The Horse as my friends and I call it is a great place to chill and play. The employees are fantastic and really kind and help you out with anything from magic to comics. They let me know when the newest issues are in and help me find whatever cards I may need. T and the owner Ron help me find stuff in record time and really know magic like the back of their hand. If it’s casual or Friday night magic playing there is fun and the atmosphere they make with the people and music is super inviting.

Camry was awesome! Answered all questions I had, and was great to converse with. Thank you so much!

I have my comic subscriptions with them and have special order some things as gifts and they always make it perfect and a great experience

The store was easy to navigate and find everything that I needed. Jason was extremely helpful in answering any questions that I had.

My son is huge Pokémon card collector. He loves going there. They have always been very nice to him - one employee knows him when he sees him and just hands him the price guide! I think the place is really clean, organized, and will definitely continue to go back.

My wife and I have always loved coming to this store, and never had any issues whatsoever. Staff has always been friendly and pricing was reasonable (preorders are always cheaper than regular purchases).With the shortage of inventory and also the issue of resellers, I do not have a problem with stores raising their prices slightly above MSRP. But what I have experienced a couple days ago was enough for me to say, that I will no longer give this store my business.I placed a preorder for the celebrations set and requested 2 of every item. When I received the first preorder on release day, every item was marked up over MSRP and seemed higher than usual. It was high enough for me to call the store back and ask for a breakdown by item. While each item seemed to have been raised a little bit in price, I was shocked when I found out that they doubled the price on the Lance’s Charizard V box.Yesterday I picked up my second half of the preorder, two ultra premium boxes and two pikachu vmax figure collection boxes. The ultra premium boxes were $250 ($120 retail) and the pikachu vmax boxes were $100-$119 can’t recall exact price (retail is $49.99). When I asked to just get the premium boxes and not take the pikachu vmax figures, I didn’t have that option. I had to purchase all 4 items or none, which I absolutely didn’t understand. If you’re upcharging an item by that much on a preorder, I assume the store believes that they can sell it for the same price to another customer, if not for even more than that, as they always charge less for preordered items?! I don’t want to make any accusations but everyone can form their own opinion on why you make someone purchases all items or none, where one item is very exclusive and not easily to come by, and the other is available in bulk at target or Walmart for $49.99 and even on eBay for $70-$80.While $130 over retail seems very high, I was more than willing to pay $250 for the premium box. At that price it makes reselling a lot less profitable for people, but it is still low enough for collectors to get their value back. What I absolutely disagree with is charging double or more than double for items that are readily available at retail stores and still cheaper when purchased from individual reseller online. That is not behavior I expect from a store that is all about the community and the hobby.

Went to Four Horsemen on Monday October 4 with my husband and told the guy running the register we were interested in buying Pokémon cards and he handed us the price list (keep in mind you legally have to sell an item at the price you have listed at-otherwise if you don’t it is called False Advertising) after we looked at the list and figured out all the cards we wanted we told the guy we’d be dropping a few hundred dollars on cards and had him pull out all the cards we wanted. After he did that I had to walk back to the car to get the debit card we forgot and when I made it back my husband told me how the guy said he had to “update the prices” and the price went up on all the cards. A $10 card went to $60. So we left and never came back. I will never give this place my money after what happened I’d much rather go on TCG player and get my cards because at least the site won’t try and scam me.

Went in for free comic book day only to see that Four Horsemen has monetized that as much as possible. They had a table set up that had $1 signs all around it with a mixture of trade paperbacks and single issues all from the last decade or so. In total I picked up 9 items for what I assumed would be a little over $9 only to be rung up for $44 and change! When I tried to explain to the cashier that I had gotten everything from the $1 table all he could say was that the paperbacks werent a dollar but he could see how that could be confusing... I wish Garys was still around, they atleast tried to treat their customers well.

