Just visited with my family. My husband ordered a milkshake. He said it was delicious and not heavy at all.I ordered a hazel nut banana bread pudding that was delicious.For my 2yo we got a mini tiny tart. It tasted good too.I enjoy the vibe, the service was good, and the food was delicious.My only suggestion will be to put some kind of shades by the table area.

Nice concept with the grab and go Sundays but they just don’t work. The ice cream melts before the rest of the ingredients. Some baked goods were refresher than others but that’s the case with most bakeries. They offer a few items I haven’t seen elsewhere so that’s nice. To me a 3 star review means give them a try.

I dont like leaving negative reviews but this needs to be shared and I hope all bakers see this so it doesn’t happened to anyone else. I purchased an Apple crumb pie yesterday and I was super excited to eat it, as it looked delicious. But once I got to my family gathering and we went to eat it, after eating a bite of my piece I realized it was completely raw inside. And I’m not talking just a little undercooked dough. Like full on raw as if it was just put in the oven. Would have taken 2 seconds to put a thermometer in the pie to make sure it was cooked to completion. Just a heads up to the bakery that... you may need to bake some of your food longer because i don’t want anyone getting sick from raw dough. I unfortunately had to throw the pie away, but I do hope you take this Information to improve because I have a feeling this isn’t the first time this has happened. Good luck to them but I won’t be back.

This bakery is my absolute favorite bakery I have come across! I live in New Jersey and I travel 2 hours just to come here. Love it!! Staff is also always so helpful and kind. Cute bakery.

Amazing milkshakes (homemade milkshakes)🍦🍨 i had the s’mores milkshake and it was so delicious 🤤 super cute new bakery in Smithtown

Even with COVID-19, the service (and cupcakes) are OUSTANDING! I went in there to get some cupcakes for a friends birthday, and I was in and out within 5 minutes. Everyone was wearing masks and gloves. Plus it smelled amazing in there. They also have the option for hard ice cream and milkshakes!! The prices are also pretty affordable as well! I definitely recommend this place to everyone!

Amanda is my go to when I need any cake made. Everything is always delicious and beautiful!

I prank called them and asked for 100 digits of pi and you know what? They actually did it and recited 100 digits of pi for me and I feel that they deserve kudos for that XD

Great bakery with cakes, cookies, pastries, ice cream, coffee, ice cream cake and more. We went in the late afternoon so there were less options to choose from. Some of the cakes looked like it had shifted, maybe due to the heat. I will definitely be back to try different things, like a huge brownie with M & Ms. Prices were fair and the two girls were helpful.

Amanda NEVER fails to make delicious cookies, cakes, donuts and more! By far the best bakery in the tri-state area. Her staff is always so pleasant and helpful, the bakery is very clean and super adorable. We always order cakes and baked goods for birthdays, holidays and more! You can’t go wrong with anything you order at the Whisk! Keep up the delicious work 😊

Extremely disappointing.While from the presentation it looks appealing and delicious, the only product that seems to be fresh is the rainbow crumb are.The freshrolls are either frozen and defrosted...with freezer burn or just plain stale.Not recommended.

Wonderful cute bake shop with very friendly staff and a spot on pumpkin muffin!

I normally dont post a review on something I have had but I wanted to take a moment to tell you this amazing Bakery! I have lived here my whole life and gone to the 2 other well know bakeries in this area. When I heard this one poped up I had to give it a try. I had the Rainbow Cookies and the Strawberry Banana Cake. My wife had the ice cream which she said she loved. I enjoyed the Rainbow Cookies. They were more of a Cake then a Cookie (which I like) and the Strawberry Banana Cake (Which had another name for it) was amazing! my family couldnt stop eating it. In one sitting and most of it was gone. Great Job to the ladies of this bakery and hope to see you again soon.

Johnson & Wales doesn’t disappoint. They shape some of the finest chefs and bakers to show the world true talent. This bakery is it! The cakes and milkshakes are exceptional. Highly recommend if you’re in the area!

Just went yesterday and its an absolute delight. I had the lobster tail with cannoli filling. The pastry was delicious, the filling was great. My girlfriend had the macaroon which was had a light cookie and a dense filling, overall tasty.I ended up purchasing an assortment of butter cookies for my co-workers and they were a hit. Highly recommend this bakery I will definitely go back.

Super friendly staff, Britney and Amanda have cake making down to a fine art .

This place is incredible 😍. The girls are so helpful. Support small business!!

