Awesome place, love the natural flavors. We liked the pistachio, coffee and salted caramel.

Such a lovely, cozy little shop with incredible treats and delicious gelato. (NOTE: the PUMPKIN PIE GELATO IS SO FREAKIN GOOD!!!) The smoothest of lighting, music, and ambiance-- couldnt have asked for a more perfect place to stop on a drizzly, Fall evening :)

I had higher expectations for this place. The 3 flavors I got all tasted the same. It was cheap though, so that it was good at least.

Very good quality gelato, decent variety of flavors, waffle bowl was a nice option over the usual paper cup, friendly service, street parking, support your local small businesses 👍

A lovely place. Friendly prices for such good gelato!

Honestly, probably the best Gelato Ive ever had! I got 2 scoops -- Sea Salt Caramel and Dutch Chocolate.. it did not disappoint. Just one thing you want to do if you order 2 scoops in a cup (not a waffle cone), ask them to put it in the bigger bowl because mine was melting like crazy and kept dripping off the sides, almost got in my clothes at least 7 times while I was sitting down licking my ice cream like a maniac 🤣

Hands don the best gelato in town! Have been going here for years. They even have treats for your dog!

Pistachio tastes like a dream. Generous portions, friendly service at a fair price. Free samples too!

Great gelato. Exceptional service. A must if your in the fairhaven area!

DELICIOUS gelato, very friendly staff. Id mKe a special trip here any day!

I’m usually not a fan of chains, but this one is pretty good. Wish there were more adventurous flavor selections available. Their pistachio is actual pistachio, with tones of nuts, not just flavoring

We never miss stopping here!Hands down, the best.

We stopped for a cup (Dutch Chocolate + Salted Caramel) and sugar cone (Forest Berry) at Sirena Gelato. Wow, great, intense flavors in their gelato! The service is really friendly and fast. Prices are reasonable--1 scoop was $3.75 and 2 scoops was $4.50. They also allow you to have a taste of youre not sure what to get. While they dont have a huge selection of flavors (I would guess around 15), we never have a problem finding something we like. It is a fun and tasty stop in Fairhaven--well definitely be back. Now they just need to give out free dog treats (they did have a water dish out)!

Best gelato we have found so far in the Northwest after living here for 16 years. The choice of flavors is great, pistachio, organic hazlenut, coffee (strong!). They offer an espresso milkshake with gelato! Wish we lived closer!

My son and I absolutely love gelato. Im dairy free and we are both gluten free so it can be hard to find good gelato that we can both eat. This place is absolutely amazing! It tastes authentic and delicious. They have fruit flavors that are dairy free, and most of the options that were available were gluten free. Ive only been to one better shop and it was in Virginia. That was because the place in VA made gelato using almond milk and vegan chocolates but it tasted like regular gelato. If Sirena had a few more dairy free options they would be perfect, but at least they had a couple things I could eat!

My boyfriend and I love this place! It’s had us deciding we love gelato more than ice cream now.

Visited with my spouse and mother on Saturday. We all loved the flavors we selected. I got the salted caramel and Dutch chocolate, which were absolutely amazing, and we’ve had gelato all over the world.

The best gelato I’ve had even better than Paris or Rome. Super dense flavors. I had the pistachio and peach.

Their fruit flavors are among the best gelato flavors Ive had anywhere.

The vanilla and carmel gelato was amazing. The waffle bowl doesnt do it justice.

Fairhaven is a great place to be but a book from village books and some gelato from Sirenas is the best way to spend the afternoon.

Afternoon Affogato - yes please! The seasonal flavors are great and the chocolate affogato is delish.

Great gelato, good size portions. The dark cocoa flavor was the richest chocolate gelato I have ever had, including gelato in Italy.

Inviting atmosphere and wonderful Gelato, definitely a must see and taste for tourists and locals alike, though there are often 5+ people there in the tiny shop so be warned

Smalls include two scopes. You can have different flavors. They also do milkshakes, sell by the pint and ice cream sandwiches.

