This place is chaos. Loooong wait, and pray you walk out with the right order. I mean, how hard is it to work out a numbering system? You cant get too annoyed though because it is mostly kids working, and they are trying their best

Enjoyed my light baked poppy with cream cheese......They do not skimp on the cream cheese. Id def prefer more then not enough but this was like can i have some bagel with my cream cheese lol.

Worth waiting on line. Easy simple food. Classic staple in the neighborhood.

Wait was long, and they got a simple order wrong, then said we miss communicated....

Best bagels on the island...so far.

This place used to be good, this is what they’ve become, cheese wasn’t even melted. Yesterday my coffee was cold and tasted like it’s been sitting on the burner for hours. This is the last time I spend my money there. Go somewhere else!

There are plenty of great bagels in the area but this is the best local spot in my opinion. The quality has stayed consistent through the years.

Best bagels in town !!!

My favorite place for breakfast ! Fresh Coffee, Hot Bagels, Friendly Employees !!!

Best French toast bagel! Great service but cash only.

Used to be good. Customer service has continued to decline in the last several years. I attentive staff. Orders filled incorrectly. No sneeze guard covering too shelf. Dirty unmaintained place. My next email is to the board of health. As I will not spend any more of my money and the staff should replaced with people who can serve customers the right way. Stop Hiring millennials who don’t care about anything but themselves. The bagels have gotten smaller as the serviced has gotten worse. If the owners don’t care anymore just sell the place.

Quality is A1 I have been coming here longtime but staff needs to be more trained better to handle customers I was jumped on the line and people behind me were asked and no one asked if I was being helped .after placing a simple order for a bagel and cream cheese I noticed that they toasted the bagel and left it alone for a good 20 min and started taking more orders i feel thats gross incompetence and staff ( looks like mostly high school students doing part time )needs to be trained or replaced ..management please do something

The bagels and sandwiches are excellent. However the service is terrible. Slow and inattentive. Especially on the weekends. Its like the children are running the show and the adults arent home.

Fresh made bagels on premises. There is also grill service. Parking not a problem in this strip mall. Its a popular local source so be prepared for a few minutes of a line, but bagels are constantly coming from oven to counter. They also have croissants and a variety of cream cheeses; they close at 2pm daily. Cash only.

Love my local bagel store! Employees are super nice and bagels are great!

Surprisingly good bacon egg and cheese! The bagels were soft, the price was fair and every one working seemed polite. I didnt expect much from looking at that place, or even after walking in. But dont judge a book from its cover - the bagels were good!

This rating is for customer service. Ive been to busier bagel shops on busy Saturday mornings that were more efficient. The employees are not at fault and I see they work very hard. Management - please provide more training on timing and task management.

Love this place. Everything is great.egg sandwich is awesome. All of the.fresh hot.bagels always fresh. Friendly staff.

Terrible staff, ordered 2 simple bagels when it wasn’t busy. Started filling orders for customers after us, waited 30 mins and asked where our order was and they had no idea.

I agree with most of the negative reviews about the staff that works here. They always look miserable and consequently they are unfriendly. The bagels are just okay. Unfortunately, they are the only show in town. Its worth driving the extra miles to go to Bagel Town in Levittown where the bagels are better and youre treated with respect as a customer.

Excellent bagels and baked goods. Friendly staff. Almost always bit of a line (which tells you its good) but it moves quickly. Cash only shop, so remember to hit the ATM at the bank next door.

Best bagel shop on Long Island, not even close. Been going here since i was a kid & they have some of the best bagels I have ever eaten, but its their bacon & egg sandwiches that puts them above everyone else. It is a very small store that gets very packed on the weekends, but its only because their that good. Talk to anyone from Hicksville & theyll tell you the same thing about Heavenly Bagels.

Great bagels!!!! Friendly staff. Cash only.

Best egg sandwiches in Levittown

Best bagel place I’ve ever been to. The line is usually crazy crazy in the mornings, especially on the weekends, but it’s worth the wait! I always get the exact same thing — a bacon and egg on a plain toasted bagel. And it’s cheappppp as well, especially compared to bagel prices in New York City.

Super egg everything is definitely the best bagel...

The Best bagels around!!! Crisp on the outside and soft on the inside. Friendly staff. Dont let the long line scare you away, they move the line very fast and its well worth a few mins wait!

Delicious bagels every time. If you go during peak hours, prepare to wait. Cash only!

Heavenly bagels have the best tasting bagels. They are always fresh.

Service is slow as molasses. Ordered an egg sandwich, waited 15 minutes and left without said sandwich.As a manager if you know weekends are busy, maybe you hire an experienced person for the grill . The current young Grill girl cooks about two eggs at a time.