Immaculate vibes. Theres so much nerdy stuff there that it makes me not feel like the self proclaimed nerd that I was. 10/10

My fiance and I decided to stop in on the way back to Martinsburg from Charleston. We have been collecting comic books for a couple of years now and we have to say that Four Horsemen hands down takes the trophy for organization, cleanliness and overall upkeep of their comics. Ive been to stores where Ive had to sift through boxes that had no organization at all.Four Horsemen provides a much different experience. Theyre honest in their conditions and pricings of the books, and their organization and storage is fantastic! The pull out cabinets provide an excellent experience searching through various runs and overall feels much more organized and clean.They also have amazing staff. We were helped by Sam who was extremely friendly. We were unsure of where to start in the store and after telling him that we had never been there, he explained the layout of the store and directed us where we were looking.Overall, very happy with the pulls I found and the pricing and staff. Will definitely be stopping again!

I saw on another reply they mentioned only older Pokémon being above MSRP… When did celebrations come out? I went into the store yesterday to see roughly 20 ultra premiums (MSRP 120) being sold for over 250$… and that was the preordered price! I would hate to see what the retail shopper, who just walked into the store, had to pay. That’s outrageous. The first week the 20$ lance charizard boxes were listed for 60$ and etbs 90$. I can’t believe how outlandish those prices are. Mini tins being 15$ too, the list goes on.

Awesome place well informed staff and a good place to go to just play cards with your friends

Fantastic service. I brought in a big trade close to close and T and Eric stayed late to make sure I was taken care of. Come here if you want treated right.

Huge store, massive inventory. Large gaming area with plenty of tables. Friendly staff, Jason, was very helpful. Found some good MTG cards.

Great stuff from collectibles to cards/rp boardgames and figurines to comic. A perfect place for a nerd like me.

Person behind the counter was extremely rude. After making the hour plus drive and asking about the price of an item in the case he told it would take a while to look it up. Then another person came in and they instantly looked up a price for them. The person behind the counter then acted very rude and said the cost was an outrageous amount, as well all the items in there store were above MSRP. *Edit* To the owners reply Im not sure why they told me it would take an hour to look up either. Also if you sell at MSRP or below then why was your Shinning Fates product or most other Pokemon product sold way above MSRP when they released?

Went to buy paint for my DnD mini but was clueless on paints. Jason came over and explained what paints he uses and which types are good for what, was super helpful with all my questions!

I dont know if it was an off day or what, as Ive not been totally ignored by staff in the past, but for some reason yesterday my acquaintance couldnt get the salesperson to acknowledge her—though her husband-to-be, who was with her at the time, didnt seem to have a problem.At least theyre being sensible and requiring masks.

Great comic book store. Ton of comics and games. They even have tables set up for playing those games if that is what you are into.

Good place with a solid selection. Sam was helpful all day. Definitely stop by when youre in the area

Overall pretty cool store. I’ve been there multiple times, but definitely had the best time at FCBD. Was helped by an associate who’s name was Tavares, but told me to call him T. He was really nice and really helpful!

We are just getting into Magic the Gathering and Our boi Jason really helped us out, feeling is how it all works and even getting us started with some decks. Even helped us with DnD and reservations for tables. Really great store and super helpful employees.

Best comic/game shop in the area. Lots of space, clean, good selection, great staff. Honestly, what more could you want!

Great selection, very family friendly and happy to answer questions. Thumbs up!

A great place to spend all of your stimulus checks. I know I did. #CardPunks

Awesome shop! Well kept, nice displays, and stock is A+ for Magic, board games, comics, supplies, etc. Have only had two visits but both were excellent. Great customer service is rare but one experience with who I assume was the owner has earned a customer for a long time.

Clean, friendly enough staff, pretty good selection.

Had a blast. Everyone was good people and had fun. Will do again

Jason was cool 😎 he was very nice to us.

Four Horseman is my favorite place to go when it comes to my trading cards needs! Their new location inside the mall offers them much more room and much more product to choose from.

Best place in Morgantown for all things fantasy and sci-fi. Huge number of comics and anything D&D you could need

Great store with great products! Jason was a huge help!

Nice place, lots of different things to choose from. Staff was helpful and friendly!

They had amazing cloth. Maybe the best I have ever seen and taisted. I can almost describe Mt experience as cultivating.

