After hearing about the lemon poppyseed bagels at a yoga class, I had to stop in a few months ago and grab some… I’ve been hooked ever since! Incredible customer service, the most delicious fresh bagels and to die for cream cheese.. what more can you ask for?! Oh and the fun flavors of the month… this place really knows how to wow a customer!

Hard pressed to find a better bagel in 300 miles. While the bagels are good, I wish they offered a little more on the coffee side of things like French press, pour overs, espresso.

I’m from Northern New Jersey near NYC where they make the best bagels in the country. These are among the best I’ve had outside the NYC Tri-State area. In my opinion the consistency is more like bread than bagel dough. The customer service is above excellent. I highly recommend.

Wonderful staff, great atmosphere and the bagels and coffee were delicious. We will be making this our regular stop from now on.

Honestly the best bagel shop in town! Their selection is so good and it’s hard to choose a favorite!

Super speedy, delicious and fairly priced. Friendly service and a pleasant atmosphere

Fast and friendly serviceEnjoyed the bagels!Will definitely be back

Delicious bagels and selection! Really reminds me of East Coast bagels

Some of the best bagels in the Fox Valley. Not to crunchy not too soft. They also have a great variety that can make anyone happy. Cream cheese is perfect and they offer good deals as well. Stop thinking about it and order from this place you won’t regret it.

Great portions of cream cheese. Fantastic service!

Just discovered this place and I couldn’t be happier. I looove bagels and this place does them right!Wide variety of delicious concoctions, the young ladies working behind the counter were incredibly friendly, and I love the “hole in the wall cafe” atmosphere. Oh, and the prices are as reasonable as you could expect.

The bagel i had gotten was excellent (apple crunch). The service was fast and staff were very friendly! I highly recommend!

So so good! One of my girlfriend and I’d favorite place to grab a quick breakfast.

Best place for breakfast or lunch! Great service great bagels! Highly recommend!!

Excellent fresh made bagels.

Never thought I would like a place like this but I am absolutely in love with these bagels!! Definitely the best in the valley! Try the chocolate chip bagels and chocolate chip cream cheese!

Would be better if they didnt always play country music.🤠🤢🤮

Was my first time visiting store. Store was clean. Staff super helpful. Bagels were still warm, and everyone said they were delicious.

Hubby likes the lox bagel sandwich. Kids like the oreo or chocolate chip bagels and I love the spinach quiche bagel. Great place to grab your bagels and cream cheese to have on hand for easy breakfasts and snacks. They freeze well too.

Best place to get bagels. Customer service is excellence as well!

Since McDonalds stopped serving Bacon, Egg and cheese bagels I had been looking for an alternative. I can say I have found a gem in the rough. The selection of bagel and sandwiches are great. The service is exceptional. The taste of the bagels leaves you wanting more. This is definitely a must try.

We love Jersey Bagels, especially their breakfast bagel sandwiches! Great, friendly staff, too.

Great bagels and friendly service

I have been a long time support of Jersey bagels until now. They have gone to complete and utter disaster. They have raised praises much higher while lowering the quality of the food. From the display of the food to the quality of the ingredients it is a complete -10/10. Don’t go there if you want a good meal only if you want to feed someone you hate.

Better than Subway.

Great little no-fuss bagel shop with a limited menu and delicious bagels.

Good bagels, but no regard for social distancing or mask wearing. If you are concerned about Covid I would not go in. There are signs up for masks and stickers on the floor to distance, but when I went in this weekend there we 5 customers without masks. No one seemed to care about keeping their distance. The 8 foot counter had 5 people waiting for the register, 2 more people ordering, and they called me up to order wanting me to squeeze in between 2 other people.

Awesome bagels, safe distancing, great coffee friendly just go there and check it out

Best bagel store around. They have the best cream cheese!

Awesome variety of bagels and cream cheese!

Their bagels are awesome and they have a large variety! Employees are nice and its a nice atmosphere inside.

Really good bagels. They are a little unique in appearance but really tasty. Had the herb and cheddar with scallion cream cheese on first visit and liked it so much that we came back the next day. Had the Jersey (everything) bagel egg and cheese sandwich today, which was also really good. Definitely recommend.

