Recent newly wed here!! My husband and I are so happy we chose Kesslers Diamonds for not only my engagement ring but also our wedding bands. Michelle at the Brookfield location went above and beyond at every step of the selection and buying process and she made it so easy and simple for us. I wouldnt go anywhere else for my fine-jewelry needs!

Kesslers has been more than accommodating in so many ways. They have been extremely kind and have made our experience better than beyond our wildest dreams. Hope, our consultant, has taken the time to work with us and has never made us feel rushed or inconvenient (even when we have returned 4 times before making a decision!). I cannot say enough great things!!

Your agent Jessica was simply awesome very knowledgeable best experience Ive had in jewelry publishing

I am not one to take the time to write reviews, but I had to after the excellent experience I had with Sara S. at Kesslers Brookfield. I purchased a pair of diamond earrings from Kesslers a few years ago and decided to trade them in to create a ring that Id been eyeing for awhile. My husband and I met with Sara and after seeing a picture of the ring, she was able to recommend one that was exactly what I was looking for. A few weeks later, I picked up the ring and was blown away. It is stunningly beautiful and I cant stop looking at it. My husband said that it looks better than he could have ever imagined. I am so thankful for the wonderful customer service that Sara provided helping me find my dream ring. If you are looking to purchase jewelry and top-notch service, you will not be disappointed with Sara S. at Kesslers Brookfield. Thank you for everything, Sara! You have a customer for life!!

Wow!!! Such great customer service!!! Jessica assisted my fiance and I with choosing a ring, and her patience and guidance with us was wonderful. She knew exactly how to bring out the direction we were going, while giving us plenty of options for the style we were looking for. But wait, theres more... The follow up phone calls and emails were over the top. Jessica was amazing, and we couldnt have made such a great choice without her. Shell be our go to in the future.

My husband and I worked with Sara at Kesslers in Brookfield to create custom Anniversary bands for my wedding ring. Sara was very professional and I felt like she really listened to me. The design I wanted was simple and instead of going straight to custom order she offered me several other in-stock options that would have saved me money. In the end they were not quite what I was looking for so she helped draw up the custom order and made me aware in advance that it would be more than the budget amount I originally set. I didnt really know what to put for my budget originally so in the end the price wasnt an issue. But, for those with a true set budget it Im sure they would appreciate knowing up front, and having other options presented. Sara did both.The rings came out exactly as I hoped.I did run into one small snag because I added 2 rings and soldered them to my existing ones. The bands ened up being just a bit too snug on my finger once they were all together. It was not an error on Kesslers part. It was an unforeseen issue because of my design. I called Sara and she got me in the same day to send the rings back for resizing- no fee. I got them back this week and they are perfect.

We had an excellent experience at Kesslers. We originally purchased our engagement ring there back in 2004. 17 years later my wife lost a small diamond on the band. We returned to have it replaced for free. While scheduling the warranty repair, I was able to work with Sara Schieg on upgrading our center diamond. They were so helpful and gave me credit for the amount we paid for the original diamond. We ended up having to ship the diamond to the Madison location so I could surprise my wife when she went to pick up her ring. The entire staff in Madison was super helpful as well. They all did an amazing job and my wife was overjoyed with the new diamond.

Stacey was exceptionally accommodating. No pressure, well informed. Purchased diamond ring for our 29th wedding anniversary. Stacey made sure the memory of the day would last in my wife’s mind. Roses, wine, anniversary glasses were all set prior to our arrival in the store. One of the staff (sorry) I did not get name, took picture’s while I escorted my wife into the store blindfolded. Can’t say enough about Kesslers Diamonds and the staff who made my moment to be the knight and shinning armor to my wife on our 29th anniversary……..thank you ❤️

My fiancé and I were in today with our 2 1/2 year old daughter along with myself on crutches so it was not ideal to say the least. Saying that, the experience was perfect! They gave my daughter a big plastic ring that lit up to wear, was very accommodating to me. I needed my engagement ring resized which was free from purchasing it there years ago. We both also left with our wedding bands picked out and ordered. Sara S. was amazing and helped tremendously. ❤

I worked with Sara for a couple months trying to find the perfect ring and she was so patient and found the ring for me. Sara doubled checked on me and was extremely excited every time she worked with me. I highly recommend working with her.

