I did not have an appointment at the end of the day and my truck had a flat tire. They got me in and back on the road quick. The advisors were super helpful and friendly. And the techs are top notch for how quick they could complete the repair.

Great tire store! Timely, and detail oriented. Got me out and off to work on time.

Very professional and helpful for getting my tires aligned. Two other places said they couldn’t do the alignment as the vehicle had dynamic cruise control. They said that since it was only the tires replaced and and no other components of the dynamic cruise control it just needed a straight up alignment and not the one that requires the special testing. Saved me money and got the job done quickly. Very pleased with service and outcome.

Having just moved to the Appleton area, I was looking for an honest, reliable location to have my vehicles serviced. I was more than pleased with the service, timeliness and communication from Dave at Matthews Tires. They do great work and made me feel like a valued customer.

I am so glad Matthews Tire is able to take care of all my vehicle needs. They are professional, courteous and you can tell they care about their work and how they treat customers. I highly recommend them!

Im a single mom and professional with a protected budget but do want to spare on safety. Matthews (on West College) has never failed me and my two daughters. They are priced fairly and they do prompt and quality work. The folks at the counter and the technicians are such good communicators and I never question their input or recommendations.With my household they have earned two generations of customers.

The plan was made to just change out tires. I brought my vehicle in and they already had a loaner waiting for me. I was treated very well and decided to add an oil change too. They said no problem and had everything handled by the time I came back to pick up my vehicle. Great service, friendly staff, would go back again.

The people at Matthews were very friendly and explained exactly what was going on with my vehicle. My vehicle was done in a very timely manor. Thank you Matthews Tire!! A++++

Amazing place and amazing customer service. Called and got me in the same day and gave me a vehicle to use as I had errands to run ;)

I have been doing business here for over 20 years. I have purchased many sets of tires, had brake work and alignments done, and I am sure many other things. They are not the cheapest, and it shows. They do first rate work and stand behind it. My most recent visit was simple - remove my snow tires and reinstall my summer tires (which they had stored for me since last fall). After I dropped off my truck and went to work, it crossed my mind to have the tires rotated as long as they were already taking them all off and back on again. Then things got busy at work and I never called to add the extra service. I inquired about the rotation when I returned to get my truck at the end of the day. As it turns out, Matthews has been keeping track of rotating the tires for me. They never said anything about it, it was never an itemized charge, they just kept track of my mileage and evaluated the condition of my tires and did what was right without me even having to ask. What great service! Hats off to Dave and the rest of the Matthews crew!

Great customer service. They were very fast getting the work done. They checked my other tires and told me what still needs to be fixed. The charges are extremely reasonable. Will go back to get the rest of the work done.

This is the ONLY place I trust to handle and maintain our vehicles and they do so with such care, professionalism and integrity and at the most reasonable prices in the entire Fox Valley.

I have been using Matthew’s Tire for years for all of my tire and vehicle maintenance needs. Very accommodating for scheduling; reasonable prices; reliable service. All of the personnel are personable and knowledgeable. Would highly recommend.

Fantastic customer service! Got a flat and they were able to replace it within a few hours.

They have good prices on tires, but their auto service is as expensive as typical dealer prices and their service is subpar. They put the cheap semi-synthetic oil in my truck, despite the fact that the manufacturer specs call for 5w-30 full synthetic. Also needed a coolant line replaced on a turbo; they quoted me $1400, my regular mechanic quoted me $750.

I have been a customer at this location (West College Ave) for years, and have always had consistently excellent service. The staff knows me by name, and always make me feel welcome. I trust them with my vehicles, and know they have the best interests of their customers in mind at all times.

Fast, professional and always friendly and accommodating - Matthews is far and away the best at what they do. They are knowledgeable and flexible and a great value - they dont charge an arm and a leg, they do what needs to get done and dont engage in a bunch of upselling. Id recommend to anyone and everyone!

Dropped truck off at 6:30AM for an oil change and asked to be called when complete. Did not get truck until 4:30PM. Was never called. I called at noon and they had not looked at the truck yet. Wanted to get truck back before noon. They stood by their lack of communication, very unprofessional.

Very courteous and prompt. They do what I ask of them and look for any thing else that needs attention.

Matthews did a great job. Service was quick and convenient. I would highly recommend.

I give them an A++ for their customer service

I took my wifes SUV in for an oil change and regular maintenance, and they got it done fast, checked all the needed systems and parts, and politely provided me with a ride to my office and back again when it was done. Who could ask for more? I wont go anywhere else!

