highly recommended.

Great experience selling several coin collections. Staff was accommodating and professional. I made the right choice!

I highly recommend buying and selling your coins here, they have great prices and offer fair value for your coins.

We did our research to figure out who we could trust to evaluate and purchase the coins we inherited and found Pegasus. The environment is secure, comfortable and the staff is professional. Additionally, we went back about a month later to purchase a watch, which we were given a generous discount.

I went there this morni g hoping to sell some silver coins i had and after a few call to other shops in town he was the only person who offered me over spot prices i left feeling very welcomed and more knowledgable ill be selling any of my silver here because he appreciates the value of coins and precious metals. Long story short the really isnt any were else to go...

I have known John for many years and I feel like a valurd customer every time I call. Regardless of dollar amount spent, John is aleays courteous and professional. The prices always check out. THIS IS THE PLACE.

This is a great coin shop. Great prices and great staff. I recommend for anyone interested in coins.

I love to buy gold and silver! If you live in the Bradenton, Florida area and are interested in either buying or selling precious metal you just gotta check these guys out. They are located in a nice urban neighborhood strip mall area with lots of resturaunts and shopping. Pegasus always have plenty variety of currency coins, bullion rounds and bars. I always leave there with a handfull of goodies! But what I like most is the friendly and helpful staff. I never feel pressured but rather feel at home. They are all very professional as well and best of all is their pricing is very fair! Believe me, Ive shopped around and they are the best in this area! Go check them out and see what I mean and find some great deals.

Best place around to sell your coins. Met with Justin a couple times and he is Very knowledgeable, patient, and great to deal with.

John and team are very knowledgeable and always a pleasure to work with. Very nice assortment of inventory to choose from - and fairly priced. Would highly recommend, whether youve got a simple question or a large collection its worth stopping in.

Having dealt with this place last year, I decided to go back to possibly sell a 1/10 oz proof Gold eagle coin/ Before leaving i looked it up on the sight i bought it from (Moneymetals.com) and it was selling for $320.. I dealt with t he younger bald man who offered me $180.

I am a first time customer. I really liked the staff and everyone was very helpful with my questions about coins and silver in particular. I plan to go back again and also tell others! Thanks!

I always had a great experience at Pegasus Coin and Jewelry. Justin and John are the best, very friendly and professional. They have the best prices selling and buying in town. Thank you very much I hope to see you very soon again.

Owners took the time to explain all the coins I brought in,and educate me soI felt comfortable. Even though I did not sell or buy anything they were so good at helping with no pressure. For sure when I am ready they will be the place I will go

Its great to have a resource for purchasing and selling precious metals so close to home. The alternative is an hour round-trip in to Bradenton or Sarasota. Justin is amiable and knowledgeable, and the store is clean and sharp, with a fine variety of jewelry as well. Give them a visit.

Excellent service! Kind. Friendly. Extremely helpful!I would definitely recommend.

What a great place to buy coins....I always love stopping in and talking to John when Im in Florida... These guys are the best!

Great company! Extremely professional -- will definitely be doing more business with these folks. Highly recommend!

It has always been a great experience doing business with John and his team over the years. Highly recommended!

Recently bought from John and it was a super smooth transaction! Would definitely do business again.

John and his team are friendly fair and knowledgeable. A great shop with decades of knowledge.

Great store with a friendly staff!

Ive gone twice to sell coins from my fathers estate. The staff are super friendly and knowledgable and they pay competitive prices. If you need to sell gold or silver coins, this is the place to go!

Friendly, engaging staff. Paid me a very fair price.

On first walking in to the store, its beautifully decorated. I came in wanting to sell some of my older pieces of jewelry that just havent been worn much. Justin took care of me. He was incredibly knowledgable, friendly and very professional. He answered any questions I had and gave me what I considered to be a fair price for the jewelry. I would definitely recommend this store. They dealt with mostly coins but I did have a chance to look at their jewelry displays and felt the prices were incredibly reasonable. Plus they had a 25 % off savings going on. Thanks, Justin!

Excellent staff. Very fair both buying and selling. Justin and John were very accommodating and helpful. I highly recommend them.

John and his team were very helpful. I had a very positive experience. I truly appreciated their integrity and honesty. I will definitely recommend them to my friends.

Pegasus Team, especially Justin has been helping me teach my 7 year old daughter about coins. I have been collecting coins since March of this year, I have been in 7 coin shops in the Manatee and Sarasota county area. Pegasus is the only one I trust for the honest price.

Shopped for the first time at Pegasus today and it was a very good experience. Helpful attendants answered questions, and well displayed merchandise.

Very professional, caring and trustworthy staff (all). With patience they addressed my concerns and lack of knowledge about items by educating me. Having this reputable establishment in our area made an incredible difference with my transaction. They take pride in helping customers. They you so very much.

Beautiful store. Wonderful staff. Very professional and friendly. I was very happy with the service and would highly recommend!!!

As soon as we walked through the front door at Pegasus we felt comfortable and safe. We met John to liquidate a coin collection that was very important to my mother. John was very kind and took time to explain the value of the pieces. We had met various coin dealers at coin clubs and fairs in both Manatee and Sarasota counties. We feel grateful to John for his knowledge, professionalism and integrity, he earned our business.

Great shop.

