YUM!!!!!! This is my new favorite Pizza in Columbus. Super nice staff and the food is phenomenal. We had the Magnificent Mushroom pizza and it was named correctly. I only wish it was closer to my house. You gotta try this place.

We ordered the ode to the magnificent mushroom pizza. It was wonderful! Quality ingredients really elevate their pizza over competitors. There was a minor issue with the timing of our order, but the manager more than made up for it. Its well worth giving them a try.

I was skeptical to order from what I thought was an office cafeteria but I will be back! The pork sandwich was amazing, huge, and a great value. It brings me back to the days when Sandman made the best cheesesteaks downtown. I cant wait to try other items.

Sandman Pizza did a wonderful job with the catering for my husband’s birthday party. The Pulled Pork and Macaroni and Cheese were delicious and a hit with our guests! Catering Manager Suzy was responsive and so helpful! I highly recommend for your next event.

Had a build your own . Pie was very tasty. Artisan crust was great!Very friendly staff. Outdoor seating if you like. I will DEFINITELY go back!

Outstanding pizza!!!! I had never seen this restaurant before because it is a little hidden. But am so glad I found them because I loved the pizza. Some things I haven’t seen at your standard pizza joint. The carmelized shallot and garlic made my pizza really pop. And saw this big grill out front and can’t wait to try the wings. Shout out to Susie who was so friendly and nice. Can’t wait to come back!

This was a pretty decent tasting Pizza. The toppings were very meaty. It just didnt give me that Chicago Pizza taste that I am used too and miss so much.

We had never tried this place before and we are glad we did. The pizza was great. We had the BBQ pork and the chicken bacon ranch.

This pizza is amazing! Gives Borgata a run for their money. First time having it and will definitely be ordering again.

Pizzas were huge, and definitely good. We were pleasantly surprised and will definitely try them again.

Outstanding !!! ordered 15 pizzas today and I think I tried every one .. We will certainly return for more, havent had pizza this good in years .

Great, cheap NY style pizza. Personable staff and great shaded outdoor dining for a little time outside during a lunch break.

Solid New York style pizza! Love it! We will be back!

Finally a good pizza place in the neighborhood! Excellent pizza!

Buffalo chicken Yum!

Everyones food looked scrumptious! I got the coconut and granola coated French toast which comes with fresh strawberries and bananas and delicious homemade whipped cream. Very well done and unique. No regrets. Ate it all, but you could split it. Tried my wifes omlet and hash browns, which were excellent! Food and service here is A+

Amazing service and an even more amazing crew! Highly recommended

Great friendly place to pickup breakfast or lunch if working at 440 Polaris or close by. Even has outdoor seating for when the weather is nice. Great daily specials and variety of items to choose from.

Awesome Pizza !

I cant say enough about Sandman Gourmet Catering. They catered a small business workshop we held and the food was absolutely delicious. Really, truly. Something you can rarely find for catered meals.I highly recommend them and the personal service was also fantastic.

Great food and amazing staff! Its hard to leave here without a smile on your face and a happy belly

People were amazing and the food was even better. Best chix wings in town. They run as a special and they are a must have!

This place is awesome! The food is fresh and always made right before you..the staff is awesome..stop in and see Susan..she is the best!

This Place is Fantastic, From the Great music & Staff to the amazing SMOKED wings, YUM.... NO JOKE you dont even need sauce on them!!!Dont even get me started on the ALL DAY Breakfast that they serve, ya know Fresh not like McDonalds version of Fresh But Real Fresh, Like make it in front of you Fresh :)My Husband Had the Sandman Chili and loved it, along with the Gyritto. He even liked it so much he had to get one for the road.One last thought on this place, they have daily specials and even make all the soup from scratch daily. WoW now thats Good stuff. Truly looking forward to going back very soon.

Please bring back the big10 though. Tempted to rate at a lower star count, but will not because I loved the big10 when you had it.

Nice people great prices – their specials are always the bomb. Fresh soups every day.

I go there almost everyday for lunch. I love the friendly service and great food.

Great food great ppl

Outstanding Food and Catering !

Very good pizza