The BEST Key Lime pie i ever had. We had the coconut key lime pie. I was just a little sad they dont ship pies. We wanted to ship some pie to my dad.The women who took my order was so nice, she told me the story how the store is now owed and operated by all the employees that work there. They have a great gift shop as well. This is a place you have to visit when in key west. You will not be disappointed.

The key lime pie is great. Believe me Ive made it a life long mission to try this amazing mix of flavors everywhere I can. Tart with a sweet crunchy crust. If they put key limes in it then this store sells it.

Really good and tart pie and icecream! Accompany with espresso.

Had a girls day trip down to the Keys and had to stop here for the best pie!! Adorable place inside and out. I tried the coconut keylime pie and original keylime. Both are to die for!! Couldnt have asked for anything better than to eat amazing pie with my best friend watching roosters cross the street 😍💚

You can take look through the entire kitchen as they bake and they also have a little souvenir collection for sale in the shop and the prices are exactly the same as in other souvenir shops close by. First time I had a lime pie and loved it! Nice little place!

We had a short stop at this bakery shop and we ended up buying key lime pie! It tasted really good, I love it! ❤️ I just forgot to buy key lime cookies!!! 😂 Next time, I won’t miss it!! 👍👍

They make the BEST PIES in ALL of Key West and if you have a chance to visit with one of the employees Ted, he’s the coolest! He gave us great tips on local spots. We can’t wait to come back for more before we head back home!

Cute little shop! Very bubbly environment! There was a lot of things other than key lime pie like Ice Cream and other more permanent things like pluses and toys. Great place for a family to go and have a nice bite to eat. I recommend it.

So far my favorite key lime pie. Limey and not so sweet. Nice location and cute souvenirs. Parking took some time to find.

Thank you Marcus! Great little store front. All the staff was great!!! Place was spotless and easy to move around. Only standing standing room to eat the yummy Key Lime pie, chocolate dipped pc and the ice cream. Yes we had all 3 before lunch. So darn good.

Key West Key Lime Pies was abousletly the best Ive ever had, however the staff has ZERO personality. No greeting, no talking, just someone with a foreign accent that you cant understand.Poor selection of Pies. I would have liked to have gotten a whole pie but not receiving anything but the silent treatment I chose to go to their completion.

The ongoing pandemic has definitely taken a toll on a lot of businesses and public places since a consumers mindset to buy anything outside of essentials or to visit a public place like a park or beach, has crippled down significantly. Now by living with what has become the new normal, it is commendable on how these businesses and public places continue to remain open and cater to the general public by following the safety standards. It is now all the more important that we as customers, support these heroes during these dark hours to mankind.Something unique with Key West is every business’ obsession in owning the tag line “World famous” followed by their product, like the young boy Russell from the movie Up who is so obsessed of getting his final merit badge. Key Lime Bakery is no exception to that and is one which is totally eligible to own the tag line “World famous Key lime Pie”.Hands down they make the best key lime Pie (apparently the ones who found the recipe). Do a Yelp Chekin to get $1 discount on a piece of Key lime pie. The staff were friendly and they had a variety of eatable and touristy items other than the pies too. The pie was so good that we returned for a second time before we left the Keys.If you are visiting Keys, you must definitely checkout this place.

I love their key lime pies! On Dec 31 I tried a traditional one and the one with more filling... Delicious! The staff is really friendly. The only problem I had was with a Sweet Petes Candy Dark Chocolate Key Lime Pie that had expired in August and was in a bad condition... I couldnt see the date because the price tag was covering it...

This place was cool..the guy at the desk was helpful and gave us some info. We had to try the original so ..we got a slice of the key lime and coconut key lime. Well the coconut was frozen so he did give us a different kind. It was ok but the original key lime was for sure the best. Im not a huge pie fan but when in rome you know the saying. I also had a Kellie soda and got some key lime products. For sure worth a visit...it set the bar high for all the other key lime pies Im going to wreck while Im here.

