user
Pickers Paradise
1750 25th St, Columbus, IN 47201, United States
Appearance
Pickers Paradise
Comments
Me
Review №1

Never the same place twice. This has to be one of the must stop places especially those traveling i74 easy on off exit. Cutest Lil town with one of the most unique antique store. Such a variety of old to up cycled pieces. Recently downstairs was renovated and has many more booths filled with treasures. Several amazing restaurants on the same block if your hungry. Coffee shop too. Sunday’s are quite in this lil town but pickers is currently open 7 days a week.

Do
Review №2

Clean, nice, well organized. Not exactly what I think of when I think of a Pickers Paradise, lol. Pricing is on the higher side for a lot of the booths. Definitely some good finds here though. Good mix of products.

Bi
Review №3

Great selection of a wide variety of things. Friendly staff, and helpful

Pa
Review №4

Nice place, neat and clean.Lots of Painted furniture.Would like to see more antiques not painted.But always find something.Lady at register was super nice!Of course I will go back.

Za
Review №5

Outstanding BBQ and great prices. First time eating here and I will be back regularly. I just moved here from Texas and I feel like I was right at home. Their special today was brisket tacos and they were amazing. Brisket had lots of flavor and melted in your mouth and they topped the tacos with cheese, sour cream sauce, and lettuce. I added some of their blackberry bourbon BBQ sauce for extra flare and cleaned my plate. The cole slaw was a mix of vinegar and creamy style. The dining area was super clean and well designed and lighted. Only downside is they have limited hours, but if thats what it takes to get this quality, Ill gladly plan around it!!

Cl
Review №6

Always loved Pickers..very nice store

Je
Review №7

There were a lot of cute items but many of them were overpriced in my opinion. There were a lot of booths with a variety of styles and products to choose from!

Ba
Review №8

This was a fun place to look around and find some unique things, and inspire ideas, place was clean and tidy, well organized. I will enjoy future visits here.

Lo
Review №9

Friendly environment and if you allow yourself is does feel like your picking lol thanks for the good time

Le
Review №10

Great place. You never know what youll find!

Mi
Review №11

Nice variety. Lots of farmhouse. Reasonable prices. Was a win for us. Would recommend!!

Ma
Review №12

Clean, organized, prices okay, i always find things I like. Dont always feel appreciated as a customer like I did at the old location.

An
Review №13

Great selections and reasonably priced items!

Da
Review №14

We shop here a lot and we love it.

Ja
Review №15

Cool place to just walk around and look at stuff....

Ma
Review №16

I love looking hereI always find something special.

Wa
Review №17

There are some really nice booths

Ca
Review №18

Loved looking at everything

Rh
Review №19

Horrible. Way over priced.

ri
Review №20

Neat finds, but often things are presented as antiques, but really arent.

An
Review №21

I like the guided path to ensure I didnt miss anything. I dropped it to a 4 because I think most of the vendors overprice their items. I will revisit the ones with reasonable prices for sure.

Ki
Review №22

It was very clean but also pricey

Ri
Review №23

Needs more antiques not made in China stuff

Ta
Review №24

A lot of good things there.

DE
Review №25

Love the variety...... Always can find something good.. 💗

Ch
Review №26

Lots of great stuff

Mi
Review №27

Very friendly staff

Je
Review №28

Good prices, great variety, friendly staff, they sell upcycled goods as well as antiques & resale items.

Br
Review №29

Nice place

B
Review №30

Great place. Tons of booths to look thru and a wide variety. I could spend over an hour in here easily

Ki
Review №31

I bought a mason jar candle with a handle. The candle burned for approximately 30 mins. These are large candles with hours of burn time. As I looked closer, there were three toothpicks stuck in it. 🤷🤷 I went back for a refund and I was told no. Not going back!!!!!

Ar
Review №32

Its ok

Sh
Review №33

Nice Store!Large variety of items to choose from for anything you may need for your home. Lots of different vendors. Quality items for sale.

Ch
Review №34

This store has a variety of new, old, and antique things. Its a treasure hunt and I absolutely love it. Its one of my favorite stores

Mi
Review №35

Nice place! I really liked it. Lots to look at! Prices were very reasonable!

Da
Review №36

Small place. Store was very neat, but really not a lot of REAL antiques. Not really a paradise for pickers. If you like new stuff painted to look old, or old-looking knick-knacks then this place is for you.

Do
Review №37

Well look here, blast from the past!

Da
Review №38

So many different things, and very clean!

Ja
Review №39

We go here alot great place

Li
Review №40

Super interesting place. They have some great things!

Je
Review №41

Very interesting and unique items. Last time we were here, had different items and this time it had changed. Which I think is good, they change out items.

Mo
Review №42

Amazing place! One of my favorite antique stores!

