An absolute gem! I am in love with this store and its staff. I love their wrapping paper and gigantic card selection! I just bought the best planner and fun sticker book set for myself to prepare for this upcoming school year. Couldn’t recommend this place more!

I absolutely love this store and am excited its in Madison! I had been to this store at the Mall of America and loved the unique items!!

Visual display of merchandise and plexiglass at counter had me feeling safe. Items vary in price from 1.99 to $40. The store has items for children, adults, decorating and holidays. Very understanding when I needed to return item. The quality of the paper goods is outstanding!

This is my go-to place for quirky, fun, surprising gifts. If you love over paying for whimsical-ness, this is the place for you. Its a cute, comforting place that I love to spend time in, but I will always go over my gift budget. I can never get anything for myself either, because who can spend $25 on a notebook for themselves? A visual delight, but not a financial one.

Cute store! Always stop when in Madison.

Great seasonal cards, mediocre birthday cards (only a few funny ones) and thank you cards...the selection wasnt big enough.

Well stocked, high quality merchandise. Friendly, helpful staff.

There are many things here you cant find anywhere else.

So glad to be able to visit the shop again. Online us fine, but the store is fun, staff helpful. Enjoyed it!

What a delight of a store for great cards, and they are made in America. I would have given a five stars, but I did not like the deal buy one and get the other half off. I wish for simpler pricing, not up-selling.

Absolutely adore Paper Source. Its got the best selection of cards and gifts. While their prices are a little higher than other places, the quality of service and gifts you get there, especially if shopping last minute, is worth the few dollars more that youd spend.When it comes to their greeting cards, they have some of the funniest and some of the most heartfelt cards you can find, and so much more unique than just the standard Hallmark or Walgreens fare. There are even some featured by local or regional artists.

Excellent selection. So helpful. I called prior to my visit. Great quality and the BEST service from Salima. Extremely conscientious regarding masks and hand sanitizer at contact-less checkout. Thank you Paper Source.

Great selection and friendly staff ☺️

Christmas items 50% off, the sign they had up read. However, when I was about to pay I realized I was being charged regular price for Christmas ribbon! That tripled the total I was supposed to pay. This place is a ripoff. They did not respect the sale so I ended up buying only one item to make sure they respected the 50% off. They should be ashamed. The girl with long black hair was pretty rude. There are better places with unique paper around.

Has fun little gifts that people probably hardly buy. The cards and other gift wrap items are really cool and they have quite a selection.

Great place for interesting gifts and stocking stuffers. I can easily spend an hour in this store.

Such fun and interesting items in this store. First class paper products and many creative uses. Purchased wedding invites from them and they did a fantastic job.

Even though its a chain store...each one is always different. Love the patterned paper choices! So much variety; unique itms, cards, craft items, card making supplies, gifts for any occasion. One of my favorite stores!

This is a solid place to get cards and decorative paper. Prices tend to run a little high, so stick to a few items.

Spent $50 on balloons at 5pm for my son’s birthday and all the regular balloons were barely hovering above the floor at 6am the next morning. Not a very great surprise and not a very happy momma. For $4/plain balloon there’s no reason those aren’t flying high 12 hours later.

Had both great service and very bad service at this location. Good selection for a small store. Unfortunately, very overpriced for the quality for a lot of items (stamps, balloons, etc.)

This is a wonderful source for your paper needs. They have a ast array of cards, stationery, wrapping paper and other unique paper producrs. The staff is attentative, and is ready to help. While on the pricy side, you get what you pay for. There is free parking nearby. They are worth the visit!

Fantastic! So many fun items. I didnt want to leave

I love everything about Paper Source. Great products. Knowledgeable and friendly staff. Totally a treat to shop here.

Excellent selection of stationery plus great gift ideas. Helpful customer service

Nice and a little pricey

Plenty of pun-based products. 10/10.

Wonderful shop!

Great gifts!

Cards cards and more cards

Beautiful place although a bit expensive