The mans and I are on the hunt for our favorite key lime pie in Key West.This place was on a listical so we obliged.We had three categories to rate and our scores are as follows:Sweetness: 5/10Tartness: 7/10Crust: 5/10This was my favorite, as I liked the amount of tartness it had. The other two pies we tried were much more sweet and less tart. Kermit’s was hubs’ favorite so far.

Key lime pies are tasty and it makes for a great resting spot while walking downtown.Seating (table and chairs) is limited.

Lady who sold me the pie was super nice! And the coconut cream pie is awesome!

Service was very sweet! There was a little line but not a long wait at all. The pie was of course, amazing!!!

Great little store for a tourist. Price is just ok for a tourist but a bit much for everyday customers. Original key lime pie is great.

Tried a regular slice of Key lime pie and a frozen chocolate covered slice. The regular slice was OK but the chocolate covered slice was amazing. There is no where to eat inside currently, so all orders are to go. They also take your temperature before allowing you inside.

Key lime pie by-the-slice is soooo good here! I also got some souvenirs and a couple of the rum soaked coconut cakes; staff was very friendly and helpful 😊

Needs 100 Stars! Are u kidding me???? The BEST Key Lime Pie EVER!

I got the extra tart key lime pie and I’m happy I did because it’s honestly my favorite I’ve had. The fresh whipped cream on top and the fact that it’s made fresh really makes if perfect. Staff was super efficient and friendly and I was glad to see them taking temperature checks and sanitation seriously.

Number 2 on my must try in the Florida Keys, Key Lime Pie, and its pretty good, not much different from other places Ive tried it up north... Cool little shop with lots of things Key Lime... Also, a pretty good hot sauces section...

No customer service support for orders placed for shipping. Cant even rate the pie since it has been almost two weeks now.Update... Three days later it shows up. No dry ice. Pie is deformed and warm. Delivered to the wrong address.This company sucks.

Best key lime pie and coffee in Key West. Locally owned and operated. Met the proprietors when we stopped in. Genuine great people, great customer service. In a time of utter devastation for so many owner/operators, they went the extra mile to take care of their customers. If you are in the area please stop in and show some love to these wonderful people.

This is one of the many food shops around town, this one claiming to be the original. I had their ice cream and it was really good!! The homemade key lime and the Cuban coffee are my favorite! They also sell some things that are kinda highly priced (they sell the same key lime things all over). Worth checking out!Plus, its an active place for the famous Key West Chickens!

I love this place. Delicious Key Lime Pie and coffee.

My wife and I visited from Maryland and they have the best key lime pie ever! Cashiers at the counter were super friendly and nice. I highly recommend them and we will definitely be back!

This bakery in the nightclub district of Key West specializes in key lime pie and related items. According to a sign on the front of the door, this bakery was the first key lime pie bakery.

Lots of key lime products. Still wish the pie flavor was more intense/tart but I like stronger key lime so that is just me. It is good. Stop by every time in Key West for pie.

This update is from August 07. I used to said this was the best place to eat the key lime pie and I left my first review at the end. Unfortunately this time the pie was not fresh and it was totally frozen. I am so disappointed :-(. Now is like any other place that sells Key lime pie in the keys :-(——-This is my old review :-(This is the best Key Lime Pie that I have tried in my life!! You must try if you are visiting Key West!! Creamy, tasty, so delicious!! I can’t wait to go again and get some more!

The key lime pie was absolutely delicious! Tons of flavor. Best key lime pie Ive ever had.

Always been a fan of key lime pie. Ive heard the adage that It aint a key lime pie unless its from the Keys.Well, I finally got my first chance to put that to the test and, let me tell you, this pie almost made me cry it was so good. Hands down the best Ive ever had. I had one slice, went about my day, and decided to go back for a whole pie to take home. The employee at the counter noticed my military ID in my wallet and gave me a discount without me asking for one.

This is the absolute splendidly superb key lime pie heaven. All the heavenly best key lime pies come from here😋

Checked web site and seen they were open until 11. Good, drive to Mallory square fighting traffic and drunk pedestrians. Pay to park a city lot and walk to bakery. We got there at 9:04 only to be told by worker she was closing.No problem we bought 3 pies at your competitor on Front St.