Im thrilled with my experience at Pegasus Coin and Jewelry. John is exceptionally knowledgeable and shares his knowledge with customers. John was extremely patient, and incredibly fair. He also displays general prices right up front and updates for spot fluctuations. They catch things that make something more valuable and points it out to the seller. Everything is up front, honest, and you never get any sense that theyre trying to maximize their profit at the sellers expense. I plan to do many future transactions at Pegasus coins due to my first few experiences with them. At Pegasus, you feel as if youre working with a partner thats looking to make some money, but thats not greedy and operates on thin margins when re-selling. 5 stars all the way.

Took a mixed box of coins for John to look over. John took his time and went through all the coins . Explained if I had a questions and was super friendly and very professional. As was one of the other workers, Faith who I spent time talking with as John went through the coins.I have more Items that I will be going back with.The amount I received for my coins was very fair.I highly recommend taking your items to them.

John and Justin were complete professionals in handling my purchases. They both answered all questions and made sure I was comfortable with my purchases. I will be a return customer.

A very lovely store. Not only for coins but have a nice selection of affordable jewelry. John & the staff very knowledgeable and friendly. Will be back!

John and Justin helped me sort thru my dads old coins and bills after his death. I went to other coin and jewelry shops who say they buy them but ended up packing everything up and leaving. Immediately walking into Pegasus I felt welcomed and had their full attention. Needless to say they have a customer for life!Thank you so much for all your help and expertise.

John and Company were Great. Straight forward, honest, and helped us make an informed decision regarding precious metals. Will definitely be back. Was worth the long drive over.

Great guys. easy to work with and very fair. Highly recommend.

I have done business with Pegasus and I have knownJohn a long time and all I I can say if you are not doing business with these people big mistake.whether it’s jewelry coins or bullion Pegasus should be your go to store

They were super helpful and took their time educating me. They have great prices and great people. I recommend them to anyone.

First, they seem to be the only coin business that is open on Sundays, which was very convenient for us. Second, although they were getting ready for a coin show, we didnt feel rushed in the process of going through our huge lot of coins. The staff is very knowledgeable, and took the time to educate us along the way. We left satisfied, and feeling we got the best price for our coins.

I have bought several times at Pegasus. The thing I like the way they post daily what they will buy and sell for. That makes it so they are very fair to all.

John & Justin treated me respectfully and patiently; thoroughly explaining how they assessed both the coins and jewelry I brought in for redemption. Lovely atmosphere .

Absolutely the most professional coin and jeweler to buy or sell through. My drive was a little over an hour but it was easily worth the ride. If you have any thoughts to selling jewelry or coins, THIS IS THE PLACE !!

I like the silver chart price was easy to understand. I bought a bar of silver and there was several types to choose from

Great people to do business with!

The best, most convenient coin shop that I know of. The employees are very friendly and help you. 100% recommend it. Plus they give away Buffalo nickels FREE. Every Tuesday and Friday.

Incredibly rude owner- go elsewhere

Great experience overall, fair prices and friendly staff. John and AJ were great!!! Definitely would recommend anyone here.

Purchased an 1873 U.S.one dollar golf piece from Justin at Pegasus Coin and Jewelry today. I’m very pleased with my purchase and recommend Pegasus to anyone that is looking for that “special” coin, has an interest, or just wants to look at some beautiful coins and spend time talking with Justin or John. Great place!

Ive had the good fortune to visit the store a few times now. What impresses me most is the courtesy that the staff shows to all levels of collectors, rich and poor, experienced or inexperienced. Im looking forward to an expanded inventory of quality numismatic material as time goes on.

Great service in a relaxed environment! John was very helpful and informative. Would recommend to everyone.

John is very honest and trustworthy. Pegasus is a reputable business to use. George Wood

Good people, fair pricing. I will definitely do business here again.Paul T Venice FL

Great experience working with John. Very prompt payment, hours after package arrived!

Very nice store. I sold some silver coins and received a real fair price. I will be telling my friends. If you are looking for jewelry, watches and other items you might want to look into this business.

I had a great experience at Pegasus Coin and Jewelry. John, the owner, is extremely educated in the coin business, and I appreciated his expertise. Paul, a full time jeweler and auctioneer, was also very helpful. It was a pleasure to do business with John and Paul. Should the need arise, I will be back.

It was a pleasure working with John the owner. I took the short drive in from St. Petersburg and it was worth the trip.Great prices and fantastic quality of products.Thanks for everything.Eric

We just bought some silver from them. They were very helpful and friendly. It was a great experience

John the owner helped me choose 4 Morgan silver dollars for Christmas gifts for my grandchildren. Great service with a smile. Thank you John & staff!!!

Very nice shop. Staff is knowledgeable, friendly and courteous. I shall return!

Great experience, brought coins in and he gave me a fair price. Will go back again.

The staff was great to work with and provided me great prices on my items.

Class place with wonderful pieces of jewelry and well priced. Run by truly professional people

Very positive experience talking with John, the owner, regarding his plethora of experience in the numismatic industry and enjoyed learning different view points and information.

Fantastic place! Very knowledgeable and friendly.

Had a great experience and made a very good deal!

Trusted Dealer A++

Bought our first 24 karat coin. Friendly staff, definitely will be our go to for fine jewelry and coins.

Good service, knowledgable staff.

Great place fair ppl for stackers

Fast and awesome service!!!

Great selection in coins!