I had to replace an ugly light fixture in my pantry. Penn Hardware had everything I needed for a reasonable price. The staff is very knowledgeable, helpful, & friendly.

A small neighborhood hardware store that may not have a football field sized business, but have staff who actually KNOW what they are talking about when asked questions about products by not so mister fix it people like me. If they dont have what you need, the staff tells you....instead of trying to sell you the wrong product like many big name chain stores do.Additionally, being a neighborhood store, they are familiar with neighborhood homes, from skylight screens to 70 year old door lock replacements. One of the few such businesses left. And yes, it has been my experience that they appreciate our military, veterans and first responders like the big chain stores do.

I live a block away from the store and having something like this so close is absolutely invaluable. Every time we do a project we always forget to buy something at Home Depot and Penn Hardware comes to the rescue. They have a huge selection of stuff and have specialty things your run of the mill Home Depot doesn’t carry. They also repair window screens and do a fantastic job!!!!! Definitely a neighborhood gem.

Hard to find items but meet Mike lucky Mike plays guitar also so quick ideas came to mind when told him my problem with a broken neck on a acoustic electric guitar I just bought (beware FB market).Stock coming in Ill be doing a little more shopping here.

Very helpful guy. Didnt even have to ask for assistance. He came up and offered to help me.

Very nice people to deal with a pen hardware they are not rude like S&H on Castor Avenue

I had two screens made for my storm door. I thought the price was a little much, but it ended up being more than worth it. Nothing like a neighborhood hardware store.

Limited supply of useful materials, overpriced. Exact same materials at Home Depot a whole lot less expensive

Nothing like a hardware store,great service thanks

Always friendly and willing to help. Nice to still have a local hardware store in the neighborhood.

Always have what I need

Has just about anything you need. A great place to have car keys made.

Ive been going there for 15 years. Very friendly and helpful staff and owners. I allways try to shop local ma and pa first. Support your local business.

Always have what you need, much easier than going to home depot, and you support a local family. Give them a try

Love this store! They almost always have what I need, and their prices are very reasonable. If Im not sure how to do something, they always have clear instructions and advice on how to fix whatever I have that is broken.

Classic local hardware store. Helpful and knowledgeable

Convenient and good prices

Good oldtime hardware store, hard to find old items for old houses. Fair staff.

Nice little hometown hardware store with whatever you need.

Old time hardware store, like before Home Depot. Good sevice.

Its fine. A bit, a good bit over priced, but convenient.

Old school hardware store that seems to have everything

I was able to find the holiday decorations that Ive been looking for.

Great neighborhood hardware store! One of my faves. Small town feel and excellent prices and staff.

Nice place for the hard to find things

Always have what I want or need!!!

Small place but always have what Im looking for. Rather use small mom and pop stores.

I bought an air pump to fill my granddaughter’s new bike tires. The pump was blowing air though the system but wouldn’t work on the tire. After three adults tried to use it I went back to return/exchange it. The employees all said that sales were final and accused me of using it for what I needed. They said people do it all the time. They were yelling at me as if I was trying to scam them. I am a resident in the neighborhood for years trying to keep stores like this afloat. I’ve never been so insulted. Next trip will be Home Depot.

Its a neighborhood hardware store, not one of them small hole in the wall stores that ya cant move in,,, its a big store with plenty of space n seems to have everything ya need for any kind of project, there are two gentlemen that work there that are always friendly helpfull n knowledgeable, to be honest things cost just a few more bucks then the big chain stores, trade off they get to know ur face n make ya feel known, maybe its me but i like the fact someone recognized me as someone that frequents n spends money in there, when was the last time ya was invany of the big cahan stores n they remembered you, alwsys call ahead for hours open

Hours say they are open utill 7. I am here at 6:25 pm and they are closed.

Like the help I get here

Always have what Im lookin for.

Yesterday was my first time in the store and Im not a handy type of woman so I asked for help and they were great at finding me what I needed. Great price, great service. I will definitely return if I need anything else.

Great little hardware store and very convenient.

Excellent and well stocked neighborhood hardware store. Need help with a project? This is the place

This place is absolutely fantastic. Needed a laser key cut for a landrover. Save me $450 from dealer

Great local shop for your basic home needsVery friendly staff at least the one guy I usually talk to!

The owners and staff (except for one cashier) was EXTREMELY RUDE & unprofessional for the two times I went there, and overall overpriced merchandise anyhow. Don’t give these people business, they don’t deserve it. Support another mom and pop place that actually deserves it.

The only reason I give 2 stars is because this store does have a large stock and they are convenient if you live or work in Mayfair. But the customer service is terrible! I dont know how reviewers say otherwise. I have been in here 3 times recently and each time they were rude and unprofessional. They definitely wont get my business again.

Perfect hardware store

Read Leons comment. They did leave me do an exchange . However, I had a horrifying experience with the bald-headed so called gentlemen. It escalated to him yelling at me when I was in back of the store doing my exchange. Unprofessional !! The owner better wake-up. Reading your comments your making people not want to come back. Im. Glad ! Ive lived here since 1966 and these owners need to wake up. I hope 🙏 they close. I really do! If youre going in for stupid sh* t theyre helpful because they cant handle anything more.