Be aware of your charges. Walked out with water energy drinks, pie on a stick and a pound cake was charged 300. Owner came through after a couple of days and refunded the difference. Thank you for doing that. I know your busy, I would suggest having someone manage your phone line for improved customer service.

If you like Key Lime Pie this is a must try establishment. The staff were friendly and informative. The pie is very rich and not overpowered with key lime flavor. If you prefer less crust to filling try the Key Lime Cup. The Key Lime Milkshake was my favorite...refreshing, light and cool. Enjoy!

Born and Raised in Homestead just before Key Largo, so had to get my key lime pie on a stick dipped in chocolate. Also fun fact watched this episode, so had to go see the changes. Loved loved loved what yall did. Good Luck on your new partner ship and moving up.Hubby retired Navy so I had to show him my old stomping grounds of skipping school as a Sr.

Love this place got the best pie and coffee and all the staff and owner was was so friendly!! Left with the cutest souvenirs for my fam 😍

Not the best Key Lime pie in KW (my vote goes to Blue Heaven), but a d@mn good effort!

We had such a wonderful experience! We got to watch the ladies make chocolate dipped key lime treats while we enjoyed our DELICIOUS pie and coffee! I had the extra tart key lime pie! and my husband and toddler had the chocolate dipped key lime pie! The staff and place is so cheerful and happy! We loved it!! Highly recommend!

Ordered a pie to be delivered to my mother on 8/4/21. As of 8/12 nothing has shipped, emails arent answered and no one is answering the phone. If youre closed please let me know.Edit 8/16/21: After leaving the review and disputing the charge with PayPal the cake was suddenly shipped and arrived within 48 hours. There was a smaller cake included with a note apologizing for the delay. Still no email/phone contact. Upd the review from 1 star to 3 stars for finally delivering the cake.

Key lime pie was really good but it could be better. Nice place to have some coffee and a dessert

Love this place. You can get in and out quickly or take some time and enjoy your piece of the pie. Surely among the best in the area. If you want a nice little space for privacy, look left when you walk in. Really good in the rain.

A very cute atmosphere with good pie! Loved that they offered a coconut key lime pie, which is something that none of the other shops in the area offer. We tried the classic key lime pie and the key lime cheesecake. The pie was very good, but not my favorite that I’ve tried in Key West. The cheesecake was okay. It just didn’t have the strong key lime flavor that I look for in key lime desserts. I probably wouldn’t get it again, but you may like it, so it is worth a try! Once again, the staff was very friendly and I would stop in again!

I wanted to try it after I watched the show on the profit!I loved the pie dipped in chocolate but not the regular pie!Staff are very friendly!

Along with regular key lime pie they offer gluten free key lime pie and gf freshly dipped chocolate covered key lime pie on a stick. The staff was nice and knowledgeable about gluten free. She did give me a heads up if you dont eat the gluten free pie it will start to melt in about 10 minutes. I ate the chocolate covered one right away and the slice the next day. It was good, but I liked the taste and balance of Kermits better. It is good though and great to have gf options to compare. My husband who is not gluten free also said it was good, but preferred Kermits.

Staff was very friendly and helpful.

Friendly staff. Great pie. What more do you need?

We arrived when the store was almost closing and the employee still let us order but she asked us to not dine in, which we understood. Since the Coconut Factory is the adjoining store, we selected some souvenirs for family and friends to purchase. The lady started yelling at me and my kids that she just mopped and why were we stepping on her floor. We decided to leave without buying any thing. Not the way to treat customers. It’s a shame this employee was not helping the store generate business and goodwill, but more concerned about closing up shop at the strike of the hour. I took my business across the street and purchased dessert for our group of 13 people.

Great real keylime pie made and sliced to order would recommend to go try

Horrible pie! Extremely sweet and left a metallic taste in my mouth.That place cannot be the authentic one...no way!

Was absolutely awesome had been wanting to go there ever since. I saw it on MSNBC and the show The Profit. Staff was friendly and super nice.....love the decor and of course the best key lime pie I have ever had!!