What a joke.... a meteorite ring a diamond cooked in an oven.... plasma chamber.... wow what a gimmick.... 81 cuts???? Only cuz its a waste of cash.... wake up

Your entire staff is awesome especially Michelle! My wife is happy so that means I am happy, in other words you guys are doing a great job! Michelle is excellent at knowing what my wife wants. I won’t deal with anybody but her.

This was one of the best customer experiences I have ever had. I cannot say enough good things about Sara and the way she helped my fiancé and I with our diamond purchase. Between our phone calls and emails, she went above and beyond helping secure a wide range so that when we came in to view them, we had a plethora to look at. She took her time to understand what we wanted and made the entire experience so fun and exciting. (Not to mention, she helped make sure we could receive the ring before we left for a trip.) I would recommend her 100 times over!

Its nice to know as I get older and my ring finger changes they take the old tungsten carbide ring and just give me a new one a couple of weeks later. Just walk in check the size then leave. Very simple.

Jessica is the best! She is patient and provided me with the diamond education I asked for. She is friendly and creative. I’ve purchased several pieces of diamond jewelry in the past few years. Always with Jessica!

This is my first time writing a Google Review as I was that disappointed with the lack of customer service by a particular sales associate. My husband and I recently went to look for rings and necklaces to celebrate a special occasion. Being from Chicago, I had never heard of this store, so I asked if we could stop by. The young woman sitting in the front of the store was very nice, however, when introduced to the sales associate, Sara, she had an attitude that suggested she thought we couldn’t afford to buy anything in this store. I’m disappointed, but hope that Sara has made some good sales with other customers.

Always extremely happy with the service especially working with Michelle. She is great! Alway very personable and great customer service. Highly recommend.

I will never recommend another jeweler. My entire experience with Kesslers at multiple WI locations has always been great (I work near Brookfield so that is my most visited branch), customer service is second to none and they make everything so easy. I will never go anywhere else.

Did you know that Obiden closed the border to Canada but has let in 1.2 million people from the southern border. Putting them on planes trains and automobiles and moving them to the interior

Sarah was awesome! Really enjoyed her helping us. My finance was very impressed with her helping him pick out an engagement ring. Very personable and knowledgable. Very cool! Thanks Sarah!

My husband and I are always pleased when we leave Kesslers. The staff is so friendly and make you feel welcome.

Keslers was very helpful when I needed to get a larger size ring when my knuckle got bigger making it nearly impossible to remove. Kessler’s offered free resizing since it was bought from them, and was sent to the manufacturer to replace with a larger size.After two weeks I received a call from Kessler’s saying that my ring style was no longer available so they offered the option to choose a new ring at a comparable price at no charge, or upgrade and pay the balance. I ordered a new ring from Lashbrook since they didn’t carry Artcarved rings anymore. After choosing a style and the customization I wanted the order was placed and I was told it would take up to six weeks because each ring was custom made. The Lashbrook website said each ring takes 3-5 weeks to produce, so I was expecting a call in less than six weeks that the ring was ready. The ring came in exactly six weeks and two days from the date it was ordered. I’m expecting that due to covid and the holiday that fell within within that timeframe the ring took longer than expected. Overall, I’m very happy with the staff and support received and I love the new ring!

The staff was so warm, inviting and as excited for my purchase as I was. I wont go anywhere else for my diamonds. I adore Mitzi!

My sales associate was Hope and I highly recommend her to anyone looking for a special piece of jewelry. She took the time to listen to what I was looking for, she was very friendly and extremely knowledgeable. The experience I had at Kesslers was just perfect all around!

Great help with finding the perfect ring with no pressure to buy or upgrade.

