Excellent dining option for singles, couples and families. There are tables that can seat at least 8 and tables for as little as two. The staff is friendly. The menu is homestyle Italian and everything sounds appealing.I stopped in for the Meatball Stuffed Loaf and it did not disappoint! 4 massive meatballs, stuffed into a crusty loaf of freshly baked bread. The bread is soft on the inside, but not so much that all the delicious red sauce and rich melty cheese make it soggy. The sauce is somewhat sweet, but not that kind of sweet that lingers and makes you not appreciate the flavors of the tomatoes and seasonings.I really dont even like meatball subs, but something about these lured me in... Im glad, because theyre incredible and you should definitely stop in and have one!
We stopped in late this afternoon for takeout dinner and were so happily surprised. This was a whim stop as we do not live close and were in Ohio and on our way home. The reviews were so good on here we decided to stop. The staff was lovely and kind. The prices were good for the amount of food you get. The interior was top notch. It was nice to be treated with respect and patience while ordering, this is such a rarity these days. The food did not take long at all to receive, as we ate some in the car, and the rest at home. The pizza and fries are wonderful! We are saving the garlic knots for a road trip tomorrow! Thanks for a good experience. We WILL be back! (Highly recommended)
There’s nothing like the local Italian mainstay that a town is so grateful to have. I never heard of a “Dugout” before (I’m from outta town), but it beats a regular meatball sandwich to a tomatoey pulp. It was fabulous. Many choices of items here. Great service. Quality food. Consistency. I recommend this place.
This is one of our go to restaurants when were in the area. Thier house dressing is incredible. I could drink it. Pizza is of course great but so many other items are as well. Sausage pie, calzones, pasta, salads. Ive yet to have an item I didnt like. Service is always great too.
Love everything they make, from the pizzas to the soups & everything in between. Cant go wrong with anything. Its all delicious
My girls and I have been coming in almost ever Thursday for the past few months. Food always great. Service is awesome. Torrie normally helps us. She knows my girls, knows what they get, and how they like it prepared. They just love this! Great job and thank you for your awesome customer service.
Food was very good, but slow service. I understand everything is made from scratch, but When dining in They need to tell you wait time for pizza is 35-40 minutes before ordering.
Stopped here to grab a bite because I hadn’t eaten all day. Got a personal pizza and let me tell you this sauce is some of the best sauce I’ve ever tasted. Although Ohio isn’t known as a pizza Mecca either. The girl at the counter offered up some great suggestions and was happy to help. Would stop here again if I’m ever in the area in a heartbeat.
Love your sauce Manginos Pizza. Friendly and helpful to customers Generous supply
If your looking for real deal Italian food, this is the place to go. This isnt your typical NY style pizza. And the sausage pie is a must have. Great service, and super friendly people.
Wedding soup & salad with the homemade balsamic dressing.. Love it
Best peperoni rolls in town
Food good but need crackers for soup and regular cream for coffee
Delicious Italian food. Very busy.
The food was good.
The best in new castle !
Amazing food. Great customer service!
Very tasty Italian and salad combo
Amazing pizza! My first time there was yesterday and I was very happy with the food! They also get 5 stars for not being a bunch of wimps and trying to face me to were a mask! I respect places that let me make decisions like that for myself. Ill be back for sure!
Extremely slow tonight. It was 30 minutes past what they told me for a sandwich. I waited paintancely though. The girls were nice but they need to say how long the wait really is
Best buffalo chicken pizza around! Sausage pie.. the sauce.. meatball sliders.. I could go on, everything is always amazing and friendly service everytime!
Food and restaurants looks nice great pics of food everywhere! But just ok, pizza is precooked and seems to be sitting for a while. Needs to be heated better ours was soggy. Crust was a bit thick in places and some spots were missing toppings including cheese. Thought it also tasted yeasty...Tip get you sandwiches heated i didnt want my hot and the bread tasted stale. So heat your sandwich.
The cover counter pizza was a bit burnt
Awesome pizza and salad
Best Lamb sandwich I ever had! Tender, juicy and mouth watering good! Highly recommend.
Fresh pizza by the slice, tasty dough and nice sweet sauce. I thought the price was good for how much food you get.
Food is out of this world
The staff was so nice and accommodating and the food was awesome. They seemed to be really careful about cleanliness and social distancing, but thet have a huge dining room, and even with all of the Covid-19 restrictions, it was still a pleasant dining experience. I would definitely recommend them for dine in or carry out.
Delicious as always! As soon as you walk in, the aroma tells you youre in for a treat !!!
Great food and great service!
Love the specialty pizzas!
First time I was there. Very good food!!!!
Absolutely fantastic pizza. The knots are amazing as well. Will definitely return.
First visit here and was a little skeptical when I saw the prices and saw you ordered at the counter. That all changed when the good came. Absolutely the best lasagne I ever had!!! A little pricey but not for the huge portion they give you! Enough for two meals!! The garlic knots were out of this world and the salads were delicious and fresh! Would have given 5 stars, but thought it was a little cold in there, almost had to keep my jacket on, and the unsweetened tea was just soso. But the food was top notch! Pleasantly surprised?
Great food. A little pricey
Absolutely amazing pepperoni rolls! Will definitely stop again next time Im in the area! Place seems clean and staff is friendly.
First time here... I enjoyed my ravioli dish. Very good and meatballs were tasty too. Side salad was ok, nothing great. Pizza was delicious.
Great Veggie Pizza with awesome garlic taste! Red sauce pizza very good also, crust is fresh and not too thin, but not heavy, thick.
