The place is clean, and well organized. All of their desserts look cute and fun.I tired green tea, rainbow cookies and also red velvet cake. Unfortunately, I did not enjoy green tea cookie and the cake at all. Green tea cookie was too gooey and too bitter. About red velvet cake, I should have asked whether their red velvet cake is with cream cheese frosting or not… I am a big fan of fluffy / moist sponge and cream cheese frosting red velvet cake, but it was far from my favorite kind… Also, I do not like fondant icing at all.It was just not my style and did not like taste but, I enjoyed looking at them :)

There are no words in this world to explain how this man save my day today. How grateful I am to be in right place in right time Thank you today for your help even though your store was closed ( Labor Day ) This chocolate cake was beyond amazing. Delicious …you made my husband’s birthday a blast. You gained a grateful customer because I have more birthday coming 😁 up.I really recommend you and your products to friends and family. It’s a great quality pastry Thank you again

Cookies were all so good!! A bit pricey but it is a pretty good size. They have a good variety of flavors to choose from. The space looks really nice and very clean and well kept. The variety of designs is impressive! Definitely stop by for some treats when in the area. You will keep coming back for more!!

To-go:Sultry Red Velvet Half Pound Cookie. Thats a next-level cookie. One of the few cookies in NYC that I enjoyed comparably to Levain (although its very different stylistically).Brownie Nouveau. A slightly above-average brownie.The server said that, because my total was $10, I could get a free slice of cake, tonight-only!? So I had a Chocolate Decadence Nice Slice. I think it was above average, but at that point Id had too much sugar to make a critical assessment.Note: These were packaged more prettily than my photos show. I biked them home, secured by a taut elastic cord that squished them, and then took the food photos, so they look unfairly unflattering.

I love their new place. Its such a contrast from their former location not far away. Their wonderful pasteries however have not changed in quality.

We met with Benny to discuss our cake for an upcoming wedding. It was everything we could have asked for and more. From the taste testing to the final design, City Cakes hit the mark each time. It was a hit at our reception with many guests taking portions of the cake home. Will do business with again! Also, their cookies are out of this world.

Service with a sweetooth! Staff is always super friendly, they know me by name! Treats are fresh and vary from month to month. Mask is required and they are LGTBQ+ friendly.

Ive been both a loyal customer and a fan of City Cakes for many years. I came to know the bakery in an unusual way. Years ago, a very charismatic fitness guru held these amazing extreme sweat inducing classes in NYC and some people from City Cakes attended. From the first time I went in and bought something, I was hooked.Over the years Ive enjoyed ordering custom cakes (amazing choices) as well as some of the stock items. Im thrilled that City Cakes opened a larger retail store near their original location on W 18th Street and I will continue to show my support.Ive put together some photos of things ordered over the last decade. Unfortunately, I dont have photos of some of the more dramatic cakes Ive received.If you are ever in town (or live here) and want a sweet treat or amazing celebratory confection, please check out City Cakes.

OMG. This place has AMAZING HUGE FRESH COOKIES. I was looking for a fresh Snickerdoodle cookie everywhere in Manhattan, and, surprisingly, they are really hard to find. City cakes had a cookie called a Sugardoodle which was half pound of sugary, cinnamon-y, buttery, doughy goodness. It was so tasty! I also got the Almond Matcha cookie, because it is such a unique mix of absolutely delicious flavors. Make sure you really want decadent Cookies when you come in, these are not for the faint hearted. Cookies are baked fresh, weigh 1/2 lb and are totally worth the $5.50 - $6.50 each price point. YUM

Was a very nice first will be coming back. To try the sticky bun. The whole store was great walking in. Love all the Alice wonderland treat 🌟👏😌😊🤘

This is the best thing that has happened in Chelsea & NY fkn City! 👏So exciting, friendly, delicious and inspirational! The best 1 pounder cookies and cakes. With design to die for! If you want an explosion of delicious flavors in your mouth, gain some pounds here by making it worth it...Bravo Mark!