Be
Review №43

Great place with many different items at decent pricing

SA
Review №44

They had what I wanted plus some great place to explore

Pa
Review №45

The new location is very nice. The booths are displayed nicely, clean and organized.

Pa
Review №46

Very cool place

Ti
Review №47

Love the items that are sold here.. I always find neat items.

Pa
Review №48

This is my very favorite place to shop! The merchandise is very good quality and the prices are lower than Ive seen anywhere else.

Li
Review №49

If you dont know what youre looking for just come here and Im sure you will find something youll want.

St
Review №50

Wasnt too spectacular on my last visit, but I checked this place out once a month. The knick knacks they have are the same as anywhere else, but the furniture they have in this place is fantastic.

Pa
Review №51

One of my favorite stores with individual booths

Ma
Review №52

They were supposed to open at 10. Showed up at 10:10. Said they would be a bit. Finally opened at 10:20. No apology or anything. We needed something in there and was on a schedule based on their listed opting time. Highly unprofessional.

My
Review №53

Love this place. Always great finds, huge selection with great prices

Lo
Review №54

Pretty good inventory, could use some better workers, staff seemed less than enthused to be there.

sh
Review №55

It was great Im going back soon!

Mi
Review №56

More like art craft store than antique

Me
Review №57

Love. They have something for about everyone

Tr
Review №58

As a daily flea market, there really are no bad ones because even a single vendor could have exactly what you have been searching for. I tend to rate them on size. This one is a small one and for that reason, I wouldnt consider it a destination flea market, but it should definitely be includes in the flea marketing rounds of local folks.

Ni
Review №59

Amazing place to find unique and affordable furniture, home decor, and everything in between!!

Ke
Review №60

It was great!! Lots of items to look at, and i found what i was needing!

Pe
Review №61

I searched for antiques and found Pickers Paradise. Terrible! A store full of stuffed animals, knick knacks, baskets (not old), and lots of miscellaneous crap! Only very few antiques. Do not waste your time.

An
Review №62

Best thrift store in town! Prices are usually pretty reasonable and always something new youll find.

Me
Review №63

I found some great Christmas presents for Dad and Mom!

Ja
Review №64

Much better when it was really a pickers paradise with some antiques and good deals. If I want stuff from Hobby Lobby Ill just go there first.

Li
Review №65

Love this place ! Antiques galore !

Tr
Review №66

A great little store

Ka
Review №67

Love catching deals and seeing some cool antiques!

Er
Review №68

Find the perfect thing you never knew you needed

vi
Review №69

Cleanest flea mkt Ive been too. Wish we had it here!

Mi
Review №70

Nice well laid out, clean, craft and antique items

De
Review №71

Something for everyone, great prices, friendly people.

Gr
Review №72

Always my favorite place to go thrifting for antiques

De
Review №73

Too expensive for me. I prefer lower priced fleamarkets.

Re
Review №74

Love it! I never know what I will find here.

Wa
Review №75

Really nice store with a lot of good finds.

la
Review №76

Nice shop. Has a variety of items.

Ja
Review №77

Nice place it was a little over crowded not easy to walk the isle

Ja
Review №78

Great place to find old stuff and collectables....

Re
Review №79

A few cute things

ac
Review №80

A neat place to shop.

Ca
Review №81

Nothing true pickers would want. Its all repurposed old but new.

Gi
Review №82

Always something interesting to see & good reasonable prices

Ga
Review №83

Love looking at antiques

Gr
Review №84

I didnt buy anything on this trip, just looking and I found some really cute things.

ra
Review №85

Small store than last time.

Ki
Review №86

Just love it!

Ma
Review №87

Great verity to choose from

Ha
Review №88

I like looking around to see what they have new.

Pe
Review №89

Nice selection of antiques

St
Review №90

Nice place with nice products

Wi
Review №91

Very nice place

Je
Review №92

Neat stuff!

Am
Review №93

Love coming here!!

Sh
Review №94

Pickers Paradise is a great flea market

ch
Review №95

Lots of items to chose from but some prices are to high

Pa
Review №96

Love this place

De
Review №97

A bit small but priced well. Friendly staff and clean floors.

Ta
Review №98

Love this place

Ka
Review №99

Loved the store

Ba
Review №100

Great place

Information
100 Photos
100 Comments
4.2 Rating
  • Address:1750 25th St, Columbus, IN 47201, United States
  • Site:https://m.facebook.com/PickersParadise/
  • Phone:+1 812-657-3488
Categories
  • Antique store
Working hours
  • Monday:10AM–6PM
  • Tuesday:10AM–6PM
  • Wednesday:10AM–6PM
  • Thursday:10AM–6PM
  • Friday:12–5PM
  • Saturday:10AM–6PM
  • Sunday:10AM–6PM
Accessibility
  • Wheelchair accessible entrance:Yes
  • Wheelchair accessible parking lot:Yes
Planning
  • Quick visit:Yes
Similar organizations