They are friendly and do a great job for a fair price

I really like coming to Matthews Tire for service on my vehicle. Even routine maintenance is a chore that I put off sometimes, but they make it pretty quick and painless. Scheduling an appointment over the phone takes just a couple of minutes, and Im always in and out within 30 minutes.

Extremely pleased with the service I received from Matthews Tire. I was driving on the interstate early morning and blew out a tire and damaged the wheel rim. I was given the use of a courtesy car for the day while they ordered and received a new rim for my car. They had my car back on the road by the afternoon.

Definitely a hit or miss with service here. I went originally to get a new rim. Had very good service and was treated nicely. They told me it would be 2 days to order a new rim and even put my spare on. The second trip was not so hot. I showed up yesterday morning ready to get my rim replaced and was greeted to a gentleman with a very bad attitude. I can understand not being a morning person but to sware under your breath is somewhat unprofessional. He was visibly perturbed when I told him I was planning to stay until the service was finished. Then after a half an hour or so he told me that they ordered the wrong rim, and it wasnt his problem. I get that mistakes happen but next time I buy tires Ill be taking my vehicle somewhere else. Thanks for the service!

I was extremely disappointed in the service experience. The Audi was fine this time, I had no issues there. Your notes should be able to show you the issues I’ve had in the past. As I was checking out on Monday, the cashier charged me for my service. I noticed that there were notes on my service form (not the one they gave me) that said I had an oil leak, fluid leak, and indicated two more issues. I asked about the issues – he only indicated he could have someone call me with estimates – never heard from anyone. He would have never brought up the issues had I not seen them and asked.I have heard about issues with the service your team provides, and I’ve continued to come back because I purchased my tires there. I have now had 2 bad experiences and I do not intend to make it a 3rd.

People were great, would return.

Weve been bringing our Ford truck there for some time now. They are great work with and they keep us in the loop on the progress of the work being done. Other places Ive had to call to find out whats going on.Ive recommend them to others.

Excellent brake service on my wifes car. Price came in as quoted and service was finished on time. The shuttle to and from work is great.The staff is courteous and friendly. Communication is excellent. Thank!

Completed my oil change and tire rotation as requested and completed on the day I brought my car in for service.

Excellent service every time!

Ive had two experiences with Matthews Tire & Auto over the past year, and in both cases theyve been OVERLY HONEST in their assessment of my vehicles needs. Both times I asked about getting the tires replaced, while getting other service or inspection done, and both times Matthews advised against tire replacement. Summer 2020, they performed oil change, and told me the tires were good enough, not needing replacement yet. Just this week, they inspected the vehicle and determined there are too many other problems with my older vehicle, to make it worth putting new tires on it, without fixing those other things.So why would I give 4 stars instead of 5, in light of this very honest service? Really because the very problem I hoped to address at both visits, wasnt resolved, which is that my tires leak air needing fill weekly. It seemed that if not replacing the tires, there might have been a way for them to re-seat them on the wheel, or check for why leaking air. I really was ready to buy new tires, to solve that problem, even knowing the car has some other mechanical problems; its been driving around fine for the most part.

Very professional, and excellent product knowledge

Dave, the lead manager, at Matthews Tire on College Ave is fantastic! He will do everything he can to give you the best service and price. He is the best in the business.

Honest and accommodating!! I took my personal vehicle there and Dave the service writer prioritized repairs needed instead of high pressure sales. That in itself was refreshing.

Since moving back to the area almost 4 years ago, we have not taken our vehicles anywhere but Matthews Tire. They have always treated us right and give excellent advice. In need of new tires, Dave advised me that the tires I wanted were not available but recommended an excellent comparable option. I dropped my car off Monday evening and I received a call by 10:00 am Tuesday that my tires were installed and alignment completed. Great work, great staff and always a great customer experience.

The staff is very friendly and efficient. I trust this Matthews completely with all of my vehicle maintenance.

Becoming more and more expensive over the years. Lacking customer service.

Dave and crew got me in for service on my tire pressure sensor system on short notice. They had me in and out of there in less than an hour and the issue has been resolved.

Matthews Tire is the best. They do so much more than tires and they really know their stuff and care. They take care of the little details and do the right thing. Highly recommend.

Thank you for your efforts in trying to repair my vehicle

Quickly found the demon in the electrical system. Very efficient and fair priced. Thanks!

They were able to get me in quickly!