Great prices for absolutely delicious Gelato! Well be coming back for sure!

The ice cream here is so so yummy 😍😋 its so fresh and tastes so good. Cant wait to try all of their flavors 🙏

So good! And they have dog Gelato

Good ice cream, a bit pricey, nice staff offering free samples. Overall good experience.

Delicious!! I love dark chocolate gelato. Not every gelato place has it (even in Italy it was hard to find!) But Sirena had it and it did not disappoint! Also, they have dog gelato! How can you not love a place that serves gelato to your furry bestie?!

So yummy. Tried the Italian Chocolate Chip - Excellent.

Does not taste like Gelato. This place needs a lesson from Italians in New York

Always a nice treat to come here and wonderful girls at the counter.

The go-to place for great gelato. Big assortment of flavors and the staff is always friendly and accomodating! You wont be disappointed. 🍦🍧

You want to go out and get some ice cream? Forget that. Youre going to Sirenas gelato. This place has delicious gelato and very friendly people serving it. Never disappointed

Love their gelato!

2 DAIRY FREE OPTIONS AND DELICIOUS ONES

Nice large scoops!

Very welcoming people and tasty yummy treats. I well recommended that you should try it out. I like that they are across from my work.

This gelato rivals the best places in Italy.

Cute little gelato shop with a great selection of flavors!

Best frozen treat in town! This gelato is so smooth and the flavors are so intense! Do yourself a favor and buy a scoop or two...or three. You wont be disappointed

I lived in Italy for 4 years as a military brat and this is definitely the most comparable to REAL GELATO since Ive been back in America!

Customer service was fair. My daughter has a tree nut allergy and the staff member was visibly irritated by being asked to use a clean utensil to minimize cross contamination. Employee dont wear gloves when serving and there was something crunchy in my daughters gelato that wasnt supposed to be in it. Sketchy. Still not sure what it was. She didnt finish it.

Birthday cake and chocolate combo. Vegan Mango is tasty as well.

Delicious flavors! ❤

Sirena Gelato is amazing! Staff is extremely friendly and helpful with suggestions and having you taste all the different flavors before you decide which one to go with. The price is very reasonable compared to the amount you get per scoop. I tried the Rose Petal as well as the Vanilla flavors and both were just incredible, the Rose Petal specially. The flavor was so smooth not as all over powering and just the right amount of sweetness.

Nice hand made Gelato. Good assortment of flavours. I had a chocolate mint which was not too sweet like many are.Little pricey.

By far the best Gelato available! So excited that I can have it delivered to my front door, thank you Dairy Distributing for adding this to your home delivery.Ben

As always a delicious treat and great service. Sea salt caramel is so yummy, black cocoa tasted like brownie batter. Mango is always a favorite. The gals who work there are always smiling. Great after dinner dessert spot or random end to a lazy Sunday.

Wonderful every time go in!

The best ice cream! Especially the Hazelnut, don’t miss out :)

Tasty

Deeelicious!

We just love love love this place & always try to visit when we are that direction. Wonderful selection of flavours. My favourite so far is the Dutch chocolate, also the raspberry which feels like theres a little fizz to it & the thai coconut. You can get samples if your not sure about a certain flavor. The girl serving was helpful & had such a happy personality.

Lovely local place. Very good gelato, and they support the local community and good business practices. Charming and reasonably priced.

Excellent gelato. My favorite so far is the Black Cocoa (tastes like the cookie part of an Oreo), close second is Dutch Chocolate (richer flavor, but not as dark). Pistachio is a great companion to the chocolate. Cant wait to go back and try more flavors. Service is quick and polite.

Had the oreo gelato and it tasted like cardboard and dust. My friend got a different flavor(chocolate if I remember correctly) and it had the same problem.