Great place 4 breakfast 😋

I love this place. Bagels are always fresh! Staff is great! Definitely recommend this place. Keep up the good work heavenly bagels!

The best Bagels around....no comparison anywhere...

Line can get cery long at times otherwise a good bagel place.

Bagels are pretty good. They go a little overboard with the cream cheese. Weekend lines are crazy long. If you are in a rush on Saturday or Sunday, dont bother. Cash only.

Better than Bagel Boss

Good service, great bagels. They give lots of cream cheese. The strawberry cream cheese is amazing. It tastes like strawberry cheesecake.

Best bagels in Hicksville. A must stop every time I come home to visit! Just remember to bring cash because they do not accept cards.

Nothing like a NY bagel special mmm good.

Amazing!!! I was new to this whole NY bagel thing.... so we found this little gem on our way home from the gym and boy was it time to carb up!!! We arrived around 1050am, which was fine for me because the bagel I would ask for had a ton left... however, that wasnt the case for the rest. If you want a wide selection- go earlier! They sell out FAST!So after looking at the menu I went with the Special #1 -A bagel with egg and cheese that comes with a coffee (very good coffee) and OJ all for $3.65!!!!I added boars head Turkey as well as their homemade lox spread and changed the egg to an egg white. I got all this on their Everything bagel. OH MY GOOOOODNESS, it was amazing! I truly think, the best bagel combo I have ever had.The freshness, flavors, etc of everything was so savory! The price was unbelievable and the girls working behind the counter were so sweet and helpful!If I am ever in the area again, I WILL definitely be coming back!!!Thanks Heavenly Bagel for showing this FL girl how bagels are suppose to be done! :)

Yummy! Long lines but moves quickly: those gals are speedy!

So good to have great Bagels havent had a good bagel since my last visit to New York

Great bagels. Cash only

Stay clear of here. Bagels are burnt regularly, runs out of Bagels on a Sunday morning, poorly managed and maintained.

I really enjoy this place... great bagels and egg sandwiches

My favorite bagels in the entire country!

Yummy bagels made the New be York way

Been going for years. The bagels are fresh and suberb, the staff is efficent and the original rotating artwork series makes the place truly unique.

Not sure the cook knows what turkey bacon is, as they served me Turkey and bacon. Apple turnover was stall and masked with powdered sugar.

The only great bagel around here parts.

Pros: Great bagels, speedy serviceCons : Expect lines out the door Sun mornings.Small space gets crampedCash only

Good food. Bit of a wait

Bagels are great, get there early always busy!

Always hectic on Sundays but the lines do move quickly. Its cash only but there is an ATM. The bagels are solid

Good bagels....loooooooong lines

Bagels are always burnt on the bottom so I will not be going back.

I came here yesterday on my way to church and WOW--these bagels are sooo good!Bagelsmith on Bedford Ave is a small bagel shop and it was packed but the line moved quickly and the employees were very efficient with getting the orders, making the food and getting to to the customers.Its really convenient to get to--its right off of the Bedford Ave. stop on the L train.I got a toasted Pumpernickel Everything bagel with Scallion Tofu Cream Cheese. The bagel was nice and chewy and had a lot of flavor. The Scallion Tofu Cream Cheese was so amazing that it had be questioning if it was really made out of tofu! This is easily one of the best bagels that I have had. They give a good amount of cream cheese and they toast the bagel just right. The bagels are moist and delicious! They have a lot of vegan options for spreads and sandwich toppings.Also, the price isnt so bad for Williamsburg. My bagel came up to 4 bucks. I will definitely be coming back here to try their different menu items!P.s. I LOVE that they dont have a credit card minimum (thats very hard to find in NYC).

Great place. Doesnt take credit but well worth it!!

Best Bagels Ever, Egg Sandwiches pretty good too.

Excellent service, good bagel sandwiches

Good bagels and closes at 2:00 pm on Sundays

I totally love this place

Every bagel is made with love 💜💜💜

French toast bagel is the best around

Good bagels but not the best.

Best bagels and breakfast specials

Visited this place on Monday early morning. There was limited bagel selection. I was craving for pumpernickel bagel but they did not have it.

Very good and good value.

Delicious! Recommended highly

Food was allright but the service was slow

Bagels are great and always fresh.

Seriously the worst service i have ever encountered . Food is always messy . Unless you are going here just to grab a quick bagel nothing on it, i do not recommend !

Great breakfast sandwiches

Great bagels

DELICIOUS BAGELS!

Not bad

Slow. Slow. Slow!

First time

Cash only

Great bagels

Great bagel

Took to long.

Great !

So dirty!!!!!!!

Bagels