Mediocre at best, the coffee wasnt even hot, and the black and white cookie was just a piece of stale cake cut out into the shape of a cookie. Also, the owner or someone working there just left all their paperwork and stacks of cash on the tables out in the open (Good thing nobody stole it).

A very clean bakery offering some of the freshest cakes I’ve had in a while. We tried the berry crumb cake with custard and fresh fruit between fluffy vanilla cake and topped with whip cream. The cake wasn’t too sweet at all, and very fresh. I will be going back. My own wish is that for their gluten-free selection, that they aren’t premade and packaged but instead just like the rest of their bakery offerings.Their prices are very fair and well under what I am used to paying at a bakery.Can’t wait to go to scopa Saturday tournaments!

Place is the bees knees! Everything is delicious and the owner is the friendliest, most professional, young entrepreneur. A real refreshing addition to smithtown.

They provided the most amazing cake for my bridal shower. Literally everyone was raving about how beautiful and delicious it was. Cant recommend them enough!!!!!

I just came from The Whisk Bakery. Excellent baked goods that goes above and beyond any air filled greasy donuts you can get elsewhere. The girl behind the counter greeted me Good morning and was very pleasant. Although I no longer live on Long Island I am happy to see a Swithtown West graduate start her own business. This was my neighborhood for 20+ years.I will be sure to stop by before I leave town to bring some goodies back to all my LI friends who now live down south with me. Best of luck and success. Please support your hometown neighbor.

My daughter ordered the Thanksgiving bread cornucopia and it was a hit!! Not only did it make a beautiful centerpiece the breads were delicious, the kids loved the mini cornbread muffins too.

Went because it was highly recommended, I got a bunch of cupcakes and they were not special. My family didn’t even finish them.

This is an adorably decorated bakery. Unfortunately, that is the last positive comment for The Whisk Bakery. The customer service was poor and the food was worse. We purchased a few items as there were 5 of us. We threw everything in the garbage including 4 terribly bitter, way too strong coffees. The tira misu had no taste and was so dry you could barely swallow it. The carrot cake had no flavor and the icing tasted like lard that I actually spit the bite into a napkin. Unknowing of our experience my sister purchased a chocolate cake with chocolate icing for a co-workers birthday the next day. Everyone at her office said the cake had no flavor and the frosting tasted like wax. I would not recommend this bakery.

Absolutely horrendous. Poor service and an even worse product. I went in and asked if they had a specific type of pie, the response was “ I’m not sure, I don’t think so”. It took 10 minutes for them to write “ happy birthday” but my 5 year old could have done a better job. It was embarrassing. Opened in 2019 and hopefully circa 2020.

Love the pastries. just ordered a graduation cake: chocolate cake, mousse filling with chocolate gnash icing. All our guests raved about it! Not too sweet. Delicious. I will order it again.

Best milkshakes ever! Everyone here is super nice and the goodies are delicious.

There brownies are Huge and delicious!!

Everything I have gotten there has been great, but the Linzer Tarts are the best Ive ever had, better than any other bakery in the area.

Love their breads and the Italian pastries make me weak in the knees.

Closes at 5 not 9 like Google saysThe lobster tails where very stale the one with custard wasnt filled in between just the ends the crust itself is very tough and Stale tasting Not very happy!

Yum!!!!! Get the little fruit tarts!

Great place to earn your diabetes.

Crumb cake like I have never had before and never will have again!

Delicious baked goods and fun cakes. We havent gotten anything we did not think was delicious.

Really Good Bakery! Top in the area. Highly recommend!

The review I posted below was 3 years ago for the previous bakery in the same location called Buon Amici. The new bakery (Whisk) does not seem to have the same recipes for the custard items I reviewed below :( The new staff is nice, and most items are good, however. I’m leaving my old review for Buon Amici for the heck of it.... In my opinion, one of the best bakeries on Long Island. The butter cookies are excellent and actually made with real butter. Amazing Black n White cookies and brownies (and we have made multiple comparisons!). The Italian pastries are a family favorite - the custard is perfect. Be sure to try the St. Joseph pasties and 7-layer fudge/buttercream cake. We are repeat customers and have loved every item we have ordered. The prices are very fair and the staff has always been extremely nice and helpful.

Very average. Not impressed at all.

They closed one hour early, I drove all the way from Queens and they decided to close 1 hour early. Very disappointed, theyre probably not that good anyway

Amazing donuts

Bought my kids a brownie they started eating it and a DEAD WORM was noticed in the middle.

Lots of cheese inside the cheese danish

Excellent!!!!