Tried a little bit of everything because their menu was eclectic. I had the fish and chips, which were very crispy and not overwhelming fishy. Their tartar sauce was very well balanced as well. My boyfriend got the rodeo burger which had a nice crust on the patty and wasnt overloaded with sauce. He also got a ham and cheese omelet which was tasty... with sausage links which were really good, very well seasoned. All in all was a great diner experience
I love breakfast any time of day and the Carlisle Diner delivers. My omelet was fresh and hot. The service was fast and friendly. A great place to visit.
Service was good food was great!!Love my BLT
This place has good down home and homemade food. Its an excellent place to get together with your family, also! The one thing that you must know; is that they give you more than enough food! Whether its breakfast, lunch or dinner, you shouldnt come out of there hungry. I always have extra to take home! 😋😊😋yummy
Best diner in Carlisle.. Wonderful service and top notch food.. Recommend the prime rib Au jus dinner meal oh goodness delicious with the mashed potatoes n gravy😍😍
The food was very good. The eggs and bacon were cooked perfectly and the coffee was really good. Our waitress was efficient but she could have been a lot friendlier. The host up front should have been more attentive to guests coming in and guests that were trying to pay their bill as he was not up front very much.
My daughter and I usually split the Carlisle Feast, their meals are priced really well for the amount of food you get. Ive never seen this place empty, but the servers are always there when we need them without hovering, which is greatly appreciated!
I ordered food that was on their online menu and not only didn’t they inform me they didn’t have it but they also got snotty when I told them they gave me the wrong thing and I had to order something else. I would give them a one star but I know they can do better and always have when I’ve been in there. I hope this is a one off incident and others don’t share in it as I love this place. The food is great the prices are ok and the atmosphere inside is good also the staff is usually very friendly. I’ve been going for years and it’s the first time I’ve experienced this. I hope they server everyone else better and your experiences are what I know they can provide.
Had a ham and Swiss cheese mushroom burger. It was okay. Just for some reason the burger tasted like liver. Weird man! I always liked it here. But had not been here in over 2 years because of the covid 19. Dont know if its still owned by the same family or not
We stopped by on our way from upstate NY to DC. Weary, hungry travelers with a baby. Kim was our server and we hit it lucky. So nice. Polite. Helpful. Food was delicious. So reasonably priced. And Kim. Thank you!!!
Good food, enjoyed my omelet. They serve breakfast all day.
Great small business. Food is great
Very nice little diner with good food at a reasonable price.
Awesome staff, extremely clean, outstanding food. Always enjoy stopping here
Great food, fast service, very large variety of food. Tried delicious dessert! Yum!
We love local, hometown diners for breakfast. This one had a nice atmosphere and a great breakfast menu. Hubby ordered the Country Fries, which is, generally. Listed as a scramble. He enjoyed it. I had the farmers omelet minus the shrooms and it came just as ordered. It could have been hotter. It wasn’t cold but just warm. The home fries were yummy. The waitress lacked personality and friendliness but she was efficient. Aside from giving me rye instead of white toast
One of the best breakfast places in town!
Liked the old American Diner environment, great food and service. Take your time to come on Sunday, pretty crowded
Average food, seemed expensive for a diner... wife was not happy with her roast beef sandwich.... my wrap was average... fries were below average.... guess it was about what you should expect from a diner
Service was spotty. We had to ask for beverage refills she didnt offer. Kids meal is supposed to include dessert but she never asked if we wanted it, not sure she even knew it was included. Food was good and plentiful although my omelet was luke warm.
My fiancé and I love to go here for breakfast dates. The eggs over Molly is my absolute favorite, nothing beats the hollandaise sauce. Its so creamy and buttery. Only issue is my fiance isnt a huge fan of hashbrowns so alot of times he prefers to order french fries with his go to eggs benedict but unfortunately they told him they wont serve fries before 11 am as the fryers arent on so he got a lil frustrated on our last visit.
Was there for mothers day good service our meals were great what they called beef pot pie it was not beef pot pie its not tomato based I dont know what it was it was it didnt even make good beef stew so well go back again even though $15 was a lot for leftover what they call beef pot pie.
Very good food especially the shrimp stir fry. Delicious. Great service too.
Was busy but food came quick with friendly service. Great diner food!
Good food at reasonable pricesNice waitress.
Typical diner. Food is too bland to my liking. However, in comparison with Walnut Bottom and Fairgrounds Diner, this one is the best of the three.
Food great service is fast friendly get alot of food for price staff is always friendly
Great food! Nice polite staff. Definitely will visit again.
Felt over charged for what we got they tryed serving are kids bad milk and the homefrys tasted like they poored drit in them and had big black chunks all thru them
Everything you expect from a local diner. The breakfast was great. I had scrapple for the first time, its not something I would eat again, but I was in the area. Eggs, omelettes, pancakes and waffles, were all done very well.
Great staff and food! we were seated far enough away from people that we felt safe dining in.
It has common diner food. The service was friendly and the meal came quickly
Food was good but the drink selection was not I had ice water and the chlorine taste was rediculous
Good food & great place to go
I always stop by to get breakfast here when I can.Theyre the best. The country benedict is fantastic!
I LOVE this place! The host, Coby, Ryan, was excellent & very friendly. The waitress was awesome. Im moving from the Carlisle area but I will forever stop at this diner to support small businesses!!!!
Love this place! Good food and fast!
