Great icecream good prices!

Amazing and very surprising!! Great ice cream and boy do they pack in it into the cups! Highly recommend!

The Ice cream is absolutely phenomenal! Ive recommended Mr. Goodies to quite a few people and they all agree. Theyve got something for everyone. Give them a shot while the weather isnt too cool. You wont regret your decision.

Cute place, pretty great ice cream. Went to a 4 year olds birthday party, and they only had 1 high chair but our group had more than one baby. Clean establishment, and they have a chalkboard wall that the kids really enjoyed..

Best non dairy ice cream you must try the midnight oreo

I moved to Virginia from Massachusetts 16 years ago and though, generally speaking, all the ice cream Ive tasted has been good, I was really happy with the quality That Mister Goodies presents. I would highly recommend it.

Very clean. Very fast. Helped with different flavors that taste amazing. And not hard on the pocket.

I love the flavor options! FYI the flight basically serves 3 or 4 so dont order solo, LOL!

Delicious. Fun with my friends. Vegan options. Outdoor seating available.

Really good scoop ice cream, huge portions, friendly staff

Solid homemade ice cream that is definitely sweetened by first Friday of the month BOGO deal 😜

The place was clean and the employees friendly. There were more choice if ice cream flavors than in many other ice cream shops. The portion sizes were good to great, and I saw that they had on offer a flight of four flavors to try. The first day employee was also doing well right out of the gate. The only thing I might say was that the menu board looked a little busy, but overall, that is a minor thing.

Amazing hard scoop ice cream!! Cant go wrong with most flavors.

Best ice cream in Lynchburg! The only problem is limiting myself to a small and choosing only 2 flavors 😃 Sea Salt Truffle, Mocha Chip, and Chocolate Insanity are my top favorites! Will keep coming back as often as my wife will let me 😅

Very nice establishment with a great variety. The presentation was nice but the employees werent welcoming. Ice cream was yummy!

Delicious no matter the time of year! Fantastic selection, including Dairy Free, plus a staff that has a smile and ready to put one on your face too. Cant beat it!

Great ice cream with 6 non dairy varieties to choose from. Perfect texture. Always evolving and coming up with new flavors.

Incredible place! Went yesterday afternoon and got the White Chocolate truffle its FABULOUS! Prices are responsible and the staff is so friendly as well. Thanks for the help and nice to meet a fellow Marylander Richard!!!

The ice cream was absolutely delicious and they had so many different flavors to choose from. My favorite part though was the amount of ice cream you get. A first glance at the prices makes it seem a little steep, but when they hand you your small which has three heaping scoops in it, you realize you are certainly getting your moneys worth! I highly recommend giving this place a try! You wont be disappointed.

Delicious ice cream place with a great variety of flavors. They even had non dairy ice cream so my wife could have some, and it was actually really good! The place itself was clean, and the staff was very friendly. The owner even let my wife try out a new non dairy recipe he was working on while we were deciding.

Incredible home made flavors and all look very good!! We just moved from Florida and treated ourselves after a great Labor Day weekend.The staff is very friendly and patient while we decided. Sample flavors really help!We will be back! The 03 flavor is such a great mix of coffee, chocolate, cookie dough, and yummy!! My wife had a banana cream pie and it was really good. Our daughter had Brookie which is really good chocalate mixed with cookie dough and brownie.

Wonderful flavour and creamy richness. Three of us went out, all had a different flavour, and all were amazing.

Literally almost best in town. As good as ROOKIES. loved the service here and their ice cream is deliciously homemade you can taste it. Their serving size is enormous. Large will kill you small is just right :)

The ice cream was very good. Compared to the other location with soft serve on Timberlake Rd. the size you get and the price you pay for it appears to be a little off. Got the banana cream pie ice cream and it tasted perfectly like it’s name. Was delicious. Chocolate tased like a good rich chocolate almost like a brownie batter. Cookie dough was pretty good as well.

I got the mocha ice cream and it wasnt mocha it was chocolate ugh other than that it was good

A more traditional style icecream parlor, they offer a wide variety of flavors, many of which they make themselves. It is good ice cream, and large servings, but they are a little more expensive than I like. Still, for an every once in a while treat, it is a great place to go.

Great customer service. Top notch. Good pricing. Good tasting unique homemade ice cream. Make sure you check out there other location for some awesome soft serve.

Clean nice people worth the wait anytime. Prices are good. A good place for a family night.

Hand made ice cream, need I say more. I love banana and they have a banana cream pie ice cream that is to die for! Im always temped to try something else, but for right now thats all I want!

Delicious, creamy ice cream in a wide variety of flavors, with a handful of dairy free options. Definitely worth a stop if youre in the area!

Definitely the best homemade ice cream in the area!

So many flavors to choose from this is one of the best ice cream shops and they are a smal business. Dont forget to tip the workers they are polite and give great service soft served with smiles!!

Perfect ice-cream, good price, fun times! My favorite is the orange sherbet 😃 This is the place to keep cool and beat the heat!