My handicapped father went in to get plexie glass cut he gave the guy the measurements and said he would be back tomorrow with myself to pick it up since he isnt physically able to carry it. The guy told him “What if you get into an accident? I can’t cut it unless your taking it now.” This man was very rude and offended my father. HE IS DISABLED! Meanwhile, him and I go back the next day to get the plexie glass CUT and picked up. He took his time waiting on other customers while making my father stand for a long period of time. Unbelievable! However, the lady at the register was helpful and offered my dad a seat.

Good local hardware store. Has everything. Good for things you forgot to get at Home Depot and dont want to take the hike back. Personal service. A bit more expensive.

Outstanding place. Great serviceFrom people who really know their stuff. Priced lower than other stores on the items I needed.

Always find what I need here. Very nice and helpful staff as well. A+

Friendly, willing to help employees. You can find anything in this store. A bit pricey though and you better pay the parking meter or you will get a parking ticket.

One of the few stores in Mayfair that pretty much stayed as it was In the 70s. Its still a good store. Tuff parking but the people make it worth going. I think in the 70s there was also a hardware store on the block of Walgreen but they closed.

Local hardware store with employees that know what they are doing

They are very friendly and extremely helpful and know exactly what you are looking for when you ask someone there. It takes ten minutes to find someone to help you at Home Depot or Lowes and when you do they tell you that is not my department and they are not sure what you need, so support your local hardware store and go to Penn Hardware!!

The service is excellent, they have a lot more product than you would think in a small hardware store. The guys that worked back counter are very helpful and courteous

Excellent help finding right tools

The people who work there awesome this guy Jimmy is wonderful he helps me with everything

No problems for me what so ever needed my window fixed they fixed it. Even explained what it was.and then today i bought paint came home and two colors didnt come out roght i called the store spoke to owner tokd me i can come back in and any one i dont like there exchange it for free. Thank u penn

Very helpful staff

Went in today for a replacement mop head.. was greeted at the door asked if I needed help. I said yes Im looking for brooms/mops.. OK far back corner he says... go to back look at selection (minimal) dont see one I need so I decide to leave.. at the door Im stopped by lady behind the counter and two men who asked me to empty my pockets... what do you think Id steal a mop? where would I even put it? its not like I was walking around acting weird or anything I was literally I there for 2mins. thats not the friendly neighborhood hardware store I expected.. I wouldnt ever step foot in here again this is no way to treat customers...

Great service! I needed to make a replacement key for my broken key. None of the big hardware stores couldnt do it. This store was able to make a replacement in less than 5 mins.

Never had a problem always very helpful and friendly

Do not go to this place, they hang up on you if they cant understand you for the first second of a phone call. Very rude and I WAS a good loyal customer. Not anymore.

Great help every time and fair neighborhood prices. No complaints

Great customer service.

Grate place to come to and the people that work there are grate and helpful i love this store

All the bad comments about this place is false, Penn Hardware is were you can get reliable service from wholesome people. If you swing by there ask for Zahir and hell help you out. Also say Hi to Jim, they get the job done.

Was a customer for over 15 years . Bought a shop vac cause the guy said it works great well it doesnt my house vaccum is better tried to take it back said i couldnt cause i used it . well how do i know it sucks if i didnt . terrible i even said id be happy with store credit . Thier reply no . Thanks i get for years of patronage even when i knew i could get better prices elsewhere .

Bought a post digger yesterday. Cashier told me i can bring it back if i dont use it. I never even took it out of my car. Tried bringing it back with the receipt and got denied. Theres no policy that says anywhere that says no returns. Just rude employees. I would give 0 stars if i could.

The staff is very helpful and friendly. Owner was thoughtful.

Yes seams like a family store very cool people just ask and they will get it for you.

Very helpful and friendly. Always have what I am looking for without dealing with the huge hardware stores.

This place has everything short of drywall. They will sell you a part and tell you how to install it. Customer service is what they do, ask for jim. His motto is anything for you

Owner repaired my door screen. Had it repaired there in July but even just the wind blew screen out of the frame. This time, he wanted to charge me $30 to re repair the screen, however, humanity called and the gentleman didnt chargr

Great place love going here ! Warn welcome at the door great help .

This place are getovers and thieves!!! Do not go here I am a single parent and have 7 kids at home and I used to come here for help cause Im a woman and count on help for my home and since this was in the neighborhood instead of traveling to a big name store I would come here anyway my circuit breakers were tripping I came for help here they sold me 3 circuit breakers which Cost about 60 dollars and said if they werent right to bring them back but they also suckered me into getting an outlet that I couldnt hook up so I brought that back they kept my receipt for returns and when the 2 circuit breakers didnt fit and I went back for help they said it was my loss!!!! I will chalk it up to a lesson well learned!!! Ithats a disgrace for a man to get over and steal a womans hard earned money like that!!! I would love to see the owner to tell me why they would steal my money and not help me!!! I just wanted the right stuff to help so I dont have a fire in my house!! Thats a shame that there are people in the world so cruel!!!

The best! Love the staff!

Well stocked and A+ service

Bought an item yesterday. I was told if it didnt work I could bring it back. I brought it back the next day and even though they remembered me they would not give my money back because I didnt have a receipt. The lady at the front desk was very rude about it. I will never step foot in this store again.

Listed as open on Sundays. Lies. Very inconvenient.

Do not buy shades from this store

Great! Prompt service

A top notch place

The store has hard to find items, and well knowledged people

Excellent customer service

They dont answer the phone !!!!

Great place

Very helpful

The assistants are stellar