Always pleasant to be there usually people are pretty helpful and people respect your boundaries

Nice local business. They have a good selection of DnD books, dice, miniatures, and other accessories.

Staff seemed helpful and knowledgeable had a huge variety for what looked to be a little store.

Pretty sick place. Went there for a smash Bros tournament but when I was eliminated they had a game room with a lot of PCs available to play on. Really cool idea!

Great selection of graphic novels, comics, and tabletop games

5 star store filled with 5 star employees

This is the only local card shop in the area, and their selection for Pokemon (which is what I buy) is pretty decent. The main issue I have experienced is the prices. The prices at this store are extremely too high, especially when it comes to sealed products. A champions path ETB for 100$ (Costs 55$ and sells on TCG 80$ and eBay 70), booster packs for cosmic eclipse and vivid voltage being 8.50 and 7$, and base set sword and shield booster boxes for 200$. Since they get directly from a distributor, this means that they pay retail, go through no hassle of acquiring the product themselves and voluntarily hike up the price to well over scalper levels. Also, their trade in value system being massively underwhelming. They do 60% when trading in towards stuff in the store, but use market value on your item and listing price for their stuff which typically makes it about 20% more value on their end. Also, if the person before traded in 100$ worth of cards and got 40-60$ for it, how does it make sense that I would then have to trade in 165$ worth of cards for the 100$ card assuming that they actually give me 60% of the value??? Overall, I have found that buying and selling items from eBay or directly from TCG player has been much more worth my money, but will hopefully come into the store one day to see that their ways have slightly changed to benefit the local community.Response: I did come in recently and saw a full shelves of Pokemon packaged goods, I asked the worker if you guys were able to get some at Walmart or how did you get so much great products since I had been coming in on a weekly bases for a month now and never seen so much products. He responded You might have to get stuff from Walmart, but we get it straight from the source. which is implying to me that he meant a distributor. If this was the case, why are the 9 ETBs listed at 100$, 45$ over retail, and multiple build and battle decks being 10-20$ over TCG prices? Also, if I am trading in Pokemon cards to get Pokemon cards, lets assume the guy before me also got store credit for his 100$ card so it would be the most unfavorable profit margin for you guys, how does it make sense that I would then have to trade in 165$ towards that card? Thats 100$ profit on an initial 60$ investment. I understand that you have to make money, but that also means that the next guy would then have to trade in 275$ worth of cards to buy the 165$ worth of cards that I just traded in.I dont mean to sound hateful, but I just dont understand why I feel like every time when I come in the scale is heavily tilted towards the guys who claim to be helping the community and not in a way where both sides can benefit.

This is a fun little place at the dead end of the mall I love exploring! So much cool stuff to see!

Great selection of miniatures, lots of RPG and board games, collectables and a full line of citadel paint pots. Large gaming area in the back.

Everything a Star Wars and Marvel geek would ever want

Cool place, nice and friendly staff! Great selection of stuff!

Great looking store, friendly staff. However I came in looking for sports cards because this store pulls up when you search for them in Morgantown and unfortunately this is not something that is sold here. Not a big deal, but maybe something that could be brought in? There’s a huge market for it right now and Walmart/target have been wiped out every time I go in.

Very helpful, worked with me on product I desired, and general atmosphere was positive of the store

Fun crew. Great atmosphere even with limited capacity.

Pretty cool store. They are knowledgeable about what they sell which seems to be mainly card and table top games. They also hold dungeon and dragons games along with magic: the gathering games a couple times a week. So if you want to meet other cool people who are into table top gaming check this place out

Great selection of new and pre-owned comics! Good selection of Miniatures as well!

Absolutely the best comic book and card/board game store in the US

Very nice card store with a lot of space. They have an awesome collection of board games to play and purchase. Its in a real nice location in the mall, and the staff were friendly. Went there for a tournament and it was my second visit. I will be going back again!

Very nice and helpful.

They listen to customers and make reasonable changes as necessary. They allow people to play test select games before purchasing.Ample room to play games with no charge.Fair prices and great service.Ron and his family have worked hard to create a exceptional store that adds something to our community.