Truly a delight! True Italian recipes (from pizza crust to parmesan, etc)! If you like Leonardos in Franklin, youll like this even more. Specialty pizzas, subs, etc along with baked items like lasagna, GREAT!
Meatball dugout was great. Service very friendly.
Food is always fresh & delicious!
I had a white pizza with tomatoes and pepper rings. Crust was good but to much seasoning for me and pepper rings were to many and spicier than I prefer. Very greasy.
Best pizza in New Castle!!
Wonderful place. We stop by here EVERYTIME we are traveling near New Castle. Food items are creatively made.
The staff seems wary of you if youre old or deaf or difficult for those reasons. The pizza is just ok. Better if its hit. And has too much sauce hidden under nasty cheese. The pizelles are overpriced for a container of dry cookies. Pepperoni rolls are a joke. Pizza Joes is better.....
DELICIOUS! Try the homestyle pizza with mushrooms. Clean restaurant with decent atmosphere, reasonably priced, incredible food. Unlike any other pizza I have ever had (in a good way).
The food is awesome. I love everything they make. They typically have a good variety of premade selections if youre in a hurry.
Have never tried anything there that I havent loved 😋😋😋
Good quality food and quality service. Would have been better had they offered to warm up my spinach rolls and sausage pie
Excellent food and staff definitely worth the drive
Grew up with the Great food. I remember when it was a store too. Must place for all who have not had a must to get
Love this place!! Great pizza!! Always stop to buy pizza, pizza greens & pepperoni rolls before returning home.
The atmosphere is great. The food is even better. I did experience very slow service but they apologized and was kind. I would definitely go bank...
Food and service CANT be beat. Such a large selection it is hard to choose what to order!
Best in town
This is my favorite pizza in the area. Great sauce, homemade crust that isnt chewy. Great sausage. Just perfect.
Food was good. The garlic knots were worth the visit. Sauce was OK, too sweet for me but good.
Love the food. Everything is delicious. Try the chicken pastina soup! Everyone is super friendly.
Awesome food. Great atmosphere to dine in.
The food was great. We had pizza, spinich roll, Cesar salad, and wings. Everyone enjoyed the food. The restaurant was clean and friendly. The waitress was very helpful and checked on us while we waited for the pizza to arrive.
Nice, good place, spacious, nice seating. Always good food. Very impressed with the new location.
1st time ever trying Manginos and it was a success! Great staff as well.
Chicken Pastina soup and spinach roll both delicious. Service was great and its a comfortable atmosphere.Thank You
Delish
I was stunned when I found out what our total was! I could not figure out how a two topping pizza and two cannolis added up so quickly. I know a lot of people rave about how delicious this pizza is, so I wanted to try it. It was average at best. I did not enjoy how they use a slice of whole cheese rather than shredded or grated cheese. It made it hard to eat and it wasnt as soft and satisfying. Once was enough for me.
The pizza is very good. I luke a few places in town and this place has solid food. I love the wedding soup, one of the best! Taste a lot like my grandma made. Roni rolls and their sauce is amazing.I havent tried their subs or pasta. But I plan to and when that happens Ill have to review it. I love this place, but I hate the road its on. Insanely hard to leave when you go around 5pm. Its a made house rush hour style.
One of the best pizzas in town
Great sauce! Great selection at the counter, very good pie!
Only had the homemade spinach rolls and soup....but both were very good!
Amazing Food and great staff
Best pizza around
The Naples restaurant may not look the same as the original Manginos Pizzeria located in New Castle, Pennsylvania, but its menu remains consistent in both locations with recipes that are real, hearty and deliciously satisfying. Both locations have a core philosophy of treating and cooking food for customers, as if they were family.
Great tasting bistro style Italian food. Clean and modern atmosphere.
Delicious. Never had a bad meal. Always quick and friendly service.
Everything is so delicious. Our favorite is meatball sliders. Our Friday treat to ourselves at work.
Was very disappointed in this experience, normally pretty impressed with the takeout at other location. However for the price, the lady at counter was ignorant, after ordering 60 dollars in food we were told it was going to be 90 some cents for a side order of barbecue sauce. Was about a half hour before food ordered was ready. Just not what I had expected from a place with the manginos name.
Delicious food, great service a very nice looking restaurant. Best pizza in New Castle.
1st theres no menu other than that on a wall, like a fast food restaurant. The staff was not very helpful when we asked for suggestions stating it was our 1st visit. The staff actually tried to talk us out of ordering a fresh made pizza, I wish wed of listened. Tasted exactly like a Augustines frozen pizza for 2/3 more money. We will not be returning. Alot of flash for very little flavor or quality.
Fantastic food and friendly service 👌
Great dining area and great food
Great Pizza. Many options
Very clean,very friendly, and very tasty, hearty dishes, very fulfilling for affordable prices!!
Food was great, love the concept of really good Italian without the sit-down, taking forever wait service!
Delicious food, inviting atmosphere, and friendly service.
Fantastic food love their lasagna and pizza
The pizza is the best. Many other options at the neshannock location. The wait at neshannock sometimes can be long when they are busy.
Great food... Acoustics a little loud... Eat in or take out
Great food. Prices are great .love decor
Great place to stop for lunch or dinner love everything on the menu you will to
It was our first time at Maginos and it was great. We will definitely be back and recommend it to others.
Awesome food, excellent service
Unique tasting pizza with special sauces and crunchy crust.
Cashier was very curt..dud bot feel welcome..pizza was great.
Excellent food. Relaxed atmosphere. Clean.
Excellent as always