One of my favorite cookies in the city! So many great flavors and seasonal varieties that keep me coming back. Their COVID-19-friendly setup is perfect for a grab and go, and it is incredibly safe for both customer and staff.I haven’t tried everything there, but I sure am working on it!

They have changed locations. Anyway.. the chocolate decadent cake slice was tasty and moist, but the vanilla funfetti was dry and underwhelming in taste. Excellent customer service.

Im always looking out for cookies and cupcakes to satisy my sweet tooth. I was thrilled to learn of City Cakes and their half-pounds. Despite being $5.50 per cookie...Ive paid close to that amount for cookies not half that size...so I decided to at least give them a try. The space itself is lovely...very modern and clean. There is a counter where you can buy cookies ($5.50), cake slices ($8.00), cupcakes ($4.00) and other pastries. There are lots of delicious options but I went for the Dark Chocolate and Gingerbread. Be mindful that some of the cookies are filled with creams/frosting. After paying I waited for a few minutes while the cookies were deivered to the front in a nice box via conveyor belt! How cool. The cookies were really good. I would have liked them to be a tad softer....but that may not be possible when baking a half-pound cookie...without it being raw. Both cookies I had were mildly soft in the very center and practically crunchy about a inch from the edges. They did taste good though....I tasted fresh and rich gingerbread and chocolate. My household smelled the gingerbread throughout the room as soon as I opened the box at home. :) There are some other misc. items for sale there as well. There is also a cake counter where you can place your order for custom cakes. The few they had in the case looked delicious. According to their website, their cakes are priced per slice and start at $8-10 per slice. Overall I did enjoy the cookies and hope to return to try some cake slices and cupcakes.

Wow! City cakes opened up their newest location this week and I had a chance to visit while picking up my Yelpie award (yay!)! I also got to choose a slice of cake, cookie and a drink. I love the feel of the place and the colorful cakes, cookies and even drinks they have to choose from. You can also have icing and sprinkles added to any cookie! They are boxed beautifully and come out to you on a cute conveyor belt. I was also really impressed by the cake creations they had on display. The cookies and cake were sweet, fresh and absolutely delicious.Open now with safety measures in place. Please support your local businesses!

Im in California and ordered a six pack of cupcakes to be delivered to my daughters college dorm. I called ahead to be sure her name was on the delivery. They were super helpful and the cupcakes were an unexpected treat for my birthday girl. She loved them. Thank you🧁!!

Love this place so much! From a tiny little below street level hole to a gorgeous showroom for its impressive artistry and delicious sweets; City Cakes is definitely one of the best! Cupcakes are my least favorite. Half-pound cookies are amazing, as are the cakes and other pastries Ive had.

Really wanted to like this place but it was just unsatisfying. Confetti cake and cinnabon were stale and dry. Peanut butter cookie was better, but incomparable to Levains.

City Cakes has been in NYC for over 10 years, I have been an avid fan and customer since its inception. They recently moved to their new expanded and GORGEOUS space. It has unbelievable pastries specifically their half pound cookie and cupcakes - YUM! Their custom cakes are some of the most beautiful pieces I have ever seen created. If you wanted to - there is an academy in the shop to learn as well - a full service establishment. Not to mention the staff is beyond friendly and sweet - no pun intended. If you havent been here, youre missing out, plain and simple. GO!

Hands down, the BEST cookies! The shop is cute and so many flavors and treats to choose from. I was in NY for 4 days, and came here twice. Ugh, so good!! I would say I wish we had one in Texas, but no need when you can order online and have them mailed to you. Dangerous for my wallet, but sooooooo worth it!! Yum yum yymmmmmm

Unpopular opinion but I think they do better cookies than Levain. Don’t get me wrong I love Levain but City Cakes are seriously under appreciated. The cookies are a half pound so they are expensive but they are huge and delicious. They have a variety of flavors and you can add frosting to any cookie. They recently moved to a newer and much bigger location on 18th from the basement they were operating out of for years. The milk chocolate is filled with Nutella which is a must try and the snickerdoodle is one of their best flavors.