Very tasty gelato. The sea salt caramel was really good. We got there just before a rush on a Saturday night and the service was good as well

Delicious. A date night staple. Tons of options for flavors, all of them quite good; I tend to go with the pan dolce (birthday cake) and Oreo. You can even get some to go. They offer a rewards stamps card as well that gets you a free dish for every eight dishes.

Incredibly delicious!

Great gelato, not too sweet. Friendly staff. The cons.. Too expensive and they always have the same dozen or so flavors.

Tasted great! Only downside was a big fat hair dig out of my cup of gelato, thankfully they replaced it with no extra cost

The best Gelato in Skagit Valley! These guys have awesome flavors and are always super friendly. Small dining space but usually clears out quick as people come and go. My favorite flavors are hazelnut, black cocoa, and rococo coffee. Their seasonal stuff is also always great!

Probably the best gelato I’ve ever had. Not only does it taste great but it’s also mesmerizing to look at. A nice little shop that is very cozy and inviting. 10/10 would recommend.

Great selection of wonderful flavors!

Very good gelato! The lime is a must have and so is the raspberry lemonade! The serving size was much larger than I expected. This will be a place I visit whenever I am in Bellingham! Street parking only, but its easy to find close by.

Go here and buy gelato! Dont ask questions. You will thank me later. There are interesting flavors, allowing for unique combinations, nice people who work there, and a small but clean bathroom.

Some of the best Gelato weve had in our world travels!

I have never had Gelato before but was very happy I had my first experience at Sirena! The staff were very friendly and personable and my shake was wonderful.

Love this place. Great staff and amazing gelato.

The best gelato in Bellingham. Every flavor I try is amazing. Pistachio made with 2 pounds in every batch. Fruit ones that are lactose-free and fat-free. A must try.

Love this stuff! Delicious hand made gelato (think richer, less air ice cream).

Delicious icecream! Prices are fair!

Yummy treats, and prompt friendly service.

It is always a pleasure to visit Sirena Gelato. The staff seem to turn over regularly but they are always cheerful and eager to help. I have been in the shop when there were only two of us and when the line ran out the door, but always felt that they were operating efficiently. The wait was never long. The gelato has always been good quality, and consistent. Excellent gelato is hard to find in Italy, most of the shops are franchises and quality is mediocre at best. Sirena has them beat. I am always surprised that they close at 9:00 on hot summer nights.

This place is incredible. The best gelato Ive ever had in my life. It was a great experience.

Simply fantastic. A nice pitstop while walking fairhaven. If youre lucky youll find a nice dog or two outside you can pet while enjoying your gelato!

This is some of the best gelato Ive ever had! Would definitely recommend, my family and I always stop by when were in the Fairhaven area.

The Gelato is to Die For.

Great little gelato shop! We stopped in the way back from Whistler in the summer. Great flavors and a very pleasant staff.

Great coffee and gelato! Always a must visit when Im in the area.

The Gelato is so fresh and creamy dreamy

Really great service! Gelato was great

Love their gelato! And they are generous with their samples.

Very good Got the mango, oreo, and berry flavor

Super yummy! Especially the dark chocolate!

Yumtown

Everything was good except they didnt have regular cups. Paper cups usually leave bad after taste

Very nice and hospitable. Yummy gelato . great location.

Have been to Italy. Does not compare. This is the best gelato. Mind blown. I know the person that makes their gelato. They use only premium ingredients. The server, Hannah, is the best :) Ask her for the inside scoop ;)

The girl who helped us was very friendly and gelato was delicious

Snowing and customers still want gelato, oreo cookies was very good.

5 dairy free options & they are delicious!

Best place to go. Prices could be a little cheaper but overall great.

Delicious gelato! Four scoops for $6.50, gotta love it!

Love, love, love this place! They have the best variety of gelato flavors and a clean, nicely-decorated shop.

A must-have when touring Fairhaven! The pistachio is great.

Best Gelato place I have been to in a long time! The peach flavor tastes like buying into the freshest juiciest peach ever..

Very good gelato. Good variety of flavors and friendly employees. Not much indoor seating though.