Kesslers lived up to their reputation of superior customer service when my wife lost a diamond form her wedding ring. They quickly replaced the diamond and returned her ring beautifully cleaned within days. Thank you!

The staff is very helpful and friendly. I’ve never had a bad experience here!

Loved the service I received. It was super quick and easy. Everyone was extremely nice :)

My wife & I made an appointment to have our rings cleaned for the Easter celebration. Kesslers called about a week later (which was expected) to let us know the rings were ready for pick-up. When we picked them up and placed them on our fingers we were astonished at how they shined like brand new again. The diamonds were so bright & the scratches were gone! It was like we bought them 14 years ago for our wedding! Way to go Kesslers! Your commitment to service after the sale with lifetime cleaning, etc. is exceptional. We love having Kesslers as our jewelor. Why go anywhere else?

I had several issues with our insurance company in getting my ring fixed when it needed to be repaired and Kesslers was extremely attentive, helpful, and honest in the process. I will continue working with them because I feel like they really had MY best interest in mind & not the insurance company’s or their own. Jessica and the whole team were incredible to work with & I would recommend the Brookfield location/team to anyone. Thanks for everything.

I stopped in to get my ring cleaned. I was warmly greeted and helped immediately. They did a great job and I was out the door in about 5 mins.

Kesslers on Bluemound is where it’s at! This is the only jewelry store in the area where the associates legitimately listened to what I wanted: looks, cost, style, etc. and recommended and encouraged me to get what I wanted. They didn’t try to over convince me what they thought I liked except offer pointers when I asked. What I mean is this. All jewelry stores I went to, anytime I tried on a ring they’d “ooo” and “ah” saying each one was “my style” and they loved it. I don’t like this sales pitch non-sense. Kessler’s consistently asked me each time “how do you like it? What are you thinking”? And based on my feedback would ask additional questions to lead me the right direction.Hands down best experience in a jewelry store. Plus, their warranty comes with the purchase unlike Jared where their items cost an arm and a leg already and then want you to spend more money on a separate warranty with requirements to be in every 6 months.

Overcharged, messed up engraving, and poor communication resulting in a very upsetting experience. Make sure you triple check everything they tell you. If it wasnt 2 days until my wedding I would have returned everything. I will never go back.

My experience has always been very pleasant at Kessler’s. My wife and I have often dealt with Sarah who is wonderful and a very special person. She has cared for our needs in a very friendly and professional manner. She is the best of the best.Additionally, I would recommend Sarah and Kessler’s to anyone looking for diamonds and the best customer service possible.Mark A.

Staff was very pleasant and helpful. Got my ring resized and it was done in a very timely manner!

The service has always been great! Friendly and professional staff. I take my wedding set in periodically for a check and it comes back looking like new! Also, most recently took it in to be sized and done very good! Highly recommended to anyone looking for jewelry!

My ring turned out Beautiful! Thank You

Very friendly and helpful!!! I bought an engagement ring and was told that it wouldnt be ready for a week because the size was not right and the woman that helped me talked to the jewler and I am able to pick it up tomorrow. Im so excited and thank you Richard Kessler as well as your staff

Very professional and helpful

Made shopping from home quick and easy. Great communication throughout the process of special ordering. Arrived early! Have been back many times and will be back again.

Absolutely wonderful place to buy jewelry all the ladies are so pleasant very caring and my wifes always happy

As always Kessler exceeded our expectations. The Anniversary band came in early. They were able to solder my ring and rhodium it within 4 days allowing me to have it for Thanksgiving. Hope was an absolute delight to work with.

The employees here are so amazing. I was super nervous about having my ring redone because it was my finances grandmothers. They walked me through the whole process and were incredibly informative and friendly throughout the whole process

I had a fantastic experience at the Brookfield location! We had just gotten engaged that day and had a ring from a different store out of state. The ring while gorgeous was a bit big and I was afraid it would fall off. We went to Kesslers partially embarrassed to even ask if there was a way we could buy something as a spacer to help it stay on until we could get it sized. Not only did they give me a complimentary spacer but they congratulated us with a gift! We were blown away to say the least by the customer service. We would highly recommend their services to those looking for top knotch care for your jewelry needs 😀

The overall experience was phenomenal! I was lucky to work with Mitzi who did a great job of personalizing the sale. I would highly recommend her and look forward to working with her in the future.