My first time at the new location and it was great! Lots of fun things to peruse and my order came out very quickly. Looking forward to going back!

Ive had two sticks of butter softening on my counter for a week... but didnt have the motivation to make cookies of my own. You can only follow City Cakes on insta so much before giving in to temptation! I havent had their cookies in several years being outside of NYC, but I ordered online. They arrived perfectly in two days thru UPS ground, packed perfectly snug in their box. I opted for reheating at 350 for only 8 minutes and they were plenty gooey/soft for me! Just as delicious as I remember... but I seem to have forgot just how filling one is as my eyes were definitely bigger than my stomach! Its a lot of cookie even for a cookie lover like me, so beware! Consider sharing or approach with an empty stomach!

Great cookies! Had the Dark Horse Salted Double Chocolate Chip and Signature Sugardoodle. You’re paying $5-$6 for one, but they’re huge cookies.

I got a regular chocolate chip cookie but now I wish I tried all of their cookies. It was bomb! They’re huge so feel free to keep them in your fridge and save them for another day or share them with a friend (as intended). I shared it with people I knew because there was no way a small girl like me could finish that huge cookie. I really did enjoy it, definitely one of my top 10 favourite cookies.

Great experience ordering birthday cake for my kid! I got lemon flavored cake with chocolate frosting. The cake was moist and the frosting was perfect - not too sugary and very nice chocolate flavor. But the best thing was the design! I asked for a birthday cake with a monkey on top and the execution could not be more perfect, the monkey was adorable. I didnt even get a chance to take a picture of the whole cake since a bunch of children swarmed me and demanded to eat the monkey.

City Cakes is one of the few places that the cakes are so fork tender that they don’t need ice cream. The strawberry champagne cake is exquisite, soaked with a champagne sauce, and frosted with a decadent but not overly sweet white chocolate butter cream. Cakes likes these are the reason why I don’t like sharing sweets. The new bakery is glistening and pristine. Amazing and friendly staff where legit your order comes out in a conveyor belt. Everything they offer will please anyone. From an array of gigantic filled cookies to gluten free peanut butter and jelly bars which I snatched a few. Ate them in seconds! If you’re in the area or visiting out of state. Stop by and see what the buzz is all about and fulfill your sugar cravings. Chef Marc and the staff are doing a phenomenal job!

These cookies are excellent. The lady working the register was very helpful when I was making my selection. I consider these cookies to be a less know, but better version of some other more well-known cookies in NYC. I’d come back here before going to Schmackery’s or Milk Bar.

My family, friends and I (not to mention all the visitors we used to have pre-pandemic) LIVE for City Cake cookies. My husband and I recently celebrated our one year wedding anniversary and my mom (who lives out of state) had a beautiful carrot cake (which I’ve recently learned is also gluten free!!) delivered to us. I was shocked when I saw where it was from, and had no idea City Cakes offered Takeaway Cakes! It was the most delicious carrot cake EVER with toffee/butterscotch garnish on top. 10/10 recommend City Cakes for all things cookies, cupcakes and CAKES! 😍PS- couldn’t wait before digging in to snap a picture but got one nonetheless! 🤩

Chef Benny did an amazing job bringing my vision to life for my boyfriends 30th birthday. Quick, responsive service, incredible artistry, and the best tasting cake I’ve ever had. Will come back again and again for all my custom cake needs. Thanks Chef Benny and City Cakes!

I had a custom cake made for my husbands birthday. It far exceeded our expectations! It was the most photographed part of the party! The executive chef of the place even came down to see the cake since everyone was talking about it. it was truly a work of art! I would give them 100 stars if I could!

The Smores cake was absolutely amazing! The cookies were good; I wanted to sample them as a pastry chef myself. If I go back it would be just for the Smores cake!

