First time, I enjoyed the cheesecake ice cream.

Place has the best ice cream in the world and you can watch football as you wait! We attend very often!! Great family place with outside seating as well!

Went to grab some ice cream with my son. Service was okay, but felt like we inconvenienced them. Very overpriced for the amount of ice-cream and the flavor the bland. The place wasnt very clean considering no one was inside. Their food score is 86, didnt see that till I sat down. Wont return. Save your money and get ice cream that tastes like ice-cream.

We unfortunately arrived later than we hoped, right before closing, but they still welcomed us and gave friendly and wonderful service. And then... the icecream? DELICIOUS!!! I got their fresh made vanilla with brownie bits; I highly recommend. Its worth every penny:)

I have been meaning to write this review for quite some time now. I had the pleasure to visit this location about 3 weeks ago. The icecream was very good and creamy. What stood out to me and the very reason I am writing this review is because of the customer service I received. I forgot the young ladys name at the register but she was amazing. She greeted me with a welcoming smile and she asked if it was my first time there. Once I told her yes she explained the menu to me and told me about all the different ingredients that was offered. She made it so easy for me because I was overwhelmed looking at the menu. I wish I remembered her name but I do remember she was wearing the most adorable popcorn earrings. What a doll you have at your establishment. This is my first time writing a review so kudos to Creamistry located in Newnan. I will definitely be coming back.

The shop was nice and clean. The staff were professional and mannerly, and the ice cream was amazing!

Really good service, pretty good ice cream. My husband got the Speculoos Overload and I got the Ruby Cacao. He loved his, but mine was mostly flavored by the toppings - the actual ice cream tasted like basic vanilla. Definitely could see this place expanding, great place for a cool treat.

Staff left much to be desired and the ice cream wasnt anything special, it was lacking in flavor.

This is excellent ice cream!!! And, they make the ice cream while you watch. It is a bit pricey but it’s both entertainment and great ice cream! I recommend you give it a try.

Man its cool watching them make it with the nitrogen and it fogs up but other than that they had a key lime cheesecake and it actually had a slice of lime in it and OMG it was great

My friend invited me here on a random night and I didnt realize that the name wasnt Creamery until I got inside and saw all the smoke! I was pleasantly surprised to be inside of what I consider to be an adult AP Chemistry class. It was so fun watching the staff make our cold concoctions. They didnt even seem to mind our filming because Im sure that happens a lot there. I loved that there was a nice sized menu already layed out with amazing toppings but you can also make your dessert with whatever you want in shop! The unicorn was my favorite and Im sure itll always be because it has birthday cake Ice cream. Everyone was super friendly.10/10 would eat a unicorn again at Creamistry:⁣Birthday Cake Ice Cream⁣Mini Marshmallows⁣Unicorn Dust⁣Marshmallow Cream

It looks so good and the way they make it is awesome

HUGE fan of this place! Our kids absolutely love it!

Love this place.......The Unicorn is my favorite......cant seem to get away from it......😍 the staff are Super Nice

For starters the customer service was terrible. Secondly, by the time I walked from the front door and 10 feet outside all of our ice cream had completely melted.. not only did it melt but the taste was terrible and it stained my wifes brand new dress. Worst overpriced excuse for ice cream I have ever encountered. And just to top it off I went in to grab some napkins and this kid had the audacity to tell me I had to be a paying customer in order to get napkins. Absurd.

By far the best dessert you can choose after a meal, or when you want to just treat your self!We were instantly greeted by the friendly staff and that cool breeze that saves you from the awful heat.I ordered the birthday cake ice-cream with captain crunch on topI also ordered a non dairy based ice-cream which they provide Almond or coconut milk which is big plus for my non dairy friends.The coconut milk based ice-cream with match flavor was just the perfect pick me up. I also asked for fresh mochi on top.And to top it off I also ordered the Elvis Presley.Banana ice cream with Carmel sauce, CANDIED BACON.. With fresh bananas to balance it all out.I have to say that I was more than impressed. The texture, the flavor blew my expectations out the water. To provide the flavor you ask for and more is hard to come by, Im so used to the generic taste. The ice cream itself has a soft bite but a taffy like pull to it, almost stretchy.The waffle cones are made to order and let me say, pretty damn good by themselves. If you have the will power to even have some to take home, even after a couple of hours theyre still better than store boxed ones.I highly recommend you guys give it a try. The staff was very helpful. They seem to flow pretty well. And are on top of cleaning tables as soon as soon someone leaves. So great desserts, clean place and the great customer service to make your visit enjoyable.