My experience with Kessler has always been wonderful. My husband bought my engagement ring there and for 20 years Ive been bringing my ring in yearly . Always a positive trip!

For our 10th wedding anniversary my husband bought me a second band that went with my engagement ring and wedding band. It was finally time to get them all put together as one piece. I dropped it off to be soldered together. It was expected to take a week and in just a couple of days it was complete. I was so excited to get my ring back and so quickly was an added bonus. We have had nothing but great things to say about Kessler’s and continue to recommend them every chance we get!

I was very impressed with all interactions I had with Kesslers in Brookfield. Their workmanship is first class. Presentation and professionalism are top notch. I would highly recommend for all of your jewelry care & purchases!

Outstanding customer service!! Always impressed!!

The staff at Kesslers were very helpful to find what I was looking for. There was no pressure to buy anything nor did they try pushing me into something outside of my price range. They have an excellent warranty that they provide as well. We will definitely use Kesslers again in the future.

Beautiful rings. Excellent service.

The store always has top-notch service! They are friendly, professional and personable. Repair was done in a fast efficient manner. Always our go to jewelry store

The experience was great! They made me feel at home and the customer service experience was wonderful and expedient. They were knowledgeable and friendly.

Kesslers has been a wonderful to us! They have always made us feel special, and directed us when we had questions. Their customer service and attention to detail is unmatched!

Fantastic customer service. Kesslers made buying the perfect ring extremely easy.

Hope helped my husband pick out the perfect diamond and create a beautiful ring.

The ladies at Kesslers in Brookfield were extremely helpful. We took in my wifes ring for a cleaning and they noticed loose prongs. They sent it out for a rushed fix just in time for our out of state move! Excellent customer service all around.

From the beginning when I first purchased my wifes ring till recently when I upgraded her bands, I must say I am in awe of the customer service and quality of the jewelry. I will be a forever customer. Thank you Jessica from the Brookfield location in making my recent experience a memorable one.

My ring was ready earlier than promised and looks brand new!

I had my ring dipped and whenever I pick it up it brings tears to my eyes how beautiful it is !! It’s like I just got it! Everyone there is so kind and helpful!

Wonderful! With curbside it was so easy to do my upgrade! I let them know ahead of time we were back in town and they had it ready next day for me! Super nice and friendly staff. My earrings are beautiful!!!! Thank you so much Kessler!!! Until.next time when I do my next upgrade!!!

Always thinking of the customer. Appointment was required and mask was mandatory for appointment. Took my diamond swan necklace to be fixed, had lost a few diamonds. I am rough on jewelry. Falls under warranty and as stated it is at no cost. Husband needed a ring sized. Told us potencial cost up front . Had a chance to look around, beautiful jewelry at a fair price. We will be back.

We were pretty disappointed with our experience there. Never received a follow up after our appointment. So we never got any pricing or pictures of the engagement rings that we looked at.

Very nice store, extremely helpful staff

Everyone was very friendly and fast to help

I loved it here and my options and the staff was awesome! She did a great job helping me narrow down to something I absolutely loved! Very good experience all around! Only giving 4 stars though because it was never disclosed that I was buying a lab created diamond. I’m not opposed to them, but I should have been informed from the beginning. I didn’t know until after I purchased and saw the receipt.

Kesslers was great when I bought the engagement ring. Unfortunately, they did not live up to expectations when I ordered my wife an anniversary band.Since this gift was a surprise, I called and placed the order and when it arrived I picked it up at the store. When the time came to reveal the surprise, we discovered Kesslers ordered it in the wrong size. After reordering the ring and waiting 6-8 weeks for the new ring, Kesslers was able to fix the situation. Unfortunately, the surprise and instant gratification of the gift was a major let down.