Best cookies ever! I ordered these online after hearing so many wonderful things about them. They were all true. The cookies are huge and delicious. I ordered 2 packs of them. They came so quickly and the customer service was super friendly. Ive already eaten a few and froze the rest. So excited to order more!

I purchased a cake for my daughters 2nd bday over the weekend and it was so rich and soft. They were very professional and showed me the cake prior to placing it in a box. Very highly recommended

This off-the-beaten-path bakery turns out amazing cake creations and legendary half-pound cookies that will keep you coming back for more. Stop in their little shop to pick up cupcakes and cookies in person or get your sweet tooth fix via delivery (local and Nationwide).

Cakes looked beautiful but the cupcake I got was very dry

Absolutely delicious baked goods! Their cookies are HUGE but SOOOO good and so fresh! I really recommend anything and everything here.

If you’re riding or driving past this place you could easily miss it. Thus you’ll be missing out on some of NYC’s greatest baked goodies. And she’s such a nice person with a easy smile. Schedule some gym time in and enjoy.

I come to this small but mighty bakery every few weeks because I’m hopelessly addicted to each and every one of their always on-point cookies 😂🤤 it’s a hidden jewel that I take all my buddies to for dessert if we’re in the area and even the most hard-to-please people love it! Basically GO!! ❤️

The cookies were okay, pretty greasy. I had the snickerdoodle and red velvet cookies through Ubereats app.

Great cakes with super friendly and efficient service. I highly recommend it.

They did an absolute amazing birthday cake. I had asked for the classic “happee birthdae harry” cake and they made it identical. I’m super happy it came out the way I wanted it to, and the chocolate cake was amazing on top of that. I’ll definitely be coming back! such talented, amazing people who work here!

My wife and I walked by it on our way to take care of some business. He have been looking for a good bakery in NYC that is comparable to a famed bakery in NC. We found City Cakes and THEY DID NOT DISAPPOINT! We bought a slice of carrot cake and a 1/2 pound red velvet cookie! OMG! WE ARE SO HAPPY WE FOUND YOU! DONT GO ANYWHERE!!

The red velvet cookie is to die for! The shop is cute and inviting. Also I posted a picture on my Instagram story that they responded to, and it’s always nice to see how invested a business is in their customers satisfaction. Worth your support!

Truly amazing! Great customer service, too. We recommend sharing because the cookies are huge! We especially loved the Macamochip Cookie and Salted Caramel Cupcake.

Absolutely delicious baked goods! Their cookies are HUGE but SOOOO good and so fresh! I really recommend anything and everything here. Some of the other baked goods are pricey but its worth it. I love eating here. Prices are reasonable. Feels similar to a cafe in Chicago I loved. I bought some for my family members too and they praised about its freshness and crunch. City Cakes is best cookie shop in New York City.

Oh so good. Soft and flavourful. Worth the search and the price.

I ordered cookies on Monday and they were delivered on Wednesday just like their website said They were for my husband’s birthday who works in NY and was away from home on his birthday! He loved them and said he could barely finish ONE! These are seriously what I would call New York style cookies! Big and delicious!

Got a cup cake for my son he said it was good they do have beautiful cakes and sliced caked that look delicious. A small and i mean small cupcake is about 5.00

City cakes is a must stop in NYC. They have the best cookies. Don’t let the size stop you from ordering a variety of flavors. I promise you won’t be disappointed. Take some home to store in your freezer or give to your favorite friends.

City Cakes is just the best. Their cookies are top notch, their cupcakes are delicious, and their customer service is absolutely wonderful. If you’re searching for a great bakery in NYC, look no further. I will never stop coming here because I am always blown away by the food quality and lovely environment/vibe.

I recently just discovered this new Bakery on 7th Avenue and 18th street. Wonder full assortment of cookies and cakes. The experience is unique, especially when you order comes to you via conveyor belt.. Plus on return trip must try sticky buns.

Bad experience greasy breakfast served in to go boxes the pastries are not great

The snicker doodle cookie was soooo good!! Also tried the chocolate raspberry cupcake and it really hit the spot. Kinda weird ordering from an intercom but was worth it!

