Went here for the 1st time the other day, and what a cute little candy shop! Reminds me a lot of a candy shop I went to in my childhood, so very nostalgic. They have every type of candy you could really think of along with different specialty beverages and unique items; the worlds hottest gummy bear, chocolate cookie dough bites, mini packs of unique Mike and Ike flavors to a large bag of all Marshmellows from Lucky Charm Cereal. No complaints and shop worker/owner? was very kind! The price on some of the handmade bag candy is a bit pricey but thats it.

I love their selection of imported candy from the UK. I go here if I want the authentic Cadbury chocolate.

Amazing store! There is so much to choose from: novelty gimmicky candy, a wide selection cotton candy flavors, and vintage finds from my childhood. Nice selection of premium rice crispy bars. Will likely return many times specifically to purchase chocolate bars from Ireland/UK. A secret candy lovers dreamland!

Friendly and inviting atmosphere. A wide selection of goods. Me and my wife thoroughly enjoy ourselves at each visit.

Jay, the owner, is a wealth of knowledge! They had candy from other countries as well as candy from the 60s on up. Wonderful store!!

Fantastic selection of products you cant find anywhere near Ohio. The owner is super cool too

I love this place. Huge selection of candy and sodas and very reasonable prices. The staff is very nice as well

Whatever candy you are looking for, you will find! Also, some other things you didnt know you wanted that will become your favorites!!

Loved this store...a candy wonderland! Jay, the owner is incredibly friendly and offered great suggestions. A great small business to support...I highly suggest checking it out!

What a great shop. Will definitely go back and certainly recommend.

The store was NOT wheelchair friendly at all, even after calling. The staff was just about as friendly as a dead bird and everything was so hot the chocolate was melting. She was cold thats why. I would sooner chop off my other leg than go here ever again

Jay was amazing! Definitely will be a returning customer! Also, will be telling my friends and family about Buckeye Candy Company also!

Girlfriend spent over $50 on candy, came home to find the GooGoo clusters and sushi candy were expired, with the clusters being visibly moldy. Everything else seemed ok, nice looking shop.

Little place with a very friendly owner. Selection of British chocolate - awesome! Cotton candy and throw back candies are super cool too.

Good selection of British goodies. Well be back.

Great selection of candy - some you have never seen before and others from your childhood. The owner was very nice and knowledgeable. I liked the international section as well.

Great service, AMAZING selection! This is the only candy shop we go to. Its a problem for my waist.

I found a lot of candy that I havent seen since my childhood. It wont hurt to take a look around.

Excellent service and the best selection. Check out all their flavors of cotton candy and jumbo rice krispies. I came to buy some candy as gifts and the gentleman working went above and beyond! Support local businesses and shop here!!

Such a great store! Huge selection of candy! The owner was very friendly and knowledgeable. Our favorite was the international section. Can’t wait to go back!

They have so much candy, old school, new school, international, real milk chocolate, we will be a frequent shopper.

Amazing I would use to never go to any candy shops but now that this is here I go here almost every weekend

Cute little locally-owned shop. Has all the candies you can think of

Love getting candy from my childhood at great prices.

Great place with a good variety of candy. Nice place to stop by after a date in Gahanna.

So many different types of wonderful candies! Plus the owner was a delight to chat with. I would of gave 5 stars except the prices were a little high but I loved everything else!

One of Central Ohios hidden gems. Its a happy place for customers of every age ... with candies for every taste bud, old school favorites and even weird things like bug lollipops. Fun selection of Harry Potter themed treats. Great service. LOVE this place!

Very friendly! Loved the store!

Amazing selection of goodies new and old! The owner is always cheerful and willing to help- even puts together gift baskets! Hidden gem here in Gahanna.

A hidden gem in Gahanna! Brought lots of nostalgia and I found treats for me and gifts

What an awesome candy shop. A little but of everything and friendly service.

Love this shop - Im so glad to have another locally owned business in town. The owner is so friendly, and has an awesome stock of candy from when we were kids and often new items. We will continue to be repeat shoppers!

The staff is super helpful and the selection of candy is outstanding! If youre looking for a unique gift, this is the place to go!

Great selection. Awesome little mom and pop store.

Awesome selection and reasonable prices- particularly the bulk candy section! The owner is friendly and knowledgeable.

Love this place.

Lots of goodies from my childhood. Wacky Wafers, tart n tiny, Zots and more.

They had a lot of retro candy, and candy from other countries, bit messy though.

Supppeerrr yummyyy