Took my damaged wedding ring in and they fixed it up darn near better then new...extremely happy

It is such a pleasure to work with someone that doesnt pressure you into something you dont want. I had ideas and they worked with me on picking out the best ring possible within my budget. The best part of this is when ever I go in to clean my rings they still treat me as if Im a new customer. Ill always go back due to there service. They always make me feel important no matter the task.

It was great! The chain on my necklace broke and they were able to fix it. Super friendly staff! :)

My experience was phenomenal like it has always been in the past with Kesslers Diamonds. Their warranty as advertised is no joke. Outstanding customer service, quick responses and in any way shape or form they go out of their way to fulfill their customers needs. Thank you again Kesslers Diamonds

I chose Kesslers because they cared so much about helping me find the perfect ring. They took the time to offer me several options and really went above and beyond with their professionalism and quality service!

Very helpful finding what I was looking for. Had an idea of what I was looking for, for the ring itself and showed me each option that fit the description. Then when it came to the center stone they gave a lot of good info to make the decision easier and were very respectful of the budget I had in mind, showing multiple options that would fit into the budget. Great experience and the gentleman and store manager were easy to work with

Inherited a humble heirloom piece that needed to be resized. Additionally there was precious hand engraving inside the band to make the job difficult. They were able to complete the resize without affecting the engraving at all (and fixed a crack I hadn’t noticed) very quickly. I was nervous parting ways with my piece but they are beyond reproach ensuring a good chain of custody and well as superior craftsmanship. I will definitely be using them again for all my repair needs.

Always friendly and ready to do anything needed to make it an amazing experience. So glad my husband always shops their. The customer service you get after owning you wedding ring 20 years has never been anything but exceptional!

Michelle exceeded expectations!

We are currently pricing rings. Our occupations wont let us wear stones in our rings much less wear a ring. After finding what we liked, the sales rep stated she would send us an email by the end of the week with some suggestions they carry. A week late, we received majority options with stones in them. Not only was the customer service late, the product we were looking for was incorrect. Will not waist my time with this location.

Love my custom engagement ring and the warranty. Recently came in for an anniversary band and was surprised at the small selection. Was told that it is “wedding season” not “engagement season” and this was the reason for the low selection. Since people shop for rings all throughout the year I found this surprising. Found 2 band options-male employee said he would contact the company and get back to us in a few days-it has been 2 weeks and we haven’t heard back from him. I don’t think I should have to chase someone down to give them thousands of dollars. Makes me want to look elsewhere.

Mitzi is amazing. She helps select the perfect item you are looking for. Thank you Mitzi!

Diamond in wedding ring was loose. Dropped it off to have fixed, cleaned & re - dipped. Was told it would be done and ready for pick up by following Saturday. They called us 4 days later to pick up. Results were amazing. Ring looks like it did the day I made the purchase!! Great Job!!

Had a great experience today picking out my birthday present :)

Connor was very helpful! I had recently lost my wedding ring and we went in looking for a replacement. Connor asked us our budget and what I was looking for and did not try to get me to spend more than I wanted. I have a beautiful new ring that was able to be sized in store within a few days. I also like that the warranty doesnt cost extra and you are not required to bring your jewelry in for inspection to keep it in place. I will definitely make kesslers my jewelry store going forward!

We always have a great experience! Highly recommended! Sara was great

For being in the middle of the Covid pandemic it was a decent experience. I love their jewelry guaranteed and policies, they make me comfortable.

Tracy has been awesome to work with! She educated me on proper care of my jewelry and made sure I understood all of the options available to me. She did not push me into anything and made it a comfortable and overall great experience. I’m happy I’ve got my jewelry back and it looks and fits perfect!

On time, friendly people. Great detailed work.

Hope was great to work with. Always freindly and stayed in the budget.Update: got wedding band an engagement rings soldered together turned out awesome! Highly recommend!