Chef Benny created our gorgeous wedding cake! We have received several comments that it was the best wedding cake some folks have ever had!!! We went with the chefs recommendation of Amaretto Cake with original butter cream. It was amazing!!!!! Plus City Cakes is wonderful to work with :)

Anything and everything I try is always amazing! Love the cookies! The cupcakes! Really magical place and great customer service ❤️

Best cookies and cupcakes I have ever had 💯💯💯The Almond Matcha half pound cookie is hands down my favorite, though 🍪🧁

These cookies are out of this world! They arrived carefully packed, individually wrapped and placed inside lovely gift boxes. Super friendly and responsive staff. Definitely my new go-to for cookie gifting.

INCREDIBLE COOKIES. I have been going to City Cakes for a few years and always take friends/family here. A cookie for everyone. Theyre HUGE, so you get your moneys worth and are actually good. Soft, thick, chewy, buttery...everything a cookie should be. Plus they have specialties so check them out on Insta!

The treats are yummy!

Excellent customer service and delicious bakes.

City Cakes has the most amazing cookies. Their little shop is below ground, so you might miss it, but keep your eye out because it will change your life. I am a cookie fanatic. I have tried most cookie places in NYC, but City Cakes it different than most. It feels like a home. You can feel the love that goes into each product. The sugardoodle is amazing!!!! It is perfectly gooey and flavorful at the same time baked to absolute perfection. I would recommend this place to anyone, and have brought several of my friends here because it’s just so amazing.

Love the funfetti cakes and cupcakes! Also had a Reese’s pieces peanut butter cookie. Everything is delicious and not too sweet. Friendly and helpful staff!

We ordered two cakes for milestone birthdays after seeing a GMA feature and we were not disappointed. The cakes were works of art and the taste was amazing. They were moist, flavorful, and decadent without being overly sweet. The workmanship of each were absolutely beautiful and we could not be happier. We are spreading the word and will be back to order more from them!

What a Beautiful space! Cupcakes as good as always.

Their cookies are on my list every time I visit NYC!

My husband got my 30th birthday cake from city cakes. The customer service was amazing and they stayed open a little later so my husband could pick it up. He told me the price was reasonable. The cake was so SO delicious. Weve gotten so many compliments and questions about the cake. Thank you!

Our daughter ordered cookies for her dad’s bday and even though USPS took 10 days to deliver the cookies are still delicious! My husband kept smiling at the size and weight... and the taste!

Legitimately the best. Most gluten-free options are crunchy or lackluster, but City Cakes GF cookies and cupcakes are the real deal: moist, fresh, appropriately dense & chewy, and flavorful. Plus they consistently have a variety so Im not relegated to the ONE thing thats GF (unlike in many bakeries and shops where they carry a token item). City Cakes is worth the calories every time. Plus you can have em shipped!

I live right near City Cakes, and it’s one of my absolute go-to spots in Chelsea. Their half-pound cookies are just what you want: flavorful, decadent, crispy on the outside and gooey on the inside. Topped with frosting (original or vanilla) plus sprinkles, and you have a beautiful and delicious dessert. My favorite cookies are chocolate chunk and Macamochip, which has macadamia nuts, puffed rice, chocolate chunks, and nutella. Go for the cookies, but also don’t miss their cupcakes; they’re equally delicious!

We had a birthday party for my friend Sam the Gucci cake box looked so amazing no one wanted to cut through it. Thank you so much for making the event extra special. Delivery on point .

Milk chocolate cookies are the best. Tried others — sugar, Reeses Pieces etc — but nothing beats them. The cupcakes are also nice.

Great bakery with a selection of gluten free cookies and cupcakes. They also do intricate occasion cakes that look and taste good - they made a giant edible koala for my 16th birthday.

Food was delicious, the associates were professional and polite. Parking was tough however.

Best bakery in NYC!!! All there bake goods are amazing and bursting with flavor...

