The fudge was absolutely fantastic. Ice cream was delicious as well and I was blown away by the variety of flavors to choose from. My kids both gave it a giant thumbs up and can’t wait to come back. 10/10 highly recommend!

One of my favorite ice cream shops in Indiana. Worth a stop anytime I am in Madison. Good selection, good product, and generous scolps!

Best icecream Ive ever had! They knew how every flavor tasted, and suggestions to mixing flavors. Thanks guys!

Great flavor, great place, large servings... these were triples... probably should’ve got the double. The cherry chunk was awesome.

We got ice cream,fudge and popcorn and it was all excellent. We will definitely go back.

Same ice cream, different management and they just DGAF. The two teenage boys acted like they were high. Couldnt remember our order for two minutes without asking, “uh…what did you order?” At check out we asked for a large box of Chicago style popcorn. The cashier said, “What? I wasn’t listening.” Good lord. LARGE. CHICAGO. POPCORN. He walks over to the popcorn (15’ away), turns around, and says, “Did you say caramel corn?” NEVER GOING BACK.

Theyll scoop more ice cream onto yor cone than should legally be allows to call one scoop. Try the lemon!

Great ice cream and large portions. Friendly staff.

Great service and excellent flavors!! My kids love going here and then taking a stroll along the river!

1st time here, excellent. Clean, timely, and not exspensive at all. Their cookie monster ice cream is a MUST.

My daughter loves there ice cream.

Customer service was as good as the ice cream!! :)

Great little ice cream shop. I definitely recommend the salty caramel toffee!!

Handling cash and ice cream/cones without washing hands nor wearing gloves. I walked out when I saw that. This is an obvious health code violation in my mind.

Very expensive but fun atmospheres and decent ice cream

If youre going to have a try homemade fudge sign outside, then you may want to actually have more than one type of fudge. Not impressed..

Great ice cream. Good service and friendly workers.

Really good ice cream and large servings!

We enjoyed our stop on a hot day! Plenty of flavors to choose from and the girl working let us sample a couple so we could pick with confidence. The price is about average for this kind of place. We took home some popcorn to enjoy on the drive home too. Madison is a lovely town to visit and this should be one of your stops, for sure!

Oh my goodness! So much ice cream and such a great price!

It was great. Small town feel with a lot of bang for your buck

Just tried the Buckeye Blitz ice cream and it was incredible!

Large selection of ice cream and homemade fudges. Black raspberry truffle is beyond wonderful.

Fudge and ice cream large serving

Lots of variety on ice cream flavors ! Plus the fudge and popcorn ! What else could you need gonna warm night !?!

Nice local place for ice cream

The ice cream cones were comically huge. Tasted great, friendly service. It was too much though. Threw more than half of my ice cream away.

Great ice cream and banana splits

The ice cream is awesome and they have so many different flavors. The employees were also very friendly!

The popcorn is awesome! Dont overlook it!

Sweeeet

Love these old time ice cream shops. The people (probably the owners) working the counter gave the best customer service. We will be back. Great place to stop in Madison after hiking the trails.

We tried to visit a local spot but although their hours said they were open until 8pm, they were closed.

I got pistachio and Cookie monster ice cream in a waffle cone. It was delicious 10/10 would eat again

Pretty simple menu but everything tasted great. Employees were kind.

Very a good selection of flavors. Shop was clean,and the staff was excellent.

Delicious and great service

Wonderful 👍👍

Good icecream

Amazing ice cream! Helpful staff, too. I highly recommend their seasonal Buckeye Blitz to peanut butter & chocolate lovers.

The service was very good and friendly, good variety of ice cream selection.

I didnt go in but my daughters did, for both of them to get ice cream, one in a cup and one on a cone, 2 scoops each, was right at $10. That seems very high to me.

Wow! I hit the jackpot with their dark chocolate ice cream shake, recommended to me just before closing by the employee. (Not too dark - probably around 55%??) I have to say it was probably the best shake Ive ever had. Very sugary for sure, and had to scoop out the extra dark chocolate chunks at the end from the bottom of the cup.

Great ice cream, plus really good selection. Employee was very nice & helpful, she let us try several kinds before getting the one we all wanted.

Best customer service, awesome ice cream!!

Tasty Ice cream, out on the sidewalk! Covid 2020

Best place downtown for some delicious ice cream. Very affordable and sizeable portions as well!

