Fast talkers. I did a deal with them about two items. We both came to an agreement. Face to face. I made extra sure that both items were not together. Each item was $15 a piece. We both agreed. How do I remember that is because I tried to negotiate one of the items for $5 more. Which didnt happen. So the agreed price was $15 a piece. How do I know that. Because I made sure that we were on the same page. So when the worker went to get the money. He came back with only $15. I asked about the other one. He said they were sold together. And if I didnt want it. Then my items would be return me. So I took the deal because I didnt have any fuel to get to Pocatello. I personally wouldnt recommend selling anything to them. Even if you where on the same level he would have did the exact same thing.

I purchased several plastic coin slips (page style). After using several, I noticed they were used. I let the clerk know - and he said - most people dont notice. I noticed. Also, they do not accept a debit card for payment, but will gladly charge you use their ATM machine, right inside the store itself. They lost any future business with me.

Great card shop with tons of product to choose from. I find there affordable boxes and singles for my boys and Ive had cool hits buying basketball hobby boxes! Recommend that shop to everyone! Stuff is friendly and knowledgeable there!

Honest and professional coin dealer. We went to Pocatello pawn shop to estimate my grandpa collection. They would give us about $4,500, then we went to Silver Slugger shop and the guy paid us $6,500 for the same collection. Im glad weve found that shop!

Fair card prices. Worth going back to shop some more. As for selling your cards to them, it wasnt the best experience Ive had. I feel there are better places to sell/trade your cards. Not sure they really wanted to deal. The price offered for the collection wasnt worth a discussion. I know they are entitled to offer whatever they want, but Ive done better with same cards at other places.

Very helpful staff! Great selection of football hobby boxes, I like to go through singles in their value boxes as well!

So happy to finally find the sold out Pokémon boxes. It’s all my son wanted for his birthday. I searched high and low in every retail store and they were sold out. Prices online were nearly triple and I didn’t want to wait for shipping. Thank you Joe for getting these boxes in! And thank you for whoever brought them in to sell to Silver Sluggers! You saved my sons birthday! Will shop here again! Coming back for card binders next.

I think hes O.K. with his silver prices. He definitely beats the crooks at infinity coins. I just cant stand the kid he has working for him picking up the coins bare fingers and all. If your going to sell world coins glove up and dont tarnish the silver please.

Great shop. Most of the card prices are fair. Nice selection of old and somewhat rare coins and cards. Make sure you have cash though, or you have to use their ATM with a fee. The guys that work there know their stuff.

Wish i could give zero stars they are fully taking advantage of the card craz as soon as the market drops so will there shopcause they did it all the wrong way only saw dollar signs and not people no card show should be scalping don’t support it they will run out of money the owner looks like he spends his money on plugs for his hair those are not cheap lol

I buy a lot from joe! His cards are in good condition. Card prices are fair. And helps every time you need help. Honest person!

Sorry but selling a box of shinning fate for 125 when everywhere on facebook market place and ebay has it for less than 100 on average free shipping is really just sad from a shop. Who ever bought them could of done better elsewhere.... dont support scalpers !

Ive been a customer for quite sometime. Today i went in and he had an item i was interested in he had it priced at 125$ i found that same exact sealed item for sell from several other sources online for 105$ i tried to show joe. He told me straight up to buy from ebay then. Super rude not even willing to negotiate.The item was pokemon shinning fates elite trainer box which is brand new and retails for 50$. (Yes i was will to buy from a scalper but not anymore.... he seemed legit mad over me offering 100$ for a sealed box he bought for 50$ last week)THIS MAKES JOE AND SILVERSLUGGERS A SCALPER SHOP.(Do your homework before buying sports cards... ebay buy it now prices with free shipping are cheaper.). Dont believe me just look it up...and compare for your self.

Great hobby shop and awesome with coins and metals as well. I have been in multiple times, customer service is excellent! Joe is super helpful and treats his customers with respect. Thanks for running a first class business!!

Pokémon is way over priced $125 for a $50 dollar box you can get at Walmart. When over to gameopolis and got that same box for $80

My mom recommend me this place and Im glad I listened will be back

Joe is one the most honest and patient guys you could ask for when looking for something to purchase or asking questions. He always gives his input and suggestions to what you are looking for. I wouldn’t go to any other shop. Plus he is local. Can’t be that!

Wonderful shop, great Pokemon card selection, best prices in town!!

Cool place

Fantastic place! Very organized and great deals like the vending machine with 3-5 cards (optic/glossed) for 50 cent, as well as 25 cent cards you can pick from. Has a very wide selection of inserts, jersey cards, and singed cards of all-star level players. Had some remarkable stuff. I will definitely be coming here again.