The cookies are so good. Definitely worth the price

LET THEM EAT CAKE--aaand cookies, cupcakes, scones, and other baked treats at City Cakes. apparently this is City Cakes newer, larger location: well-designed (easy to social distance), superclean, brightly lit, and has a friendly modern warmth to it. if you didnt know, City Cakes is a small locally-owned bakery that is a shiny new gem in the Chelsea area.discovered this place via the Yelpie promotion, and i am glad i didnt let the cold, wet weather dissuade me from going. it was well worth the trip. i tried the 1) Almond Tricolor Wonder cake. the cake slice was HUGE and easily shareable by 2-3 people. i really loved the smooth almond buttercream, the three thick layers of colorful cake, the raspberry and apricot flavors, and the dark chocolate exterior...expectations exceeded by this colorful explosion of cake and flavors. for peanut butter fans, there is no better option than the 2) Reeses Pieces Half Pound Cookie. again, easily shareable by 2-3 people. really captures the peanut butter-iness without being overshadowed by sugar/sweetness. the half-pound cookie has a nice amount of softness and crumble so its midpoint for any cookie fan. i bought a strawberry shortcake cupcake and i have to say this was one helluva of a cupcake--simple yet the effort could be tasted from the actual shortcake itself to the vanilla buttercream to that sweet strawberry sauce. AMAZING!City Cakes also displays a gallery of edible artistry in the front of the store. the amazing looking art is currently inspired by Alice in Wonderland. beyond the art, City Cakes offers options on custom cake, cookies, cupcakes & more to order/create/purchase as well as classes on creating cake masterpieces.the staff are incredibly friendly and know their stuff. i had a bunch of questions and needed some recs and they were happy to oblige. great vibeseven the boxes have instructions on how to optimally store and warm up the baked treats. City Cakes really does care that you have the best experience enjoying their eats whether youre at their store or at home.

City cakes makes the best cookies that i have ever had. plus the super talented team is also extremely nice!

We heard great things about City Cakes so we decided to order the Dark and Spicy Fall Favorites. These are the best cookies ever! Layers of flavor--definitely the best cookies ever.

Best cookies of your life. Texture and taste is immeasurable. Great quality cookies!

One of my favorite local bakeries and my go-to for their half-pound cookies. They also make delightful custom cakes that are perfect for birthdays.

City Cakes is THE absolute best when it comes to sweets and people. I came here the first time I visited NYC after they reached out to me on Instagram as a place to visit. Let me tell you, these cookies are no joke, easily the softest, tastiest cookies Ive ever had. On top of all that, they have the sweetest staff! If youre in the area or are in need of a sweet online delivery, I highly recommended City Cakes to everyone and anyone.

Best cupcakes Ive had in the city

The best

My friend recommended this place to me and I didnt know that cookies could taste this good until I came here. Firstly, this place is like a little hole-in-the wall place, underground. They have stamp cards, so make sure you get one of those so you can stock up on these delicious half pound cookies. AND they have snickerdoodle flavor which is my favorite ever! The cookies are crispy on the outside and thick and soft on the inside. Its like eating a cookie cake. I also tried the chocolate chip flavor and that was DELICIOUS. I highly recommend coming here if you want a cookie that will absolutely blow your mind. You get a lot of cookie for $5. I had to share with 3 other people to finish. Even then, I wanted more after. Being back in LA, Im for sure craving city cakes while writing this review.

My go to for special occasions, or just because I have a huge sweet tooth. I always make a point to pick up some half pound cookies when I’m home in NY visiting family. But even when I’m away, they’ll ship to overseas military APOs, which is amazing. They always have fun, unique flavors and I love that their cookies can be frozen and still taste amazing (though I usually eat them all before I can freeze them). They are a great small business doing big things!