It’s hard to get into Matthew’s Tires (regardless of of which of the three Fox Cities Matthews tires I contact for a simple rotation of tires.Keep in mind that the tires on my vehicle were purchased at one of the three Mathew’s Tires locations noted above.Note: Prior to payment for the four brand new tires purchased, I was repeatedly informed by the sales representative assisting me that is simple tire rotation would be something I would have very little difficult completing. The representative even specifically stated that I would be able to readily complete my tire rotation as you walk in Customer… That is, without a scheduled appointment.Since the purchasing of my tires and the plethora of attempts and energy put forth to get this needed simple service completed Has not only been very time consuming… But also has been very disappointing with regards to the availability… In the excessive amount of time needed before my call for an appointment to the actual booking and completion date.The quality is there… However all three locations within the fox cities area need to come together and reassess the amount of employees present at each service location to help meet the needs of the communities overall.

Have been a customer for almost 20 years and wouldnt go anywhere else. Matthews service is phenomenal. Great people who do a great job! Thank you.

We continue to enjoy taking all of our cars here as we always get wonderful friendly, professional service at a fair price. I highly recommend Matthews Tire for any and all of your tire or service needs.

Awesome service, they fixes an issue we had other mechanics look at. Decent prices, kind understanding mechanics.

Overall I had a great experience. The work was completed in a timely manner and with the usual high quality workmanship.

Great honest service. Hard to come by now of days.

I’ll only go to Matthew’s for service. They’re always quick, professional, courteous, and friendly. You can’t beat the prices, staff or quality of work.

I have to say thanks to Jason Laluzerne!! Jason definitely went out of his way to make the rims and tires i wanted on my 88 mustang gt go on and fit right and look awesome! Jason had no hesitation getting his hands dirty out in the shop to make it happen. Jason knows his tires and rims! I highly recommend Jason for any tire and or rim questions and in the future I will be coming back to this location. Great staff, very accommodating to my schedule to get me in asap. Thank you Jason and thanks to the rest of the guys who helped make the cobra rims work!

Very last minute oil change needed for my dads vehicle, they were packed and very busy but pushed his vehicle in and got it changed and taken care of within a couple of hours (82 and new to the area). I couldnt have been more grateful for their kindness and promptness, thank you Amy for taking great care of my dads car!

My first experience with Matthews Tire was good but not excellent. I called in for a quote on the phone while they were running their buy 3 get the 4th free tire sale. There was a miscommunication over the phone where I was told that a certain service was included in the price they quoted me, and it actually was not supposed to be included. I called in and spoke on the phone with Jason who made the situation right. He honored what I had understood over the phone, even though it wasnt supposed to be included. This is the type of service that makes one location stand out from other service shops. Good job, Jason! The customer service from Amy was not great, but I still will be a returning customer.

The staff did a great job on fixing my car! They took me to work and picked me up when the car was finished- Thank you.

We have used this place for a long time. We generally trust their work, advice and prices.

They patched one of my tires and did an oil change and tire rotation all for a good value. I also asked they to CHECK my brakes and other fluids but they didnt so I took off 1 star.

Always a pleasure dealing with the cast of characters at Matthews on W. College Ave. I wouldnt go elsewhere.

Good price fast service.

Excellent experience. Matthes Tire and their staff went out of their way to accommodate our needs.

Simple phone call to check on tires if they were in stock, they were. Also who answered the phone has pleasant.

Mitch at Matthews Tire on College Ave was very professional, polite, honest & courteous. The work was phenomenal. I had problems with two tires leaking air. Turns out, the valves had to be fixed, so they rebuilt them. Expecting to have to buy a set of tires, I was very elated with a zero bill! Matthews rocks! Mitch also came out to my vehicle so that I did not have to go into their waiting area, which I really appreciated.

Food was delicious. Service was great. Beer was ice cold. Fun night

They fit me in with 2 flat tires and had me on my way in no time!

Excellent 👌👌👍👍 service!!

UPDATE 8/5/2020Got a flat in one of the tires. Took to Matthews and they found that the piece of debris was far bigger than I thought and therefor damaged the tire beyond repair. Had the replacement tire in the next day, and the service was done well before business close. A stud broke off while they were removing the spare. I believe this to be from when my roadside assistance tech installed the spare - I think he cross-threaded the nut onto the stud. After going back and forth with the tow company and Matthews, I spoke with Amy at Matthews who was empathetic to my situation. I did not touch the car at any point, and yet it seems Ill be stuck paying for this... was my basic argument. Despite this not being Matthews fault, the tow company was non-empathetic to my situation. Matthews comped the wheel stud part and labor for me, and for that I am incredibly appreciative and grateful. Mitch was also very helpful, and I appreciate the work that this shop has done for me on multiple occasions.Original Review -Fantastic job! Tire Rack install and alignment was performed perfectly, done by the quoted time, no “gotchya” charges... just fantastic service. They were BUSY so be sure to call ahead. Word is out on how great this place is.

Been doing business with since 1967 only place where I will purchase tires well worth the drive always prompt and courteous service and done right the first time

Very helpful with my snowblower tire issue.

