Stuff a bagel was delicious! Great place to have breakfast.

People lined up everyday! Everything here are fresh and made each day! Bagels are good and healthier with less salt on everything bagel lol. Omelette, sandwich, rolls, you name it they have it and ready to serve a very good breakfast. Menus are uploaded. Have a great Breakfast!!!!

I LOVE this place! GREAT sandwiches.Very clean. I just discovered this place. Went there at least 5 times in the past month. GREAT food selection!

Our favorite bagel place in the area for breakfast and lunch. Excellent egg sandwiches, wraps, salads and sandwiches. The over-medium eggs are always perfect and the tuna salad is delicious. Highly recommend!

Paying extra for toasting, for a bagel about $3.65. Service was so impersonal. Dry Bagel ( cheese was shown to bagel and bagel to cheese).

Decent, but not the best bagel place

Fast service. Great bagels. Friendly service

Good deli. I wish they had Almond milk/ Soymilk options and not just almond creamer to offer for protein shakes

Great place. Great local neighborhood deli. Service is always on point. Nice and friendly staff. Pricing is very reasonable and food is great. My wife loves the fact that they have many options for bagels and cream cheese flavors here!

I really miss the bagels from this place. I moved from Bethpage to Central Islip and I have to say there is no comparison at all. This place has the best bagels in NY!

Great food, not just bagels. Sandwiches, salad, baked treats and the coffee is really good. They also have a really nice iced coffee. You can park in front or behind the shop since they have a rear entrance. Well worth it!

Over priced

Best sandwich i ever tasted. Great employees.

My stuffed bagel was everything, its officially my new place after work.

Came to Stuff-A-Bagel for the first time the other week in years. The place is clean and the staff is friendly. The one thing myself, and the others who ordered, wished they would take a sandwich order as is, and not push for one of their sandwiches that sounds similar. Sometimes a person knows exactly what they want to eat. In the end, the sandwiches ordered tasted good.

Called this morning for a very large breakfast order, one item was for grilled ham and cheese on a bagel they told me they can’t do that because they are way too busy doing egg orders! Really ok no problem taking my business to another bagel store!

Absolutely love the food and the staff is amazing.😋 Miss so much since I moved out of state.😔

Stuff a Bagel is a staple for early morning bagel runs at Bethpage Taxi and Airport Service! Many of the staff know the names of the cab drivers here and know the dishes they order! That is why we will always go to Stuff-A-Bagel whenever we need a fresh bagel and hot cup of coffee!

Nice quick service. For some reason or another I end up with pocket full of change when I pay cash... maybe its the way they price their items... dont know...

They do not make their bagels there. They are shipped in raw the night before and cooked in the morning. Its expensive for most prepared meals, expect to pay for the convenience of an expansive menu. Saturday mornings are the busiest and the line can wrap around the store.

This place has the best chicken salad. Been coming here for years. Consistent quality foods available.

Very friendly and helpful staff. Breakfast was very nice and everything was done perfectly. Glad we stopped in.

Great bagel s

Pricey but the food is really good here. The portions are solid for many things there too. It does seem a little crowded and busy with their set-up, and it always seems people are just standing around but Im not accusing them of that because Im sure I dont know what they are doing for a fact. Just sharing the things Ive seen and talked to other customers about.I definitely recommend it.

Sometimes they forget things. Like my entire omelette. Otherwise I love this place.

Best bagels on the island.

FAST. In and Out even with a small line. Really nice. Good was good. But not amazing. Fair prices.

The food is good but Im giving them 3 stars because they nickel and dime the customer. I ordered chicken salad today with a bagel on the side and they charged me 15 cents to slice the bagel! Are you kidding me I thought so I asked the server and he shrugged his shoulders and said they charge for everything here. They used to offer a free coffee refill for sit down customers but they stopped doing that. They charge Starbucks prices for their coffee so they have room to offer a free refill and still make plenty of profit but they wont do it. They also have a $10 minimum for credit card purchases. Im surprised they dont charge a fee to use the restroom!