They have slices and pies of gluten free pie and it’s incredible! Service was really good here too.

We had a plan to stay here for breakfast but the place is closed to dine-in, working for to go and for pic-up only.We ordered piece of traditional key lime pice of pie and cup of latte. They were not have milk for latte. Ok, we just took slice of pie for to go.But taste of pie was not so good and not fresh - it was frozen, we saw some ice on pie, and on taste it was soooo bitter.So, not my piece of cake.

Dont bother. This was the worst Key Lime Pie I have ever had. We decided to have a slice each day to taste the variety. We got the original Key Lime Pie here and it was so tart and overpowering, it tasted artificial. It was so strong that it burned my throat and made me cough. There has to be better Key Lime Pie in Key West. I would tell my friends to skip this place. Would not recommend. Go to Bagatelle and have yourself a slice of delicious pie.

Wow I do feel that they have the best key lime pie I’ve ever had, not just in key west. It’s not to heavy or dense and just the right amount of tartness. They even have an option if you like your key lime pie more tart. Great place!

The staff was friendly, yet very, very slow in service. The pie flavoring and menu were selections were great. The prices were decent. The store location is convenient, though local parking can be tough. The store environment was clean, open, and inviting. Wed come back.

If you head to the Keys, you better have Key Lime Pie. We stopped here for a slice (well, actually 2 slices...one traditional, the other dipped in chocolate). Great ambiance. Amazing flavor. Perhaps a little on the pricey side. But you have to try Key Lime Pie. You wont regret it!

I bought a whole key lime pie in this shop thinking it’s the best pie in Key West. I was very excited and told my daughter I bought it from the Key Lime Pie Bakery who claims to make the original Key Lime Pie recipe from Key West.But as soon as we cut and tasted that key lime pie, it was the worst key lime pie! I do not recommend it! It’s very tart and the crust tasted old and soggy. I have tasted key lime pies from Mrs. Mac’s Kitchen, Sloppy Joe’s and from another restaurant by Islamorada, they were all excellent that we wanted for more. So, I was very disappointed about the key lime pie I bought in this Key Lime Pie Bakery. Save your money and have a piece of key lime pie from the restaurants. Theirs taste a lot better! And as a baker myself, I truly say “NOT RECOMMENDED”

The pie was ok. Tasted more like cheese cake. Didnt have a lime taste, but was still tasty.

Awesome Key Lime Pie. I loved it. There were also Key Lime Pie ice creams which were really good. The store is really nice with good music. Xavier was super helpful and nice!!!

Anyone visiting Key West should not miss this pie!It’s amazing! Just right not too sweet not too tart just perfect! Once I started eating I couldn’t put it down and before i know it, I ate half of the pie 😬!!

Cool shop, great key lime pie! Lots of other key lime flavored things available from candy to honey to salsa. Definitely a place youll want to check out when in Key West.

Though a bit expensive you absolutely have to try slice of this cake!Made with a crunchy graham cracker crust it is the best key lime pie you ll ever taste!And there s nothing like eating it in Key West

Great pies excellent service from the nice lady

6.5 for the key lime pie not the best one in key west and management is very nice.

Im not a big pie connoisseur but both my wife and I found it to be inedible tonite. It literally tasted like tin. Oh well. Maybe they just had a bad batch.

This place is amazing omg the pie is made with love and is soooo good I came all the way from Louisiana to get some

Tasty key lime pie on a hot day. Nothing like it

Amazing key lime pie, and a great selection of really great tasting hot sauces as well.

Delicious key lime pie and friendly service

Key lime pie on stick is so good and so is there Ruben iced coffee.

Absolutley amazing. They definitely own the right to brag. 😁🍈👊❤👏👏Kudos to them!!

Best key lime youll ever taste. Not too sweet, not too sour. Pairs perfectly with some coffee and/or ice cream. But an entire pie for the most bang for your buck!

Absolutely the best coconut pie Ive ever eaten, my husband loved the key lime pie and my son loved the key lime cheesecake! This place is a must!