Such yummy bagels and a variety of cream cheeses. Nice alternative treat to donuts.

Staff are extremely accommodating to special orders. Their bagels are VERY good. Love that they do special flavors of the month, have never had a miss on them.

Always great bagels and service.

Awesome place to grab a bagel or sandwich in the morning. Huge variety of bagels and cream cheeses. Only gripe I have is EVERY time I’m here there are a few specific employees who are not welcoming and come off very impatient.

Breakfast sandwiches are tasty and the bagels are amazing! So warm and fresh. Love the Oreo bagel 💗

Aweome bagel place for those bagels you want.This is a great little stop for bagels. They have a wide variety of choices and good coffee too. The dining room is modern and clean. Food is always prepared timely and accurate. The crew working there are all pros in the business and do a nice job of getting people in and out.My wife got me hooked on this place and it’s easy to see why. My favorite is a BLT or a jersey bagel (everything bagel) with cream cheese.Go here for that Sunday morning bagel you won’t be disappointed.

Love the begels, they are the best...not hard or crunchy they are soft. Salt is the best.

A must visit when in town.

Great local deli with wide selection of bagels and breakfast sandwiches. Fresh coffee at a reasonable price.

Great bagel shop! Try the salt bagel with vegetable spread. We will continue to stop in for breakfast and lunch.

This place is flat out awesome! Best bagels around. Best sandwiches around! Top notch employees that clearly take pride in their work. Highly recommend this place. Prices are fair and portions are very reasonable.

Best bagels Ive ever had! The owner Kurt is an awesome guy.

Bagels were very good and was in and out quickly.

Great breakfast or lunch spot. Service and food/coffee quality always top notch!

Brought back hear memories of Sue Annes Bagels when I walked in the door. Many of the same bagels and cream cheese were available and they were all as delicious as I remember. Great service and great food!

Best bagels in Appleton

Great non chain atmosphere. Good prices. My son loves the bagels! Very fresh. I would encourage you to go here over the big chains where the bagels can sit for hours and dry out.

Best bagels my family has had in the fox valley.

Good food at a good price.

Always our favorite place for bagels! Staff is friendly and helpful. Bagels are delicious. Their vegetable cream cheese is amazing. Wish they sold specialty coffee drinks (only brewed coffee is available), but that doesnt stop us from enjoying their offering.

Love this place! The bagel sandwiches are delicious. The cream cheese is perfectly whipped too! One of my favorite morning spots when I want a treat.

The sandwiches were good. The bagels were great with a huge creative selection, but the sandwich options were fairly run of the mill (club, ham and cheese, bacon and egg, etc) and didnt have a premium feel. Given the higher price point it definitely affected the perceived value. I would have expected more craft cheese and meat choices to better match the bagels.

The bagels are fantastic! My new bagel store for sure!

What a nice group of young people working together!! Ellen gave me a very nice “good morning “ and a genuine “have a nice day “Great job training your crew!Bagels are always awesome

Good bagels, but no one working there had a mask on.

Great bagels....love the Tomazzo & Cheddar Salsa! Reminds me of the old SueAnns Bagels place & havent been able to find good bagels like they had in this area!

Great food, friendly staff!

Love the service at this place! And the bagels are my absolute favorite... one of a kind! I’m not usually a bagel person but I love these! With so many options of cream cheese for a basic bagel, but also a bunch of sandwich options for lunch or breakfast! The atmosphere is welcoming and the service is fabulous! I’ve lost count of how many times I’ve been there it’s just so good!

Nearby. Bagels are often warm out of the oven. Good Sunday morning gathering place for me.

Always friendly service. Good clean environment. Great selection of 20 or so types of bagels and wide variety of cream cheese. Recommend: ham egg and cheese breakfast sandwich on the hot tomazzo bagel!

Husband eats here every day.

Absolutely 100% hands down best bagel shop around. If you havent been here you are truly missing out. I crave this place all the time!

Normally my husband picks up the bagels for us here and I think well continue that arrangement. Very busy and the young lady who helped me looked and acted sullen the entire time. You dont have to be thrilled to be there but I shouldnt walk away wondering if you got my order right and feeling like I burdened you. Bagels are good but the attitude sucked.