This is a must stop hole in the wall ice cream store on Main Street in Madison (oh yesss! Main Street is alive and well in Madison, IN!). They have so many flavors to choose from! Pro-tip—if you’re with your SO, buy the three scoop banana split! You get to choose three flavors of ice cream, toppings, etc. and it’s cheaper than two individual cones AND you get the romance/adventure of splitting a sundae on Main Street.

It was Great

Awesome!

We 💛 Scoops!So family friendly, and affordable.They have many flavors of real icecream to choose from.Plus they sell fudge, and different flavors of popcorn.

Awesome place! The line moved fast

There are a few places to get ice cream in town but I really really like this place because their scoops of ice cream are pretty big, plus, of course, the ice cream is delicious (the reason the scoop size is important:). I always get strawberry! The texture of it is slightly soft (just a smidge) & I like that.

Great hand dipped ice cream!

Employees were on top of things! It was very busy and they got us through very quickly. Ice cream was amazing!

Me and my wife and our son came into town trying to find ice cream for a good price and very friendly place? And boy did we find it!!! The owners were so nice and polite!!!

Me &my girlfriend HEIDI.WE went there for the 1stTIME &their ice cream is very very 👍 GOOD!!! AND ALSO HAD A GREAT TIME THERE

Amazing ice cream. Friendly service. Maybe a touch pricey.

Very generous scoop of ice cream and a great many flavors.

The service was so great the ice cream was great i forgot the ladies name this sunday but she had great coustomer service thank you very much i recommended

The service was amazing there was only one person working but she got us our ice cream in an exceptional amount of time.

This place is the best ice cream shop downtown in my opinion. So many flavors to choose from and the amount of ice cream you get for the price is spectacular . I also love their fudge and caramel popcorn . will always choose scoops Ive cream over any other downtown ice cream.

Was so good, came back for a second helping! Good sized scoops and some fun flavors. The staff has us laughing while serving us.

Loved this place! Great prices, wide selection, wonderful service. Definitely stop in and try it out.

Awesome ice cream shoppe in Madison, Indiana, especially for Diabetics!! Sugar-free ice cream available!!!!! Its sooooo good!! Fiancé had a cherry-vanilla, and I a butter pecan. Scrumptious both of them!! Cold a/c too on a 96F degree day!! Win-win-win! Well stop in again anytime we visit.

My baby girl is forever on the wall! I love this place.

Large portions. Great price. Service was excellent!!

Superman wasnt superman i was very upset .Drove 50 miles

Very good and fair prices! Not a whole lot of seating and the atmosphere could be better, but its a cute little shop and Ive been a few times and will visit more when Im in the area!

Great ice cream. Great service. Friendly folks...everyone who works there.

Best banana spit ever. U can choose ur own icecream. WILL BE BACK!!!!!

Wow. Great ice cream! Fast service.

Great Ice Cream, Black Raspberry Truffle.

Me and my family go here all the time for our ice cream usually we get it and head to the river to the park the prices and amount u get are way better than the red peppermint we usually spend about 13 dollars for 4 or 5 of us its clean cheap and they have soooo many choices to choose from its by far our favorite ice cream place in town just wish they could get the playdoh ice cream back it was a huge hit with our family

Generous portions. Excellent ice cream!

Great ice cream, popcorn and service

Fast service. Great icecream

Mike did gooood

Awesome atmosphere and absolutely delicious!

Great selection. Friendly staff. Yummy ice cream. Flavored popcorn too.

Great ice cream, I intend to go back and sample the fudge and popcorn.

Never had bad experience here, great service!

Delicious ice cream and good value for the price. Always friendly staff.

Great ice cream & service too...always good ! Great quiet Lil place...

Great ice cream, generous portions, good prices, and excellent service!

Quick friendly service, love visiting here when we come down this way!

Great place, decent selection, nice people. Also got popcorn for those who like it.

Ice cream was great! Lots of smiling faces

Oh my goodness....three words....Buckeye Ice Cream!!!

The best ice cream in town, plus a selection of delicious fudge and flavored popcorn

Amazing ice cream shop with 32 different kinds!

Its great I recommend Fudge Brownie Blitz

The gentleman offered a milkshake of his Teo favorite ice cream Chocoblast and raspberry truffle by far best milkshake ever great place friendly staff

Good Ice cream and good people!

Great quality ice cream & fast, friendly service

Great shakes and ice cream. Very good prices on the shakes

Icecream is delicious 100% reccomend!!! great texture and flavour!!

Good ice cream, but store-bought cones.

It was the best icecream ive ever had.

Great ice cream and service, Repeat customer.