Joe is the most honest businessman in the field I know. His store is a treasure trove for card collectors. Highly recommend hobbyists endorse and support this local business.

Only place in town that has Penney sleeves and top loaders that are fairly priced has all sports in cards..Only place in town that has hobby boxes at fair prices

A friend recommended Silver Slugger Coins to me. Now its the only coin shop in town that i will go to! Great customer service and even better prices. By far the lowest price on silver rounds in town. Thanks Derek for the recommendation!

Best coin and card shop around. They are always getting new sports cards products in from Panini and Topps. I love the Quarter boxes and the $1 auto and Jersey card boxes. My kids always have a great time at this store. The owner is always very friendly and helpful with me and my kids! Highly Recommended!

So glad I found Silver Slugger, I went to the other shops in town for years. Silver Sluggers price on silver and gold bullion is so much lower than the other shops in town. Great customer service and very friendly and knowledgeable. Thanks you have gained a customer for life. Cheers

Was looking for some 2017 baseball cards and found through searching on line that silver slugger had a case of what i was looking for. i called them up directly from NEW JERSEY and i spoke to joe kunz on the phone and he was just the nicest guy...he helped me by working with me on the price and then i was worried about an entire case being shipped from idaho all the way to new jersey so he insured it for me and made sure to package it really well! the case got here two days ahead of schedule and was in perfect condition. i just cant say enough nice things about this store and the fact that they were so nice dealing with someone they had never spoken to from across the country. if i lived in idaho id be at that store every day of the week so if you live near there or even an hour away, id be going there! i bought this case to help me relax with all the covid stuff going on in new jersey and it worked like a charm...im only half way through the case and i already pulled a mickey mantle superfractor numbered 1/1 and ANOTHER auto also #d 1/1....thanks joe! - nick lombardi( i dont have a google account so im using my girlfriends lol) stay safe everyone

I went there first time to check their prices. Very fair, easy to deal and talk to a guy who works there. Shall be back.

Was there today and even with the restrictions they were open. They had limited availability but was able to get what I wanted, fair prices and good service, I will be back to buy

Great place and honest. Brought in some coins to be appraised and the guy was very considerate and friendly.

If you’re looking to invest in silver this shop is perfect, they have the best prices! Under $1 over spot! I won’t purchase silver anywhere else but here 👍👍Also to those who are accusing him of selling you fake silver, he has a PM verifier literally right behind the counter. So if he did sell you “fake” silver.. kinda your fault for walking out of the shop without verifying your purchase. I highly doubt he would risk his business by selling counterfeit silver. Mistakes happen people.. always test your silver before you leave a coin shop.

Love going to Silver Slugger. Best prices that I have seen in all of Idaho Falls for silver and gold! Very friendly and knowledgeable.

Huge selection of wax. Best prices on new boxes of cards that I have found!

Ive been to this store many times and every time was super pleasant and gratifying experience for me and my family!) They are always very friendly and honest,and the kids are welcome ( as long as you dont let them do whatever they want and respect the place! ;)))

The people are really friendly and they have a huge selection of coins. They also have amazing deals on there cards I think that this is the best card shop ever!!! They are very organized and clean.

Have been dealing with Silver Slugger Coins & Cards for years. Always very polite, friendly, helpful and trustworthy. Great place to buy silver coins. No reason to go anywhere else. A++!

Very poor customer service skills. Incapable of answering simple questions without losing temper. Very disappointed with this establishment.

I was excited to see a coin and card shop open in town. There is nowhere else to buy cards and its nice to see what other coin shops have. Unfortunately they are FREAKING CROOKS! They sold me a fake coin, then when I confronted him, he conveniently had a real replacement in the back and put the first one back in the case. I have asked around and heard the same story from others. They dont know coins at all! Never go here!!

I went in with a box of coins and he acted like I wasting his time. He wouldnt even look at them then moved on to another person.

It was cool shop but when I got Pokemon cards out of the vending machine some of them were really damaged and some of them were fake. But they were at a good price and the rest of the shop is cool!

I have been buying coins and cards for my collection here for 3 years. Best prices in Idaho! No need to look any further

I personally love this place for getting Pokemon & yugioh cards. There prices are cheap and your can order cards from any expansion. They are the best cards place ive ever been to.

I love their store, very friendly, knowledgeable and the best prices!

Has coins

Poor attitude and will sell you counterfeit coins -- avoid. not honest

Great place very friendly.

Horrible experience. I was treated as if I wasn’t good enough to be in the store. Will never go back.

Neat store, but felt rushed and like I was a hassle. Prices are a bit high but much better than Infinity Coin. That place is comically overpriced.