This bakery does not hold itself accountable I’m in Oklahoma and reading the replies from this bakery saying it’s the customers fault or problem is absurd they cry over one star rating over a person opinion I would never do business with them if I came to New York they do not take criticism very well if they keep continuing to cry 😭 and not be held accountable they business will go down under

Excelent, delicious, accesible

We worked with Chef Benny for our wedding cake last month and we were SO happy! The cake tasted amazing and looked so beautiful. It was beyond our expectations. Chef Benny was so nice and very easy to work with during the whole process. I have to say that we picked City Cakes both because of the flavor of the cakes (the chocolate ganache and hazelnutella buttercream are phenomenal) as well as Chef Benny. He really loves what he does and it shows in his work. We will recommend Chef Benny over and over for any wedding or special occasion cake... or even just for his delicious baked goods! Thank you Chef Benny and City Cakes team for making my favorite part of any wedding (the cake!) a grand slam success!

City Cakes’s half pound cookies are one of my favorite desserts in NYC! I know the shop has “cake” in the name, but do not sleep on their cookies! Sometimes cookies of this size are dry or crumbly, but City Cakes’s are perfectly chewy with a soft center. My favorite is the classic chocolate chip, but the red velvet is a close second! I love to bring them as a hostess gift to dinner parties because they’re much easier to transport than a frosted cake or cupcakes (I’ve had many subway dessert casualties) but they still have the “wow factor” because of their sheer size and weight. Or, if you really want the look of a cake, you can order a stack of cookies with layers of icing in between, so it looks like a layer cake. City Cakes also ships nationwide, so I always recommend sending cookies as a great birthday or holiday gift for friends and family who live outside of NYC.

Love the red velvet cookie. Its big and the filling is addictive. Yummy!!!

The absolute BEST cupcakes in NYC! Perfect balance of tasty, flavorful cake topped with the most delicious icing ever. Perfect size and flavors, all delicious! Follow the numbers on the building (#251, lower level), otherwise you may miss this gem...absolutely fabulous!

This place is hands down the best cookie place in all of New York. Im so glad we made a stop in!! Im reading some of these reviews and the logic is so bizarre to me-- too sweet? half-pound??? LIKEEE.... Its a cookie, its gonna be sweet. And if you have a problem with the cookie being a half pound, why would you step into a bakery that specializes in HALF POUND cookies?! I just dont know. Anyway, please listen to the other great reviews, this place is just phenomenal!

These cookies are absolutely amazing!!!!!!! Seriously the best cookies I have ever had. The people at the bakery are very nice and helpful. The owner is a doll, hes so sweet and seriously one of the very best places to visit while in NYC. You wont be sorry.

I brought 6 half pound Cookies for New Year Eve party. And Man, these cookies are super sweet... We felt like eating 1/2 pound of sugar. I have to give a 1 star because we end up throwing these cookie. If you like sweet sweet cookie, this is for you.

Got there near six, it wasnt packed at all. The staff was very welcoming and observant.

Loved my order from city cakes! These cookies do not disappoint. They are still so soft when you get them, I even froze a couple and when thawed out they were soft. They are really good if you pop them in the microwave for a few seconds, but they don’t even need it. The pricing for the cookies, as big as they are is great too! Too many cookie companies overprice their cookies but not city cakes!

Fantastic artisan cakes.

City Cakes went above and beyond my expectations in every aspect! They were extremely prompt for starters. I was trying to surprise a good friend of mine for his birthday so attempted to place an order online and then called because I had a very short window to work with (15 minutes). Was shocked to receive a text within minutes of leaving a voicemail (with a loud screaming baby in the background). I honestly didn’t even expect a return call.Then I was contacted about the delivery specifics which were quite difficult as I was trying to surprise someone on the go in NYC which is hard! The address wouldn’t come up on google maps or in their system but after multiple text messages back and forth, they made it happen.If you’re looking for a place that goes above and beyond for their customers, call them! You will not be disappointed. I couldn’t have asked for a better turnout.Thank you City Cakes for making this special day happen! ❤️❤️

I’ve ordered City Cakes online and they are hands down one of the best cookie services you can purchase online. They are like it’s fresh out of the oven to your doorstep. The quality alone is worth the money!