Love the Carlisle diner! Great food!
Food was decent enough, service was OK, ill head back if Im passing that part of town again and get a diner craving
First time Ive ever ate at the diner. Ive heard many people tell me how wonderful it was that I should try it. I highly recommend this restaurant. The beef chips and gravy was delicious. Next time Im in the area I would most definitely come back!
Great prices great service, yummy diner food.
Always good food and they added more precautions and outside dining
One of the best diners around. Awesome staff. Great food. Good atmosphere.
Love to go here to eat and talk with friends.
Food is fabulous, the waitresses are courteous,and respectful.
Good food & fast service
I used to really love this place, but it seems like lately theyve been hiring absolute potatoes as servers. Had a gentleman named Christian the past few times Ive been in. Last time i was in he forgot my coleslaw (which is included with my wrap) and this time he forgot my friends coleslaw and my salad. Along with the blue cheese i ordered with my appetizer. The dude doesnt pay attention and seems to not be familiar with the menu. I swear Jess and Kim were the only two servers that actually know what theyre doing in the past year or two. I used to be a regular but this is disappointing anymore.
This is a nice cozy little place doesnt make you feel like youre at a big chain like Dennys or waffle House this makes you feel like youre going to get some good home cooking so I recommend this place cuz the food was good the service was good the place was clean and quiet so go there have a meal and you will agree with me
Always good food, fast service justike a diner should.
Being a Carlisle native, Ive eaten at The Diner for many years. The food is always delicious and the service is excellent!
Amazing service every time!
Best Reuben Ive had in years!!!
Great food, service and pricing
Very nice would be going back
Horrible service, smells bad and seems like everybody are depressed
Me and my Dad eat breakfast there all the and my favorite is chipped beef on toast and homefries.
Food was excellent, friendly staff,price was great,
As always great food, great service! The waitress was very overworked but was still very quick and polite. GREAT JOB!
Stopped for a lite lunch. Soup n coffee. Ham n bean soup was excellent, chicken noodle good but a tad spicy for moi. Coffees were good, hot and plenty..nice clean place. With very good service. Worth a stop when youre in the area
Great food, reasonably priced. Fast, friendly service. Great place to stop after the Carlisle car events!
Had a quick supper here with husband. I ordered the Reuben w/fries, coleslaw & pickle. Very good sandwich and fries were perfect. Coleslaw could use a complete new makeover. Very blah. Great service from friendly on top of it waitress! Coffee at this diner is great. Always fresh & hot. Never bitter...I give my experience 5 stars.
Great waitress great service great prices good food
Great fast delicious food
Always good food here
Large selection. Good prices
Food was very dry over cooked
Wonderful best service and food.
The prices are definitely catered to the college kids. Ive never been to a diner before where replacing one item could hike up the bill for the price of a drink. Homefries are free to replace for french fries anywhere else you go.Dont come here expecting fair prices on anything with how underwhelming the menu options are. (Who doesnt put the time to have have a decent breakfast menu) The prices are def more than your average diner, you could easily get more food going elsewhere for the same price.Beyond that, decent staff and atmosphere.
Great food. Very large portions, never disappointed.
Good food
Food was disgusting. Server was nice but will never eat there again.
Not Happy People walking in with no masks and were not told about this.Clearly sign said Masks are to be worn.My ice cream Sundae.Worst Sundae I ever had.Ice crystals in it.I enjoy the Burgers though.Will go somewhere for Ice cream sundae
Great food!! If your ever coming to a Carlisle car show, stop here!!
It is a good diner. The food quality was what you would expect for a good diner. The price was comparable. We spent around $20 total for 2 people. That is for breakfast, coffee, juice, and tip.
We usually do not have any problems with the food and service however lately it has been just OKAY.
Very good food,and at a good price.Also weight staff are all very very nice
They raise there prices
The diner itself was very good. It was clean, service was fast and friendly, and the food was very good.However, the clientele in this place .... not always so great. I was seated next to a group of older teens who were cursing and having a downright disgusting conversation.I had to ask to be moved.Because of this, I recommend the Walnut Bottom Diner instead. I have been there many times and have never been seated near a raucous and rude group such as this.
Dirty, food isnt good, and poor staff.
Good food.. Great price..Room for bobtail semi parking..
Great food and service. I believe they were short staffed but managed to give good service regardless. Other eateries should take notes!
Breakfast was very good and hot. Service was wonderful! The waitress kept the coffee flowing and the portions were large.
Barb is awesome
Was very average, main course was good, sides, not so much.
I had a great meal that was well prepared and cooked to my delight. I thought my visit was great with two exceptions. The server was ore interested in the three young ladies at another table . There were only five other couples dining when I was seated, but it took 16 minutes for a menu to arrive. Not good for business at all.
Our waitress was amazing, very friendly and attentive. The rest of the staff was as well. The food is well priced and good. Nice environment. Overall I was very pleased.
Love there food
Great food good service
Great service and food
I always love the food. They have great service, very polite and fast. And I love the car decorations. Very cool place
Great Food, good service, ample parking. Attentive waitress.
Good food generous portions,reasonable prices, super clean, friendly helpful staff.
A cornerstone of the town. Ive been coming here for at least 15 years. Im a breakfast anytime if day person, and they never disappoint. The salads are huge, bring your appetite. And dont forget the dessert case. Its worth a dedicated trip on its own.