The bagels are okay but they charge for EVERYTHING.. slicing a bagel fee wow! will head to bethpage bagels.

Increeible food and great service. Only issue is finding parking i suggest parking in the bigger lot behind the store and walking around and dont waste your time trying to find a spot in the front by the doors. Otherwise all in all great service and the food ? It is incredible. Definite recommendation

I love this place is normally quick and my family like their sandwiches a lot

One of the best bagel shops in the area. Prices are good and the bagel was amazing. So glad we stopped in on our trip back to the island.

We always go after we get our tee time at bethpage and the place is good. The food always made to order and service is always great.

Usually good but lately the grilled chicken they use in their salads and wraps are not fresh at all and feel like rubber. Very disappointing.

Good food! Fast, friendly service. Good prices.

Great bagel place, good quality ingredients, really good bagels, better staff.

Staff is very accommodating, and the food was very fresh and tasted amazing

Ive been going to Stuffa for years and years like the majority of bethpage. I have never had an issue with the food and consistently return here. Very nice and clean inside (although i do miss the old pre-renovation dirty/dingy stuff a bagel). Bagels are usually perfect. My only suggestion would be for them to put more bacon on the egg sandwiches or at least try to distribute it evenly.

I love bagels and I love sandwiches so this is a great place for me. Prices are decent as well.

Great neighborhood place. Great coffee.

I ordered a simple egg sandwich, they had to make it twice and even the second one came out wrong. Paid $5 to throw away an egg sandwich.

Good place to pick up coffee and breakfast while you wait for your Bethpage tee time.

How the food tastes is irrelevant when delivery takes over an hour and we are less than a mile from them. Couldnt even switch to pick up since the driver had the food in the car for over 30 mins. All hot food was cold and soggy.

Staff was very friendly and patient when I had asked them to ring me up 3 seperate order which they had already rung up togetherAlso...I got the chicken salad on a plain, toasted scooped bagel, which I recommend. That will fill you up

Good service. A little pricey but staff are very nice.

Ok Ill let my friends nowI loved it the foods great

Bagels extremely fresh and taste is good too.

We had breakfast and everyone enjoyed what they ordered.

Great place

I miss the old stuff a bagel... Eggs arent that good either taste like fake eggs.

Good bagels and sandwiches. quick service and good coffee.

Good spot for sandwiches and bagels top notch

1st trip : Bagels need to be cooked more and the staff has to pay attention and get the orders right. 2nd trip : totally screwed up the order... $16 for a messed up egg sandwich order....wont go back.

Yummy food, friendly service. !!

Excellent food and very affordable

Friendly staff. Line can get a little bit disorganized at times. Bagels are good.

Great food and service

Always good

Prompt service and good selection

Dont order a wrap from here. They put very little cold cuts in so the whole thing is wrap. Paid 10 bucks and has happened to me multiple times will not go back

Great service and food

In the year 2017, refusing a regular, local and paying customer because they dont attain your so-called minimum $10 credit card purchase-when the food is already made and sitting in front of me-- is absolutely absurd and short-sighted. Lost a customer for sure.

Staff is amazing

Everything is Delish!

Great service, and best french toast in the land

This place is great awesome sandwiches always 💯👍🏼

Good food

Great place for a quick breakfast sandwich

The bagels are fine, but the service can be spotty and $2 for a small coffee is a bit high.

Good food.

The food is good, but the in-store flow is terrible. Its hard to get around inside, especially during peak hours

Awesome Bagels & Breakfast Sandwiches

Great bagel shop and deli.

Bagels always fresh.

Theyre not redefining breakfast or bagels here, but a solid and consistent spot to nosh.

Good food

Best tasting bagels

They discriminate against small credit card transactions

Very good

Good place

Great food

They and great

Great food

Love it

Usually a long wait.

Okay

Ng