Fantastic selection and fantastic staff. Lots of great olive oil and balsamic (with free samples) and also other food treasures - including Wisconsin-made items, honey, jams, truffle salt, pastas... lots of great items.

Love the selection, only place like it around town as far as I know.

They have the best assortment of oils and vinegar around. They will let you sample anything you like. They have a small size available if you just want to try a flavor. They also have a small assortment of olive oil products and wine /beer brittles. Masks are still required and they serve you the samples.

Best olive oils and select balsamics in the valley. Farro and great pastas also.

Great oils and knowledgeable staff.

Really awesome place. The staff were super friendly and helpful with my many questions and were quick to offer me samples as well. They have a large selection of gourmet olive oils and vinegars, they also have handmade pasta, sauces, wine, and more. I honestly cant wait to go back and try and buy more next time, Ill be filling up my punch card here for sure.

We always have a great experience at the Olive Cellar. Today I stopped in for a bottle of the 12 yr balsamic for a gift and stocked up on several additional varieties for our home. Also grabbed a bootle of the butter olive oil which we like on popcorn. Mmmmm

This place has the best products and the best customer service. I Was running late the other day and called in my order and even though I arrived 2 minutes past the time they closed.. both nice ladies still waited on me with a smile and were over the top helpful. Thank you all for your wonderful products and customer service we will always shop with you!! The quality of your Olive oil is the best in our favorite is the extra spicy I thank you pronounce it baccaloo.thanks

Love balsamic vinegar, they have wide variety. Worth stopping in.

Excellent oils and balsamics at a competitive price. I wish we lived closer.

Great store! Nice selection of oils and vinegars, as well as pasta and wines. Customer service is A+. Like stepping into a little oasis!

Great Olive Oils and Vinegar. I usually get a standard normal and then a flavored. Use the olive almost daily when I cook. Sooo much better than anything you can get at a grocery store...well worth the extra money. And the service is fantastic. They help you, tell you about the stuff and let you browse and try the different flavors at your leisure. If you cook with grocery store olive oil, give this place a try...youll never go back.

Nice selection of oils

A great selection and delicious options. I love the ability to sample almost everything!

Great selection of olive oil and balsamic vinegars. Helpful staff too!

The Tuscan Herb olive oil is beyond awesome and the customer service is wonderful. So glad the store is a part of our community! 😊

Loved this place. So many good choices, garlic olive oil is fantastic. Cant wait to visit again.

Best tastings oils around. Always helpful!

100% pure olive oil. Not like the cheap supermarket stuff. Huge range of oils and balsamic vinegars and even real tuffle oil. Delicious!

Absolutely the best in the Valley! Wonderful oils, vinegars, and a fun selection of other wines, treats, pastas, and sauces.

I am like a kid in a candy store here! You can taste every specialty oil and balsamic they have and there are plenty! Not cheap but you are paying for the highest quality products. Oils and vinegars from grocery stores no longer cut it for me. The quality is so inferior to Oil Cellar it should be a crime to sell it.

Amazing olive oil and balsamic vinegar

I dont go anywhere else for my olive oils.

Great selection super clean store

Freaking fantastic

Very helpful

Awesome place