Love this place. Really good ice cream and comfortable place to eat indoors. The Turtle Pecan flavor is great.😊

Everything there is amazing. Cinnamon buns are HUGE and delicious. Im addicted to the donuts. Love this place

GREAT ICE CREAM. Friendly staff. My favorite chocolate peanut butter cup ice cream around. 😊

Fantastic Ice Cream! The other Mister Goodies seems to be mostly soft serve, but the Ice Cream at this location is homemade and tastes amazing!

Best Ice Cream in Lynchburg! Go to this location instead of the one on Timberlake. You can watch them make their blends. The blends are awesome! Chocolate Insanity is my favorite!!

I had the Black Cherry Italian Ice. It was delicious, the price was right, and the service was great.

Fast, friendly staff. Delightful flavours. Ample portions. Butter Pecan is amazing.

Good pricing, good quality ice cream. Staff not knowledgeable in product ingredients. Overall fun place

I absolutely love this place, the Rivermont is an amazing dark chocolate ice cream, and I get it every time. Generous portions, too!

Homemade ice cream with many interesting and unique flavors. It was so hard to choose. And great prices too!

The value is good and its nice to visit with other folks you meet there

Amazing ice cream. So many flavors!! I got the Rivermont and it was one of the best ice creams I have ever had! 😄👍

You will not go wrong getting ice cream from here

Great homemade hard ice cream! Nice place to sit inside and out.

Homemade ice cream. Lots of flavors. Plenty of seating. Clean and inviting.

It is a great place to enjoy ice cream their friendly staff makes the experience even better delicious homemade ice cream!!!!!

Nice servers. Great ice cream. Great experience.

Yummy ice cream in generous servings across a wide variety of flavors with ample seating. Great for bumping into friends in the neighborhood!

Good ice cream and good choices, I love the homemade whip cream

Their ice cream is delicious and the service is great!! If you like flavors, then this is the place for you.

Ice cream was really good! I got a brownie sundae and split it. It was still a lot of ice cream for the price.

My absolute favorite ice cream! Homemade and so many options for chocolate lovers!

Fair to middling ice cream. While I do appreciate the homemade aspect of the shop, the ice cream has not special taste. My family stopped in and everyone got what the wanted. Peach, Rivermont, Some chocolate overboard, etc. and when we finished not a wow, great in the reviews, simply, it was ok.Specifically the peach ice cream needs more peach flavor/bits. While you can taste peach in the ice cream, peach ice cream should burst like a summer peach. The Rivermont (pretty sure that was the name) said it was chocolate and caramel, While you could definitely taste the chocolate, there was no hint of caramel. My strawberry shake had bits of chocolate chips in it. While the shake was nice and thick, the bits of chocolate in a strawberry shake, when not asked for, was a bit of a shock.All in all could be a very nice ice cream shop, if they could just increase the flavor to the flavors.

Their ice cream is always amazing! They like to throw some strange ones in there sometimes but they have so many options for us more conservative ones haha

Best ice cream EVER!!! Everyone in the group got something different and ever selection was a real winner!! Big portions of great ice cream at a good price.

Extremely friendly folks, ice creams good too!

A slightly less expensive version of coldstone. Very good but still a little more expensive than I would like.

Good ice cream but way overpriced !

Very good ice cream the peach is the bomb

Great hand dipped ice creams. Big selection of flavors.

Wonderful variety, excellent value and nice staff. We come as often as we can.

We tried Mister Goodies for my daughters birthday and we loved it.

Delicious ice cream! Amazing selection! Ice cream lovers Haven!

The ice cream is fantastic and the staff is always happy to serve! This is the only ice cream parlor worth coming to.

Place is horrible. Never going back there again. Even the kids hated it

Great homemade icecream, not too pricey. Great staff.

Try the ooey gooey, yummmm :P very clean too

Love the mocha chip. Big servings, good price.

So good. You have to try it

The most delicious ice cream in Lynchburg, Va

Their cake batter ice cream is so good! My fav!

Brownie sundaes are huge and delicious!!! Had to take half of it home :)

Fun family atmosphere. Delicious homemade ice cream.

The new eggnog is fantastic!!! Love, love, love. Now waiting for candy Andy cane!!!

Wide variety of flavors and great portion size. Always fun to see what they will come up with next.

Wonderful ice cream and great staff

Best ice cream in town. I dont like any other ice cream but Mister Goodies! 😀

Wonderful handmade ice cream! Best place in town!

Really good Ice cream and a good price. This place really is a gem.

Not bad. Different variety.

Delicious, creamy ice cream. Lots of flavors.

Good ice cream but its kinda overpriced. The Mr.Goodies soft serve is better.

Very good place to get some icecream

Best ice cream in town but everyone already knows that!

Always have a great experience when I go

Best ice cream in town, huge portions, very friendly staff, always a treat!!!

I go here every friday with a couple friends. You get so much for your money and they constantly have new flavors.

Yum yum yum. Best ice cream in Lynchburg.

Amazing ice cream and excellent service!

Love all the choices they have very creative

Courteous, competent server, clean premises, tasty ice cream.

Best icecream around...period

I have never been here but did drive through this parking lot

Good ice cream and service.

Great.

Always good ice cream

Love the ice cream n service