They put a date for an event on the Clarksburg page. No mention about Morgantown. Then I arrive at Clarksburg to find out they messed up. Called to see if I could arrive 10 mins late. Said I would get a round one loss. I took today off work to play modern. Very unhappy and disappointed with the four horsemen in Morgantown. I expected better.

Cool place but the price gouging is ridiculous. Charging double the retail and lining their pockets.

I have been a lot of comic book stores in my day. And for the most part they will say hi and leave you to your own devices. But at Four Horseman Comics they are genuinely interested in taking care of you comic needs. They are always super helpful and accommodating as well as curtious. They will get you whatever you are looking for. Great customer service.

Good store and staff, but not a great comic selection.

Nice establishment with good gaming space. Pretty excellent selection from board games to 40K. Decent selection of graphic novels. Helpful service. It was the kind of place youd expect to find in a downtown shop, but at a mall.

Lots of energy here. Just not a lot of yugioh stuff or support. But other than that they have great games and a lot of supplies. Worth visiting for sure!

Cool place, cool finds

One of my absolute favorite places in Morgantown. The atmosphere is friendly, there is a huge selection of games, cards, and miniatures for purchase, and Four Horsemen is a fantastic outlet for the tabletop gaming community in this area, with some sort of event being run almost every day. On top of that, the staff is phenomenal, and, for the most part, very knowledgeable. All in all, it is a fantastic place to go.

Super friendly and patient staff. They are very helpful to those of us just branching out into the comic world and the seasoned or obsessed fan. Their inventory is always changing and growing. Free comic book day is a great way to introduce people to the joys of comics. Their food and drink section is the cheapest in the mall. They have cosplayers that take the time to entertain mall patrons and kids. They are a family run, family friendly, and inviting store.

Being new to the area, thought I would look for a local place to pick up a few comics... nice selection of back issue comics, friendly staff that is willing to help, seem to really appreciate their customers. Will definitely be back.

Wanted to buy a miniatures base set. Their price is almost $20 higher than Miniature Market or Amazon. When I asked the associate about matching price or coming down on it at all, I was treated very rudely like I was in the wrong for asking. I want to support my local shop and I understand paying a little more for convenience but not $20 more.

Great if your a gamer, but not for the comic enthusiast. There is a huge selection if cards, dice, and the like. However, if you are looking for an awesome selection of comics and a staff that knows their comic stuff, this is not the place.

Friendly staff, good environment, and all your nerdy needs. Love visiting whenever Im at the mall its one of my friends and I #1 stops every time we are at the mall

Recently relocated close to Four Horsemen Comics and I was very pleased with the service and selection in this store. The staff is friendly and always willing to help and the selection of free comics on Free Comic Book day was very large. I will continue to shop there.

Amazing people and amazing staff, Ive been going up there since the store opened, Ron is an AMAZING guy, I hope they stick around for a LONG time

Very nice, helpful staff and owner. Come and immerse yourself in gaming, and comics! You wont regret it. They have everything you could ever want, or can order it in a hurry. Very knowledgeable and friendly, good prices and a lot of fun times!

Best tabletop and non video game store that you can go to in the Morgantown area. Great with pop culture and comic books as well unfortunately I dont do Comics that much but I have seen them work wonders

Everyone at the shop was really friendly and attentive throughout my entire experience. They have a great selection with tons of neat stuff to check out!

Four Horsemen comics in Morgantown West Virginia has an excellent selection of new comics, back issues, and vintage comics! The staff is fantastic and knowledgeable. The gaming sections are inviting and exciting (though I usually get lost in the vintage drawers and miss game time...thats my bad!)All the collectables, sculptures, graphic novels, Etc you would expect to find in a comic book store are here! What I love about it is, it has its own convenient place in Morgantown Mall.This was one of the easiest reviews Ive ever done! Five stars to Four Horsemen comics!

Awesome place. Staff is friendly and knowledgeable. Great place to shop, game or just hang out.