Yummy!!! Great place to get after dinner dessert!!! They have non dairy options available too!!!

The dairy-free/vegan ice cream cake I ordered looked and tasted amazing. Will definitely be getting it again!

1st time trying it... & it was delicious!

People are very nice, service is great, 10/10 would recommend coming here

Amazing ice cream and even better staff!

Friendly staff and very clean inside and out. But it’s way too expensive for unique and decent taste ice cream. Creamistry cost me more than our lunch at newks. I dont think i will return for 8 bucks ice cream unless i win a lottery.

Yessss!!!! Love that theres so many vegan options!!!!! Im lactose intolerant and can never eat ice cream while out with family...now I can lol...Thanks for this awesome ice cream establishment!! Oh and it was really good! Lol

Amazing ice cream! It’s pricey but so yummy!

Loooooong wait time before you are able to go to counter and place order. Almost 20-25mins. They make fresh icecream. We tried Milk Coffee with Brownie chunks and whipped cream on top. While icecream tasted good the brownie chunks were almost as hard as Croutons. Price is a little higher compared to quantity you get and other icecream joints in Newnan but I guess thats ok for this fancy new way to make icecream? Will come again but not when its long lines to order. Also would like to see some more flavours in Grab and Go Freezer as it were only 2-3 flavours during our visit.

Rude employees and they close at 8:30 Monday-Thursday according to the sign. However the rude employees say they close at 8. Will never go back

High quality ice cream and friendly staff! And they fill it up.. you get your money’s worth!

Amazing gluten and dairy free ice cream options made in a separate bowl to ensure safety! Awesome customer service also!

I love this place. I can not say enough nice things about the staff, the cleanliness, and the flavors they have. Its nice to finally have some ice cream options for my lactose intolerant self. My favorite is the unicorn with cashew milk. 😁 I never have to wait too long and the customer service is always 5 stars. I reccomend going here and then going next door to the popcorn place to get a treat for later.I hope this place becomes a Newnan staple for many years to come!

Excited to be able to consume ice cream from a shop as most places do not have vegan options. Its hard being sensitive to dairy and Im glad that creamistry exists. I had the unicorn and my beau had the elemint. Im grateful for the customization ability as well

Its really good ಡ ͜ ʖ ಡ and it fun watch it mafe

Extremely fresh and flavorful. 10/10 on presentation, quality, and cleanliness. And it seems like little to no waste is produced. Great job!!

PLEASE BRING BACK THE PARTY ANIMALLLL. IT WAS MY FAVORITE. 😓😓😓 I LOVE U GUYS THO. UR DOING GREAT SWEETIE 😁😁😁💗💗💗

Wow! What an experience! We walked in to get out of the rain while walking around waiting for our movie to begin. Never been so surprised! They use liquid nitrogen to flash freeze the ice cream. The taste is very rich and creamy! They had a $2 of special for a flavor that was right up my wifes alley. We ordered one to share. Regular price is just shy of $10 for a large. Good deal for the awesome taste! Great customer service! We will definitely return!

Mask friendly thank God. If you’re looking for an ice cream place that will give you peace of mind the staff here is very straight laced about Covid precautions. Gloves,consistent correct mask usage, they even put a little nitro touch on the end for any lingering virus. It was worth my extra money not going to Brewsters or somewhere else where some burnt out staff member is gonna argue with me about putting mask over their nose.Plus they have original flavors and different options other than traditional milk-based ice cream. It’s just cool great for kids when you want more than just a “vanilla” experience.

Delicious~ my new favorite ice cream shop!! I highly recommend Captains Breakfast!!