Quality bagels at a great price. Bagels stay soft and tasty even after a couple days in the fridge

Great and friendly service! We were helped by Isaac who was very knowledgeable about all the bagels. He was a great help!! Thanks for a great breakfast!

Very friendly staff, get your food out to you quick. Lots of bagels to choose from. Right now they have a resses peanut butter cup bagel.

10/10 food complementary Coffey fast service friendly staff!!! Try it you will love it!

The Jersey beagle is wonderful with lots and all the extras. A fresh fill pickle a hot tomazzsal and soft drink makes a nice lunch.

Could be more welcoming.

Jersey Bagels on the North East side of Appleton is our weekly stop on Sunday for a great breakfast sandwich and a weeks worth of bagels for lunch sandwiches. They have friendly servers and a nice clean store....love it!

Jersey bagel is my FAVORITE place in the fox valley to grab a bite to eat. The bagels are the best I’ve ever had and are super cheap! Seriously though — if you haven’t been here yet, you’re really missing out.

Love to go there in the quiet sitting with a friend and a fresh Bagel life doesnt get better than that

Best bagels and breakfast sandwiches in town, fantastic family owned establishment, with friendly service. You cant go wrong.

Delicious always. Cant eat bagels from anywhere else.... so spoiled.

Great lunch selection! Wide variety of fresh bagels to choose from!

I needed lots of cream cheese and they let me know the cost effective for buying bigger vs individual without even asking. They look out for their customers. The bagel was so soft and yummy and cream cheese amazing!

Tried the turkey on cheddar herb bagel with chive cream cheese, the sandwich was basic no real robust flavors. The other sandwich ordered was a ham, egg and cheese also on the cheddar herb bagel, nothing special about this sandwich either.

We love this bagel shop. My wife always get the Hot Tommazzo bagel. We used to go to Sue Annes bagels back in the day to get it there, but when they went out of business we thought she could never get it again. Turns out this place may have bought the recipes because it is exactly the same and very good!

Delicious deli sandwiches made on your choice of fresh bagel. Breakfast and lunch options. Endless flavors of bagels and spreads. Grab a quick to go or sit and enjoy.

Dont let & deli fool you. Youre only getting bagels here. No salads. No soup. No options for low carb. Didnt see anything gluten free. The menu is very limited.

Love the bagels. Our favorite is the cheddar and salsa. Wish they made more of them!

Great bagels at a great price!!

Best bagels in the Appleton area. Especially like the chocolate chip and Door County cherry bagels. Also their lunch sandwiches on bagels are very good.

Very delicious, and friendly.

I got an everything bagel and it was awesome I will be back

The manager here hasnt an ounce of conscience in her. She takes care of her 3 granddaughters during her working hours. She usually feeds them with the free bagels. After the store is closed and her two daughters take their kids home with them, she starts to work for her job as manager. Since she starts to do her job after the store is closed, she has to work overtime. Thus, she gets overtime payment. She begins to work in earnest when her boss arrives there. When the boss comes, she acts like she never has fed her granddaughters with free bagels. She acts like she is a devout catholic while she talks about her boss, staffs and friends behind their back. Her two daughters work there. They are inhospitable to customers. Looked at objectively, the bagels taste not so bad. However, I dont want to eat here because I have no loyalty to the bagels made by the unscrupulous manager and her daughters.

Their bagels used to be amazing about 2 to 3 years ago. They have stedaly gone down hill. Today I got 4 bagels and the were all under baked. You guys need to be consistent with the product you are putting out. Also who do you have to know to get an asiago bagel. Pretty sure you only make 4 of them for all day!

Great selection of bagels and cream cheese good prices and friendly staff

The hot tomazzo bagel is hands down the best one🥰

The food and atmosphere is awesome.

Very friendly staff and great bagel

The kids that work here are super friendly and you have to try their amazing coffees.

Good bagels

Delicious bagels and cream cheese flavors! I was super impressed! Ill be back!

First time wont be the last!! Had no idea what to expect. Blown away by selection, options and service. Take the time to stop here! Sooo worth it!!

Great place to stop. Love their chocolate chip cream cheese!

A good place in Appleton for a Breakfast Bagel! Plus, a place to pick up extra bagels and flavored cream cheese!

The coffee was good