Absolutely love this store and the friendly and inviting atmosphere! I dont have one bad thing to say about such a wonderful establishment. I encourage all comic and gaming lovers out there to stop by because you wont be disappointed!

My sons favorite artist delivered a signed edition for his birthday.This place sold it instead! Their apathy said a lot about their integrity. Really awful experience for an 11 year old.I wont spend money here.

Nice staff great price and selection

Love this place, been going to them since they were just a little store tucked away off to the side that has gotten huge since. Always has friendly staff on hand, owner has always been pretty chill. It sure fits the bill for an FLGS (Friendly Local Game Store) in my book.

I personally love this place, the staff and all the other customers give off a very carefree and laid back vibe which us perfect for escaping the daily grind. In my opinion its a place for everyone, especially if you want to meet people and talk about all things nerd/geek culture.

Awesome place that has plenty to offer. Huge selection of board games, miniature games, and comic books just to name a few. Lots of tables to play said games, and a great community constantly hosting events of many different types.

Awesome place for comics and games! Staff is friendly and atmosphere is intoxicating. Everyone in here is friendly and willing to show you something cool. A real treat.

Amazing staff and a fantastic selection of almost anything you could ask for! And their D&D room is incredible!

Great place to go for comics or some board gaming. There is always something going on so swing by and try some games. For me its the featured attraction in the mall.

Id rate it two and a half stars if I could, as its just crushingly average. The merchandise selection is very, very shallow. If youre looking for anything even remotely niche as far as tabletop or comics goes, youre SOL. Atmosphere is also lacking. They have a number of nice decorations and scale models but on the whole the place just feels empty and uncomfortable. Its the best comic/gaming shop Ive been to in Morgantown, but thats rather sad.

Amazing local gaming and comic book store. Lots of space, well run events, and well organized.

One of the best places that I have ever been! Friendly staff and excellent care of the products make this an amazing place for beginners and collectors of comics and gaming supplies.I have enjoyed every time I have gone in there.

Over priced comics! Not much of a selection! Only good stuff is new comic releases. Other then that just not great!

Awesome place for tabletop gaming. Amazing people, great atmosphere, good prices.

Great store for TCGs, board games, and comics.

Four Horsemen is THE place in Morgantown for gaming and comics. Today, I took my son who is a budding, Pokemon TCG player in to pick up some card pages and inquire about events. The staff is always super helpful and genuinely love what they do. They talked to Spencer, showed him some of the cards they themselves pulled today in their own packs, told us about how they have packs cheaper than anyone in town, and told us about the weekly pokemon event they rin on Friday nights (7 pm).Definitely deserves your business. You wont be disappointed.

Awesome place for anyone just starting to get into a game (Magic: the gathering) or even a seasoned professional. Great staff and friendly atmosphere.

Helpful, caring, and active staff. Stocked shelves with tons of variety. Room to play games in the back.

Never had a bad experience, great place to look at hand picked games.

Ron is as awesome and helpful as ever. Keep up the good work!

Everyone is so friendly and nice. Great atmosphere to play MTG

A Place For Card Game Duels, Has An Arena Of Computers To Battle Eachother On Video Games, Has A Lot Of Old BoardGames, Holds An Event Every Friday Around 5 Or 6, But The Best Is DnD And Most Important. Ya Yeet.

Tons of comics to browse both new and old. Huge space and ever changing to accommodate more.

This is the best comic store in the Morgantown area. Lots of recent comics, board games, they even have war hammer tables. Theres always someone in the back playing Magic games. Not five stars because it isnt very well lit and the atmosphere could be improved some.

Ron is a top notch person, and creates a fun, friendly atmosphere. Ive been going there a while and now my son has started going with me too.

Went back again to see if anything has changed and it hasn’t I use tcg player for card prices and just this morning the cards I took in was worth 313.46 they offered me 132 in store credit and 87 cash and you pay 60 percent of card value now 60 percent of 300 in cash comes out to 180 and some change and store credit would be around 200 the man at the register dropped all my cards on the floor and I’m damn near certain he didn’t count in some of my cards including a 45.32 uro. I will be contacting bbb and a few others