My grown children and their s/o took me tonight first time ever. It was amazing. I got the Coffee one and since I am a coffee junkie it was perfect choice. My daughter in love was going to pay for mine and hers but the register messed up and the manager/ owner whomever he was just said go ahead. When we got our order my daughter in love went back to see if he had fixed it and to pay but he said it was all ok on the house tonight. We will go back. A big thank you to the gentleman who took care of us.

Waited 30 minutes to get my icecream

The salted caramel crunch with the waffle cone placed through out the delicious cold creamy concoction was so tantalizing! A must try!!!

Really recommend the key lime! You absolutely get what you pay for..... And on another positive note, they are military and law enforcement friendly!

Way too expensive!!! Not very good service. Disappointed

Delicious and cool experience

The absolute best ice cream I’ve ever had in my 33 years of being alive!

The only way to have ice cream. My daughter cant get enough of this place. Great staff and very friendly.

I cant believe how creamy the ice cream is when you make it with liquid nitrogen! This was the best ice cream I have ever eaten. My only wish is I should have asked them for some extra caramel because that is my favorite topping. I definitely recommend taking kids there because they would love seeing all the smoke when they pour in the nitrogen. It is both a culinary and entertaining event.

Its really, really good stuff !!!! Best Ice Cream Ive ever had, but it aint cheap. High quality comes with a price. It is a slow process but its worth the wait. I highly recommend trying it !!!! 👍👍👍👍

Best Ive cream and creative combinations. Not to mention, its just plain gin to watch.

The concept with making custom ice cream with liquid nitrogen is really novel. The flavor combinations are pretty good too. However, after coming here twice, I dont find the flavor or skill with with the sundaes are made to be anything special. The teenagers working the counter arent very skilled and the final product bears minimal resemblance to what is in the picture. The ice cream is definitely good, but doesnt seem worth the premium you pay over and above other ice cream stores. Im sure well be back, but its not a place that I would ever have to go to. I would love to see a froyo place at Ashley Park again!

Tons of fun and unique flavors. The nitrogen mixing machines are fun to watch. Try the Elvis - banana, peanut butter, & candied bacon!

Over priced and the ice cream is oddly bland. However, Its fun to watch them make it.

Tried for the first time Creamistry last night. Super nice employees, nice building, very popular place. I wasn’t impressed with my s’mores ice cream. I didn’t understand the hype. It was just chocolate ice cream with marshmallows and whip cream. Nothing fancy and not that great

Our 14th month grandchild loved the strawberry sorbet. So did my wife and myself little price but well worth the stop in

Outstanding!! Super clean. Friendly service. Fast and delicious!!

Loved ice cream

The creamiest ice cream ever and so many options to choose from. My goal: try every one of the creations !!!! 10/10

Staff is wonderful and the ice cream is amazing!!

Very neat and fun place. Great ice cream too

The ice cream was amazing and it was neat to watch it being made with the nitrogen!

Very good, try the Spuculoos one

Amazing! So good itll keep you cool in this heat!

Tried the cashew cream base...it was amazing!

Great ice cream but very pricey 🤔

Ice cream was delicious!!! The workers were very nice, helpful, and we loved it!!

Very Tasty 😋 but kind of pricey ~

Delicious ice cream and personable owner & staff!

Grab a fresh waffle cone from here and head to Cold Stone for some good ice cream . I was fooled by the gimmick of it being flash frozen . Extremely bland and unfortunately the staff isn’t very friendly . Ours was thrown together very haphazardly and slid across the counter without even a “here ya go”. It wasn’t that crowded when we walked in but maybe they had a stressful day ?

The banana pudding is bomb!

Wow, love the uniqueness!

Ice cream was superb!

Neat concept, very expensive for what you get

Big fan of cereal on ice cream! ❤

The tastiest of treats

Too Good

Milk free options on point.

Kind of pricey and it takes a minute for you to get your order but definitely worth it!!

Not worth no $10

Great fresh ice cream. Love this place.Note: please update open hours in Google to match actual store hours. Thanks.

Good .. but a little expensive ..