We took a pie making class & had a GREAT experience!! Fun, informative & lots of samples. Highly recommend the Blood Orange & Strawberry variations! Well be back next time were in Key West

We tried both this and Kermit’s (which are both supposed to have some of the best key lime pies in the area), and found this place to have the tastiest one I have had anywhere. NOTE: We like the tangy zestiness of key lime pie, so we ordered the “extra tart” version and it did not disappoint!Only docking one star because it’s somewhat expensive (but that seems to be the case everywhere.)

Outstanding pies, for a place featured on CNBC and the Food Channel, Id say the pie lives up to the hype.

Yep, this is the best Key Lime Pie in Key West. We tried 3 different prominent places around town today and this places pie was the most flavorful and about makes your cheeks pucker! Its a step above the competition!

We got original key lime pie (7/10 score, good but could be better) and key lime cheesecake (1/10, not good and don’t recommend). The shop is very cute and had other small items/gifts available. They were making fresh cakes when we came in.

I really hate that we had a bad experience here because I am a huge Marcus Lemonis fan! We walked into the store and there was no one in it except for 2 employees who were not friendly. They didn’t greet us, even when I was beaming with excitement. There was no music playing. I ordered fudge off the menu and the employee responded that they didn’t have fudge... I tried asking questions about what to order and she couldn’t answer those either. There was no soap in the restroom, although once I pointed that out, the other employee promptly refilled it. It just wasn’t what I expected at all and it wasn’t worth the drive to that key lime pie place when there are so many in the Keys with better service.

I choose the key lime cheesecake. It was delicious!! You buy a slice or whole cheesecake or pie.

I personally think this pie is the best in town. Tart and creamy, with a thin crumb crust. The whipped cream was the creamiest compared to dozen others I had. The filling texture is almost ice cream like. Must try!

Absolutley horrible! I bought a whole key lime pie on 4/10/21, the lady working there suggested I take a frozen one since we were driving back to marathon. We tried eating it once it was thawed and all 4 of us threw ours away after one bite! It tasted like rotted eggs! Ive tried a lot of key lime pies, and never had a bad one until now. I was honestly afraid we would get sick. Im wondering if they may have froze old pies to keep them from going bad. They waited too long on this one. What a waste of money!

This is a slice of paradise...the hundred year old recipe is beyond dreamy ... It is a shame the whole pie wont make it home...this is worth the trip but itself...highly recommend ...

The pie was incredible! The crust was amazing! Definitely worth the walk even in 90% humidity! Now we know why it was featured on The Food Network!

Yummy, unique twist on key lime flavors! Can get a key lime float with ice cream of choice or key lime pie ice cream. Also, gift shop full of cute souvenirs!

Hands down the best Key Lime Pie!!! You have to come to this place! Plus you can see pies made right in front of you!

Great pie and coffee and Ted took care of us

A little pricey but what isnt here. Very good!

Delicious tasty pie and espresso too. ( The best cake in the world Ive ever eaten. ) I recommend 100% :)

The BEST Key Lime pie in Key West, Fl.Very fresh and tart. Tasty. Highly recommend.

Great pie. Super friendly lady working.

Pie was good, not the best on the island.

Hands down the best Key Lime Pie Ive ever tasted! I was happy to cross it off my The Profit bucket list!

Definitely top 5 Key Lime pie slices I had down there. I wish I tried the extra tart! Their homemade whip cream is to die for! The texture of the key lime pie was excellent

Hands down my favorite key lime pie! I personally LOVE the original...husband LOVES the coconut key lime - you cant go wrong, theyre all delicious!

Will have to say it has the best key lime pie, I have eaten in the Florida Keys by far. Sampled over 20 pies in the last couple of years and half were nothing more than a frozen/melted GFS mess on a plate. The rest, I have no clue what recipe they used, or even if they had key limes in them.It is well worth a stop in, to grab a slice for $5.35 with the governors taking his slice of the pie for 36 cents or grab a whole pie for 22 dollars and governor does take a cut of your key lime pie.