Best place to sell your gold jewelry! Greg was very fair and honest! He explained everything he was doing as he was doing it and actually taught me a lot. Highly recommend!!! Also have a great selection of coins!!

Nice place friendly Derek was a great help learned a few thing easy to find

I just want to say that I could not have had a better experience!! Ed was so helpful, very knowledgeable, and made the whole experience a lot of fun. He took the time to look over and test the items I brought in, and explained anything I had questions on. THANK YOU!!!! I would recommend this store to anyone. They do all the checking and weighing right in from of you, nothing leaves your sight and there is no pressure. Cant say enough good things about this business.

I went in today to ask the proprietor of Buckeye Gold Coins & Jewelry about how I could tell fake silver from real silver coins...especially old silver dollars. I met Ed and he took the time to explain to me several ways I could tell the difference not only with the coins themselves but how to spot fake sites on line. He spent the time to answer all of my questions and give me confidence that I can now tell the difference. Ed is very professional and I will take all of my business to his shop in the future. I highly recommend Buckeye Coin & Jewelry in Pickerington!

I went into this location earlier today to have some stuff appraised, and even though my items werent worth much, I really appreciated the gentleman at the desk thoroughly explaining to me why. I didnt feel he was being dishonest or just trying to turn me away, like I have at other Buy Gold places. Ed was very engaging and offered great customer service. Pickerington is a bit of a drive for me, but I will gladly return to this location if I ever need another appraisal or want to buy some jewelry.

Oh my gosh I love this store!!! They have the best selection of vintage and unique jewelry!! Ed and Greg are awesome!! Every time I come in they are both so personable and a pleasure to talk to! I highly recommend visiting this store if you like unique and vintage jewelry!!

I was looking for different investments, gold and old coins. I met Ed, and he was very helpful and knowledgeable about vintage coins, especially gold. I will definitely return and buy more coins.

Looooove Ed. He is the most honest buyer I have ever encountered. I have learned so much from him. I would come here just to educate myself.

Stay away from buckeye gold and silver. They offered me 80% of spot price for my silver. I went to Grove City Coin and Currency and they gave me OVER spot price. Walked out with 1500 cash. Buckeye Gold’s offer was under 1200. I made over 300 dollars more just going somewhere else. Wish i had the option of zero stars.

Buckeye Gold is by far the best Bullion/Coin/Jewelry shop in Ohio. I collect coins as well as bullion and always go to Buckeye Gold before any other. Ed is usually there when I go and is extremely helpful. Unlike employees at some other coin shops, Ed is always willing to talk with me and even give me advice about the coins. Ed remembers what Im looking for and stays on the lookout for what Im interested in. I always have a great experience while Im in the shop and I recommend that anyone stop in and look at what they have to offer.

Very helpful staff. For someone getting into buying precious metals I would highly recommend this shop

I had been to Buckeye gold before to sell some old silver that I inherited, but I stopped in to look for an engagement ring for my girlfriend. The manager there was very helpful. She asked me about what my girl likes and helped me pick out a good ring. I was very happy with the selection and the price, especially compared to how expensive some rings are at the mall. I will definitely go back when I need gifts for the women in my family.

The woman who helped me was very sweet! I was stuck in traffic and didnt know if I would make it there before close, but she assured me over the phone that she would stay and wait. I got there right at closing time, but she was still so nice, even though she had to stay late. I very much appreciated her taking the time to help me. Definitely the kind of service that makes me want to go back.

Buckeye Gold Company in Pickerington is by far the best place to sell your silver and gold. The manager, Ed, provides exceptional customer service and is always extremely fair. I have been to most of the other competitors in the area and there is no comparison! Buckeye Gold is the BEST. They also have a gorgeous selection of silver and gold vintage and designer jewelry at prices that cant be beat. i just love this place and highly recommend it.

Friendly, Knowledgeable, and Honest!