I cannot express how impressed I was with this shop. Over the years I have visited many coin shops in Indy. This shop was by far the friendliest of them all. There’s so much to look at. The staff was very nice and educated me on every item I brought with me today. 10/10 recommend .

Fair, friendly, family business. We have always found the staff to be knowledgeable and very helpful in providing accurate information on pricing. We visit often and highly recommend this shop.

A great place to find out how much your old coins are worth and to buy old coins

Nice coin shop but they know little about grading coins

VERY FRIENDLY . Marvelous variety of coins and precious metals . FAIR pricing . Highly recommend!!

Dont bring anything old to this place. Its a coin shop not a collector and they are there to make bank. I wasnt trying to sell I just wanted fair assessment.What I got was condesending and in my opinion uneducated. Therefor they will not give true value to seller because they cant make money on it.

I have 40 coins for 2005 speared bison Jefferson nickel

I went to the lost Dutchman coin shop first because online they said they where the “primer” coin shop in the Indianapolis area well that was not true at all didn’t have anything in the few display case that they had in the smallest coin shop I have ever been to also not very friendly employees working there so I drove to the south side of Indianapolis I live in “fishers” to the coin index I wasn’t expecting much since I went to what was called the best coin shop around the first time but was pleasantly surprised by what I saw the place is big and lots of cases full on coins also they have a big showroom that is clean and nice looking compared to other coin shop I have been to around the country I would recommend the coin index to anyone buying or selling coins

I found their card in my dads things when he passed away. They gave me an honest appraisal of everything for the probate court and when the time came, have me a fair price for the coins I chose to sell. I highly recommend them.

This place had Gold and silver for sale when other place in town don’t have it or won’t sell it and their price are comparable to ampex and JM bullion and if they don’t have what you are looking for they will order it for you

Bought some coins from them today prices where good for what I wanted to spend to fill some holes in my coin collection I will definitely be back my new favorite coin shop

I been a collector for as long as I can remember I’m about to be 19 I love how much Knowledge they have on everything they have my one problem is there Prices for some things but some of the Friendliest and kindest people I know but when I go there I don’t really mind the price because I know whatever I get is going to be legit

Recently sold old coin collection. This business is very well organized and clean location. Prices quoted were above my estimated. I recommend this business to anyone buying or selling coins or precious metals.

I was left a coin collection from an estate. The people here were happy to help and were very fair and reasonable. I would definitely recommend coming here for your coin needs.

First time in the coin index to buy some 1 once silver coins good price and good service when I came in they where really busy they greeted me when I can in and said they would be with me in a few minutes I had to wait about 20 minutes but it was worth it thanks andy for answering all my questions even though there where more people behind me waiting for help see you soon

Starting from my first impression; I felt like I could be comfortable, that I wasnt being juked, or taken advantage of through deception or high pressure sales tactics . In fact, to be straight with you, I was given a quote far more fair than I expected (I knew what that grey sheet they pulled out said before they rattled off their figures). The husband and wife team; are quite the impressionable, business savvy, and down to earth couple you could ever expect to do honest, and integrity thorough business with . The veteran of the shop and gentlemans name who slips my mind at the moment, my apologies to him. Keeps me so focused on his wealth of information and adept perception on numismatic and worldly experience, in and through his lifetime in the business and still to this very day. intact remains a Pentacle of wealthy hearted, and people I will always pride myself and recommend to my friends, my grandmother ( rest her soul), and my children after me . In numismatics you do it right the first time, no shop follows my guideline more so than they do . Thank you to the owners, the old timer, the puppy dog, and there bright, young, and cheerful new employee . Thanks for the 2 pounds of world coin, Indian heads, barber 1/2 & 1/2 s, walkers, and cull seated today ! See you soon! 👍✌️

Hands down the best around. Friendly, knowledgeable staff, great selection, almost always everything I’m looking for all in one place.

Sold my dads coin collection to them their price for my dads coins where way more than the other place on the east side of Indianpolis I would recommend everyone to check out The Coin Index they are very nice and easy to deal with

They are very knowledgeable and they taught me a lot. I recommend everyone to go there!

Several dozen deals with the friendly staff now. Over roughly a year and a half’s time . Honestly, I feel like I’ve been taken care of as a priority and it was a far cry from the profit margin merchants in general asses . They don’t stare through you like your invaluable to them or insignificant rather .. oddly enough, is all to common amongst my dealings with other “reputable “ establishments. I won’t go anywhere else, nor will my peers.

Nice clean safe place and the coins are fun to look at to

Ive had nothing but friendly and knowledgeable people help me at the Coin Index. All are very friendly and answer any and all questions you have. I give them a thumbs up!

They have the best selection Ive found in Indy. Prices are hit or miss compared to Hoosier Gold Buyer. You just dont know until you look for yourself.

Nice people and a ok environment

I have bought and sold coins to the coin index and have completely satisfied

A++++, quality and service above the rest!

Good place to go for coins

Lowballed me on proof coins. Only got silver price could have gone to pawn shop. they make 40 bucks on my coin. Also, I was actually refered to this place by the pawn shop down the road. go figure.

The staff here was very helpful and made my first time buying just a great experience! Thanks Coin Index!

The prices are way too high for buying. Everything is way above red book value

Probably the worst coin shop I have ever been in. Would barely give us the time of day and obviously did not want to do business. If you want a professional coin dealer go somewhere else and steer clear of this guy!

Nice informative staff.

If a 6 star was available They would get it. Go There

Best Coin Shop around