People are nice and know what they are taking about.

Went there last week, with my nephew, in desperate hopes to find a new gaming store (Game Master Games is gone, and Cosmic Comics and A Store of Fire and Dice are a little far for me).They had plenty of cards (MtG, Pokemon), but that was IT...... They have little in TTRPG gaming (Just a small handful of D&D books... no Pathfinder, no Starfinder), they now use the entire front half of the building as their storage room, which you cant walk into anymore, the two guys there werent rude or disrespectful, but they werent accommodating or convincing, either. It felt like stuff was just there, but the store was hardly a store.I cant see how these guys have gotten 5-star reviews, 2 years ago, because they honestly NEED to step up their game NOW. Theres almost no way Im coming back because of how disappointing the store was to me and my nephew.

Friendly staff. They have a good amount of stock for a smaller store.

Great guys, very knowledgeable a little steep on pricing but honestly, You know youre getting what you pay for. Would 100% recommend

Great place, friendly staff, good selection of cards at good prices

Purchased 23 booster boxes and package came to my door damaged and already opened. Asked for partial refund for damaged items but they will not offer anything. Very poor packing, used an old box and one that could not handle the weight involved. Paid $3500 but they dont care about proper shipping.

Nice local card shop in Nassau county. The guys that run the store are knowledgeable on your favorite trading card games and can assist in making suggestions to fit your needs. The Nassau area has been missing a shop since game master games closed its doors years ago and hopefully these guys can fill the void. Shop is kept clean and has new tables and chairs as well as freshens the shop daily. It is a little small so hopefully they can expand in the future and run larger tournaments once covid is gone. Price support is fair and so are the prices on boxes, singles and accessories. Support your local game shops and give Mythic Games a try ! You won’t be disappointed. Their snack selection is also a surprise . I haven’t seen fruit gushers and roll ups in ages

Very great store and friendly staff bought a set box of kaldheim and definitely going back for more single cards and magic the gathering products for my deck and collection

Best card shop on long island

Friendly staff, great atmosphere. 10/10

Absolutely baller of a place, they give fair prices for Yugioh boxes. Support your local shops. They treat you well.

Ever since Game Master Games closed down, Ive been looking for a convenient game store to indulge in card games and tabletop roleplay.This place is well kept, not too far from home, and has a friendly work staff. Whats not to like?

Great place to chill with friends, very spacious and cares about their clientele, cant recommend them enough. Much better than the broken down depot

Nice space, great for paying card games like magic. Good parking polite staff.

Friendly staff, great selection, and lots of play space. Best store on Long Island. 10/10

The customer service was great they were nice cant wait to go back

Fantastic staff and great products!

One representative is extremely unprofessional.

Friendly Staff, Clean Facilities, a little overspecialized (in Magic The Gathering)

Very friendly and helpful staff!

Easily best MTG store on the island

They do have chess but do they have checkers?tuns out they also have checkers but do they have bayblades?

Not much there