Excellent service, done quickly and reasonably .

Fast friendly service

My dad takes his car here all the time and they are always helpful

Mitchell saved the day. I had a 4-6 hour service appointment scheduled, and I messed up. After my vehicle was dropped off, I was back to work and realized I had a sales call I had to be at before lunch. Mitchell coordinated the service techs to stop work, get my car off the racks and ready to drive in 15 minutes while he personally came to pick me up. Thank you Mitchell. #bestcompanyeverDennis - ARC Contracting

Great service and just down to earth good folks

Great people a d great service.

They didnt tell me everything they knew which would have allowed me to make an informed decision.I went in for an oil leak thinking it was the valve covers. They fixed the valve covers and didnt mention anything else, just that thats what they believe it was and it should stop the leaking. My car continued to leak, not as badly but still leaking, and I went back in and they gave me a list of about 5 different things totalling about $1400 in ADDITION to the valve covers that it could be? or they knew it was? (Im still not sure). So basically I had already paid to fix what I thought was the end of the problem, but after speaking with the manager, they knew it could have been one of 6 things to begin with but thought they would start with the valve covers. They didnt tell me that. My stepdad called the store because Im young and a woman, so I felt they had already tried to take advantage and wouldnt take me seriously. The manager said he wouldnt have put anything except the timing belt leak on the quote. I can understand 2 different areas leaking at the same time, and thats a $1000 difference. This Matthews is NOT connected to the one in Plover or WI Rapids. I always had good experiences with the Plover one so I went here and the honesty and trust isnt there. I dont know cars very well but I do have enough critical thinking skills to figure that 6 different areas of my car leaking at the same time would be unlikely and luckily didnt spend $1400 fixing them.

Always friendly and fair!

Matthews has earned my trust and my business!

Have had my back on any car issues

Oil change, tires rotate and balance. Staff is always a pleasure to work with.

FAST EASY AND I WOULD RECOMMEND!

Exceptional service and friendly staff. I dont usually buy their tires ( Discount Tire is where I shop) but I assume they stand behind their warranty.So far, no complaints on any service done to my vehicle(s).This is a well trusted mechanic shop 👌

Helpful and friendly staff

My family has been going here for a long time. Always good service. Never go anywhere else for oil changes.

They are crooks. They tried to rip off a female friend today, never patronize them, EVER!!!!

I cant recommend Matthews enough. The staff is friendly, professional, honest, and thorough. When I call, they always work to get me in as soon as I need something done on my car, even if it means giving me a ride to work and picking me back up later. One the days when I have time to wait for my service to be complete, their waiting area is clean, comfortable, and accommodating. Especially whens something unexpected comes up outside of routine maintenance, the staff at Matthews always manage to a stressful experience into one that makes me feel like Im being well taken care of by people I can trust to do a good job. Ill never take my car anywhere else if I can help it.

Always incredibly flexible, timely, HONEST, and practical in their direction on my vehicles. A true partnership type of business to work with.

Good people, good service.

Got a set of tires mounted and balanced; the people I worked with were very nice, the prices were very reasonable and the whole process was quick - couldnt ask for more!

Ouch $$ but need a safe ride....and I like Matthews people nice friendly and know there business.

Service and how can we help attitude is amazing at the College Ave. shop in Appleton. Several occasions recently where people I know called multiple providers looking for help with tire and power steering problems. Everybody else told them Sorry, this is what you need and itll cost this much. Period.. On both occasions the people at Matthews immediately engaged in helpful and creative problem solving and came up with great solutions and service in record time!

Great work at a reasonable price.

Very good tire store with impressive building and reception area. Very busy and had to get fast service because of how backed up they are.

Very nice and professional. 100% better than where I had been taking my car.

Found out that I had a major puncture in a tire, dropped it off last night and they had it patched up and ready to go to morning.Friendly and helpful. Definitely will go back!

Good service

The front desk girl was not the best person to deal with customers. Dave and Brian were good. This girl checked me in but got my phone number wrong and never corrected. Overall experience is 2 star just because of rude girl on front desk to deal with customer.

I have been a customer here since 1995. They sell a huge selection of great tires and do a lot of service work on all kinds of cars and trucks. I even had a tractor tire and a wheelbarrow tire repaired/replaced here!

Dave Flunker and all the Service Advisors at Matthews Tire are fantastic. I have been a loyal customer for over 20 years. They give me my options and let me decide what is best for me. I recommend them to everyone looking for car care and tires.

Very nice people at the college ave store

They were absolutely fantastic! I wish Id gone there sooner, it would have saved me years of hassle at Firestone!