user
Arthur Bay Cheese Co.
237 E Calumet St, Appleton, WI 54915, United States
Appearance
Arthur Bay Cheese Co.

Comments
La
Review №1

DO NOT WASTE YOUR TIME OR GAS TO GO HERE..Absolutely horrible this place is listed as open until 5:00 p.m.on Google yet me and my family drive all the way across town to show up around one oclock just to see a closed sign on the door. Will not be back.

Ra
Review №2

We love cheese curds and gave these a shot but this brand is way too salty. That’s all we tasted.

ma
Review №3

Small local cheese shop. Lots of specialty cheeses some sausages and specialty items. Nice change of pace from the big box stores.

Ru
Review №4

Lady was very helpful and it was great that they could ship it for us there. Saved a trip.

Er
Review №5

Amazing quality cheese some of the best tasting cheese Ive ever had. Very friendly and knowledgeable staff

Am
Review №6

Great cheeses for reasonable prices and the staff are so helpful! They also mail gift boxes which worked great as a holiday gift.

mi
Review №7

2nd time here, quality selection and very good. Wont be disappointed.

Ma
Review №8

Restored my faith in retail stores. helpful, knowledgeable in the products.

da
Review №9

Good selection plus gifts and Christmas boxes are packaged and an ship all over the USA

De
Review №10

We are so happy we found you. Your cheese is very good. Drive right past Simons to get to you. This is my husbands favorite place now. Yummmmm !!!!!

Pa
Review №11

Best cheese in the Fox Valley. Im from Little Chute however this is my choice for cheese.

Ol
Review №12

Got the Mozzarella cheese whips. Love the strings but they have wayyyy too much salt in them.

Jo
Review №13

They dont make cheese. And the cheese i bought didnt taste that great.

Tr
Review №14

Dill and garlic curds are the best. Will be getting more

Ti
Review №15

The only place to buy cheese in our area, right in town, very fair prices and great staff!

Ja
Review №16

Very good cheese, a lot of nice gift packages too.

Ma
Review №17

Bought the mozzarella cheese whips, wow, waayyy too much salt! So much I couldnt even eat them, threw the bag away. What a waste of money.

Ke
Review №18

Colby?I got a large block of cheese that was labeled Colby, it had the consistency of Velvita, and the flavor of American. First time I have ever been disappointed in their products.

Ka
Review №19

Always so nice, the cheese is great, fresh cheese curds are delicious!

my
Review №20

First time there. They were helpful and had samples!

Tr
Review №21

Very helpful and knowledgeable.

An
Review №22

Great sale going on, great service

El
Review №23

Fabulous fresh cheese curds!

Di
Review №24

Great cheese great location

Ph
Review №25

Nice Variety Helpful clerks

Sa
Review №26

Nice place

Ma
Review №27

Very friendly people.

Information
6 Photos
27 Comments
4.5 Rating
  • Address:237 E Calumet St, Appleton, WI 54915, United States
  • Phone:+1 920-733-1556
Categories
  • Cheese shop
Working hours
  • Monday:Closed
  • Tuesday:Closed
  • Wednesday:8:30AM–5PM
  • Thursday:8:30AM–5PM
  • Friday:8:30AM–5PM
  • Saturday:8:30AM–5PM
  • Sunday:8:30AM–5PM
Accessibility
  • Wheelchair accessible entrance:No
Planning
  • Quick visit:Yes
Similar organizations