I have never had a negative experience in this store. I frequent the one in Brookfield and everyone there is above and beyond friendly and helpful. Most recently, my husband and I walked in to have my wedding ring and bands looked at because I hooked them at work and we were greeted by a gentleman named Walter who had a soda and his briefcase in hand like he was on his way home. He asked me what they could do for me and I explained my situation. He promptly responded with ‘let me take a look for you!’ So he walks back to set his briefcase down and I told him I’d be happy to wait if he’s on his way out and he responded with ‘I’m not anymore, we need to make sure this is right for you!’ He didn’t even bat an eye at it and both my husband and I felt how genuine and sincere he was with his concern. This is the exact reason why I won’t go anywhere else for my jewelry purchasing. I am in retail management and the genuine service and care you receive here is what makes them a top player and a competitor to look out for. Thanks Kesslers for always making me feel important even when I’m not in to buy and I just need the peace of mind that my ring is ok. You guys are the best!

Wonderful experience. I am going to highly recommend Kesslers to anybody looking to buy an engagement ring. I was helped the perfect amount throughout the entire process. I never felt like they didnt care and I never felt pushed to buy anything. I truly believe I was given the best possible deal, and I am very grateful for that. I will ALWAYS use Kesslers for any jewelry needs.

Hope was great! wonderful experience getting my engagement ring !!

Kessler’s is the best. There very timely and the customer service is outstanding. Thank you Brookfield crew for making my wife’s 10 year anniversary band. It is beautiful and truly one of a kind!

I came here twice to purchase a ring that I had seen at the downtown location but needed a different size. The prices are high and the selection isnt that great, but I wanted something simple and I was pressured for not leaving enough time before a wedding (more than 4 weeks). I purchased from here. I was shocked at they were attentive when trying to sell to me, then the moment I purchased the ring they didnt seem to care about the details. They printed a receipt that didnt have my name on it, even though it was my credit card. It had my fiancees name and address, even though I hadnt given his name or address and he wasnt with me. They apparently knew to link us because he had looked at an engagement ring here but did not purchase here. Still, I paid with my credit card and the receipt came with his name and address. The person helping us said she would send an appraisal for insurance purposes. It took from May until today to finally get it from her via email. And guess what, the name is four names mashed together. Wedding rings can be a large purchase and wedding planning can be a chaotic process, do yourself a favor and find a jeweler that will tend to the details a bit more.

I had a great experience! I was shopping for a gift with my daughters. Everyone was really friendly! I was offered a beverage as well as my daughter. My daughter even got a sucker:) The sales associate who helped me was Mitzi and she was great! The manager came over when we were done to make sure we were happy with everything! I would definitely recommend this place and come back!

Kesslers is fantastic! I designed my engagement ring gave them the color of my diamond I wanted and they did a great job at giving me exactly what I wanted. Not only that I love the fact that I can just go in any day of the week to get my ring cleaned and no one is hassling me to buy anything! The staff at the Bluemound location is so amazing and helpful! Thank you for the amazing service and dedication not only to your customers but also to your company! Love it!

Very helpful staff

Took my ring in for repair. All the employees are friendly and helpful. My ring looks beautiful. I wouldn’t shop anywhere else for good jewelry.

Sara Schieg was truly amazing! She went above and beyond for us to guarantee all our needs or wants were taken care of! Truly could not ask for a better Jeweler. Thanks again Sara!

No longer live near our jewelry retailer, where we got my engagement ring and wedding band, so took the set to Kesslers to get soldered together, sized up a bit, and get the setting on my engagement ring fixed. I felt confident giving them my most prized possession to care for, knowing they had ID’d my main diamond before handing it over. The work was done beautifully and the fit is perfect.

Great service.True to their warranty.I lost a diamond from my wedding ring.I took it to Kesslers, they were friendly and helpful.My ring was back in less than a week. Diamond replaced at no charge.It looks brand new.Thank youKesslers

My wife recently had her engagement/wedding rings I bought over ten years ago resized, cleaned and replated, all at no cost. She couldn’t have been happier with the service she received!