user
Papa Gelateria
318 Highland Ave, New Castle, PA 16101, United States
Appearance
Papa Gelateria
Comments
Pa
Review №1

Amazing Gelato! This is such a gem. Great atmosphere, decor, and beautiful patio shaded by trees and with a great view.The pistachio is very authentic, ans one of the best I’ve had-nice chunks of chewy pistachio.

Na
Review №2

Maybe I went at an off time. Thursday at 3 pm. No one in the business, but the person taking the order. I ordered a panini, the veggie option. They were out of the greens.The inside along with the outside was not tidy. I did try the gelato, which was delicious. But with the atmosphere and lack of attention from young man behind the counter I wont be going back anytime soon. At least the had a poster explaining the process.

HF
Review №3

Excellent Gelato, it is however difficult to find but tucked away in a neat location. Banana and strawberry are great and cookie dough is right up there as well. Theres a covered porch like sitting area. The gentleman working was less than enthusiastic to be there, maybe because it was a Friday afternoon. They were also out of alot of flavors, I guess the key is to get there early. Ill probably return.

Re
Review №4

Pretty good place for gelato. They have some interesting and delicious flavors. The Young man that owns the place is very friendly. Its in kind of a weird location which can make parking a little complicated for some. It is definitely a small mom and pops type business. I would highly recommend this place to others. (We need to patronize small businesses before there is none left)

Ra
Review №5

Nice little hidden coffee spot. Good homemade-style treats and coffee.

Gr
Review №6

Great selection of flavors and huge portions. Now that they got the temperature right in the freezer its a perfect consistency.

Jo
Review №7

The staff was friendly. The flavor was rich. I want to return to try their coffee!

Re
Review №8

This place was a pleasant surprise. I love their Gelato.

An
Review №9

Great little spot with delicious Gelato. Cant wait to try more things on the menu.

Jo
Review №10

Excellent authentic gelato and pastries, this place is a gem hidden in the historic district of New Castle. The owner is always friendly and seems to truly love his business. We wait patiently for them to announce all their new goodies!

Ph
Review №11

I ended up stopping in for some gelato after popping by the highschool for pictures. I then proceeded to try everything in their menu, and am glad to say, I enjoyed everything I tasted. I stayed there for 4 hours and didnt want to leave. The owner is a very relaxed and friendly young man and I enjoyed chatting with him. Wish I could live there, hands down one of the best experiences in this town.

Jo
Review №12

Just stopped in after a day of hiking with the family. We opted to get the $20 sample platter. Loved every flavor, we will certainly stop back again soon

Pa
Review №13

Guy at counter was helpful n friendly gelato is very good

Se
Review №14

Such a CUTE parlor!!! Definitely recommend their Dark Chocolate, its SOO good!

Ze
Review №15

Very tasty and great service. Awesome and really nice location! Even at night!

Fr
Review №16

The absolute best gelato!

Gi
Review №17

Outstanding! Best Gelato Ive had since Italy

Mi
Review №18

As one of the very few Italians left in New Castle; The last of a dying breed of people, if you will, I would like to tell you all that this gelato tastes of my people, of our culture, of our rich, silky history. Pictured is the Tiramisu gelato in regular size. The gelato is excellent. The location is well appointed and very casual and relaxing. The staff and owner are very friendly. Support a local business and have a delicious treat!

Ry
Review №19

Great staff and amazing ice cream. Also they have the best coffee around.

Sh
Review №20

The place itself is really cute and very homey. The staff there are also super sweet and considerate. The gelato was so good I highly recommend it over any other place.

Da
Review №21

Amazing 😁

Ch
Review №22

Amazing gelato & very nice employees!

Sh
Review №23

Love this place. What will I do until spring???

Rb
Review №24

Very good gelato

Gl
Review №25

Best Gelato in town

mi
Review №26

Excellent Gelato

Li
Review №27

Awesome gelato

Jo
Review №28

SO DELICIOUS!

Jo
Review №29

Amazing Atmosphere

Information
84 Photos
29 Comments
4.9 Rating
  • Address:318 Highland Ave, New Castle, PA 16101, United States
  • Site:https://papagelateria.com/
  • Phone:+1 412-529-9818
Categories
  • Ice cream shop
Service options
  • Dine-in:Yes
Highlights
  • Great dessert:Yes
Planning
  • Quick visit:Yes
Payments
  • Debit cards:Yes
  • NFC mobile payments:Yes
  • Credit cards:Yes
Similar organizations